M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Im confused what your confusion is

You literally said "there is no scum thread".

But you've demonstrated you understand that there is a daychat.

So I don't care, it doesn't matter. You were just being strange for no reason, oh well.

There is no scum thread. There is a discord chat. Those are two different things. I keep making the point that its completely wild that someone would post here thinking its the discord mafia day chat as some people suggested that is what others did. Which is just CRAZY

Uh this sounds like a mafia excuse

[DemonRHK]

I like the fish voters, but am mid on the wagon.
I like the Flav wagon, but the viters on it SUUUUUUCK

This post is fischy

Like you are trying to discredit both wagons in two different ways at the same time

I mean, it's not a secret. I think Dip is still the vote. Flav is tied for my number 3 choice, but I HATE balki and Dip on there.

fish, I haven't paid enough attention to have a confident read on him. BUT, I like the voters. Specifically jamie and squigs.

[Squigs44]

For how much of a hard on Jamie had for the damo wagon, I'm a bit surprised he took the flip so well. I would have expected town Jamie to spend at least 3 posts yelling at a dead damo blaming him for being such a bad townie and that he wasted all of our time

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I like the fish voters, but am mid on the wagon.
I like the Flav wagon, but the viters on it SUUUUUUCK

This post is fischy

Like you are trying to discredit both wagons in two different ways at the same time

I mean, it's not a secret. I think Dip is still the vote. Flav is tied for my number 3 choice, but I HATE balki and Dip on there.

fish, I haven't paid enough attention to have a confident read on him. BUT, I like the voters. Specifically jamie and squigs.

True, Balki is sus

But dip is so obv town it hurts

Fair enough on the fisch wagon

[sweetandcool]

It could be some sort of deficiency, but Flavius has been rabidly focused on unimportant things this game, just grinding down on them for no reason.

First the tadpole discussion, which could have lasted a couple posts, and now this weird quibbling about scumchat.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Alr I'm caught up and have a few things to say.
Thing 1:
I have a new reads list
7x7_blank - with names - Copy - Copy.jpg
I keep going back and forth on damo's alignment though. I feel like I'm missing something.

Why do you keep moving around? Can you explain some of your allignments here? Why is no one in the "evil" category?

1. I keep moving people around because my reads change.
2. Which ones?
3. That's actually a good point. You are now Social Evil.

[Foxcastle]

33% isn't good when it's just the proportion of games that I've rolled scum. Broken clocks and all that.

(As an aside, I suspect 33% is lower than the average outcome of just guessing randomly.)

And I would be fine if your read of me was based on my actions in this game, but it's not. You talk about my actions in this game but then step back to a meta-read where I'm supposed to be behaving in a certain way (a way I've never behaved, as far as that goes).

I hope we can focus on this game from here forward. I agree with you that I don't have any kind of effective meta read on you. I believe you are generally hard to sort as either alignment.

Great, yes. I've been waiting for you to get to this point for literally years.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I like the fish voters, but am mid on the wagon.
I like the Flav wagon, but the viters on it SUUUUUUCK

This post is fischy

Like you are trying to discredit both wagons in two different ways at the same time

I mean, it's not a secret. I think Dip is still the vote. Flav is tied for my number 3 choice, but I HATE balki and Dip on there.

fish, I haven't paid enough attention to have a confident read on him. BUT, I like the voters. Specifically jamie and squigs.

Just a note here that my impression of DemonRHK in this game is very different than my impression of him in the last game we played together, where he was a Wolf. He is loose and abrasive and confused here. He's also openly antagonizing me. Thinking Town.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

I like the fish voters, but am mid on the wagon.
I like the Flav wagon, but the viters on it SUUUUUUCK

Other than those two and me, who would you like to wagon?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

This post is fischy

Like you are trying to discredit both wagons in two different ways at the same time

I mean, it's not a secret. I think Dip is still the vote. Flav is tied for my number 3 choice, but I HATE balki and Dip on there.

fish, I haven't paid enough attention to have a confident read on him. BUT, I like the voters. Specifically jamie and squigs.

True, Balki is sus

But dip is so obv town it hurts

Fair enough on the fisch wagon

Balki flashwagon?

[Ezio]

This post is fischy

Like you are trying to discredit both wagons in two different ways at the same time

I mean, it's not a secret. I think Dip is still the vote. Flav is tied for my number 3 choice, but I HATE balki and Dip on there.

fish, I haven't paid enough attention to have a confident read on him. BUT, I like the voters. Specifically jamie and squigs.

Just a note here that my impression of DemonRHK in this game is very different than my impression of him in the last game we played together, where he was a Wolf. He is loose and abrasive and confused here. He's also openly antagonizing me. Thinking Town.

yup RHK is town.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Yoyo, what's your alignment?

[Foxcastle]

I kind of like the Dip wagon. I don't think flipping Flav is correct, so I don't want to put him in the lead, but I would be interested to see what Dip does under pressure.

##VOTE DIP

[sweetandcool]

I mean, it's not a secret. I think Dip is still the vote. Flav is tied for my number 3 choice, but I HATE balki and Dip on there.

fish, I haven't paid enough attention to have a confident read on him. BUT, I like the voters. Specifically jamie and squigs.

True, Balki is sus

But dip is so obv town it hurts

Fair enough on the fisch wagon

Balki flashwagon?

Why not Fox over Balki? The hypocrisy reeks.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Yoyo, what's your alignment?

Also, I think about our hug in Washington DC all the time. Also, I think I owe you a pizza.

[Foxcastle]

True, Balki is sus

But dip is so obv town it hurts

Fair enough on the fisch wagon

Balki flashwagon?

Why not Fox over Balki? The hypocrisy reeks.

So what's gonna happen when I flip town?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

I'm going to go do something called "having a life" (I'm aware some of the people here haven't heard of it). I'll see you all around EoD.
PS. Demon is tunneling me.

[FlaviusAetius]

No Im just saying that because the mafia are able to have higher coordination this time around from pretty much out of the gate; they probably chose to give people multiple roles to play in this game. Someone will be their "lurker"(I think there's only one), someone will be their skater (minimum talking), someone will be their solver(who will do a lot of analysis), someone will be the person who just talks a lot etc

And the people who will play those roles are the people who are most comfortable playing them. You described one type of mafia and said oh well Im looking at people who are playing that kind of role and I think that is WRONG.

Have you ever seen a mafia team assign roles in this way? Have you played much forum mafia?

I played 7 games on this website maybe more Im not sure I used the statistic excel sheet, I might have played more I dont know. No I dont think Ive ever played as mafia, maybe once. No I dont think this is something mafia usually do, they dont have the opportunity too since they cant talk until N1, BUT this time is different they have a live 24/7 chat so they had the opportunity to do this highly controlled gameplay.

[sweetandcool]

Balki flashwagon?

Why not Fox over Balki? The hypocrisy reeks.

So what's gonna happen when I flip town?

At the very least it will prove you need to focus on this game instead of past games.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I'm going to go do something called "having a life" (I'm aware some of the people here haven't heard of it). I'll see you all around EoD.
PS. Demon is tunneling me.

Sick burn