M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[BunnyGo]

I think the HB wagon was town driven. Mafia don't need to rush to kill Ham, since he usually finds a way to get himself miskilled at some point regardless. Conversely, he's always suspicious, so it makes sense for town to suspect him.

Hard agree ^^^

Solid “don’t interrupt your enemy while they’re making a mistake” type situation for the mafia RE:HB

We've played together before, right?

I'm having trouble remembering you, but liking what you're putting down so far this game.

[FlaviusAetius]

Like Flaviois I don't understand you. You say it's anti town to talk about the tadpole and I literally agree which is why I'm saying anyone who talks about wanting it should die.

Like I'm beginning to think there's a language barrier here and why I asked if you lived outside of North America.

EDITED?!?!

Im from North America, Pennsylvania #1

[Dousing]

Well, Vecna and I appear to be on the same page, at least.

I like the idea of you two teaming up and solving this game.

Does anyone else find this sentiment from Sweet odd?

If Sweet continues like this I’m gonna start advocating for voting him up. EVEN IF he is a town, if he can get sheeped this easily he might as well just be mafia.

[Dousing]

We've played together before, right?

I'm having trouble remembering you, but liking what you're putting down so far this game.

Yeah we did, but it was quite a while ago.

Most likely you remember me when you made me switch my vote from Eden to KoalaAttack: http://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?p=337604#p337604

[Dousing]

I'm just confused now. If Vecna votes someone reasonable that is not damo I think I will sheep.

This at least I can agree with. I trust Vecna here.

@sweet and Dip:

Why did you trust Vecna?

Just so they don’t miss this question

Why do yall trust Vecna?

[Dousing]

This at least I can agree with. I trust Vecna here.

@sweet and Dip:

Why did you trust Vecna?

Just so they don’t miss this question

Why do yall trust Vecna?

This question might not actually be fair because Vecna reads town to me. Looking through their posts they seem rather organic in their thinking and asking pretty good questions. + they’re low on the shitposting count which is nice.

[Dousing]

Vecna reads town to me.

*Vecna reads town to me as well.

[ghug]

I think the HB wagon was town driven. Mafia don't need to rush to kill Ham, since he usually finds a way to get himself miskilled at some point regardless. Conversely, he's always suspicious, so it makes sense for town to suspect him.

This game is too fucking large and there's the tadpole in play so I'm not going to really try to solve until D4 or so, but I do think Dip and Flavius are looking good. Flum feels very meh. We should kill Ezio, though a Vig should be given the opportunity to do that themselves first because it's a longstanding webDip tradition.

Why the Ezio kill?

1. It's a meme that he gets shot.
2. He's scum.

In that order.

[dargorygel]

##GM NOTE

D SHARP.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Idk, Vecna seemed very levelheaded in the midst of Jamiet and HB.
And yes, this is more intuition than evidence. I'm not proving Vecna is town. I'm just explaining why Vecna seemed like town to me.

PS. Fluminator

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

I think the HB wagon was town driven. Mafia don't need to rush to kill Ham, since he usually finds a way to get himself miskilled at some point regardless. Conversely, he's always suspicious, so it makes sense for town to suspect him.

This game is too fucking large and there's the tadpole in play so I'm not going to really try to solve until D4 or so, but I do think Dip and Flavius are looking good. Flum feels very meh. We should kill Ezio, though a Vig should be given the opportunity to do that themselves first because it's a longstanding webDip tradition.

Why the Ezio kill?

1. It's a meme that he gets shot.
2. He's scum.

In that order.

Are you trolling me?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

@Foxcastle when I said I'm bad at sheets I meant I'm REALLY bad at sheets. How do I display the possible scumteams?

[BunnyGo]

Sorry so I’m caught up. I couldn’t follow all of the Brian stuff but appeared to me he was town just not catching up which I think a few people are in that boat. I mentioned will before because he reached out to me for being new which I appreciate but also felt like a way for him to get in my good graces as a scum. Let’s not forget scum could be trying to frame the people on the Brian bandwagon and start coasting so maybe one or two in the bunch that voted him but I’d look more towards one of the other speedwagons for most of the scum.

Which players are you having the hardest trouble telling apart?

Which players have you not noticed/registered/remembered anything about?

Which players do you vibe the most with (either in reads/content or just tone/posting style)?

[sweetandcool]

I think the HB wagon was town driven. Mafia don't need to rush to kill Ham, since he usually finds a way to get himself miskilled at some point regardless. Conversely, he's always suspicious, so it makes sense for town to suspect him.

This game is too fucking large and there's the tadpole in play so I'm not going to really try to solve until D4 or so, but I do think Dip and Flavius are looking good. Flum feels very meh. We should kill Ezio, though a Vig should be given the opportunity to do that themselves first because it's a longstanding webDip tradition.

Opinion on the fisch wagon? It never felt serious, but it actually was in contention almost the entire phase.

[BunnyGo]

We've played together before, right?

I'm having trouble remembering you, but liking what you're putting down so far this game.

Yeah we did, but it was quite a while ago.

Most likely you remember me when you made me switch my vote from Eden to KoalaAttack: http://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?p=337604#p337604

You're confusing me with snowy?!

I'll take it!

[ghug]

I think the HB wagon was town driven. Mafia don't need to rush to kill Ham, since he usually finds a way to get himself miskilled at some point regardless. Conversely, he's always suspicious, so it makes sense for town to suspect him.

This game is too fucking large and there's the tadpole in play so I'm not going to really try to solve until D4 or so, but I do think Dip and Flavius are looking good. Flum feels very meh. We should kill Ezio, though a Vig should be given the opportunity to do that themselves first because it's a longstanding webDip tradition.

Opinion on the fisch wagon? It never felt serious, but it actually was in contention almost the entire phase.

Seems like a fine kill, especially if what you say is true, but I haven't analyzed closely.

[sweetandcool]

I'm just confused now. If Vecna votes someone reasonable that is not damo I think I will sheep.

This at least I can agree with. I trust Vecna here.

@sweet and Dip:

Why did you trust Vecna?

I don't know if Vecna has ever realized this, but I am practically on board with all of his takes when we are Town. Vecna must be Town this game because almost everything he says so far makes sense to me.

[Col7by]

Sorry so I’m caught up. I couldn’t follow all of the Brian stuff but appeared to me he was town just not catching up which I think a few people are in that boat. I mentioned will before because he reached out to me for being new which I appreciate but also felt like a way for him to get in my good graces as a scum. Let’s not forget scum could be trying to frame the people on the Brian bandwagon and start coasting so maybe one or two in the bunch that voted him but I’d look more towards one of the other speedwagons for most of the scum.

Which players are you having the hardest trouble telling apart?

Which players have you not noticed/registered/remembered anything about?

Which players do you vibe the most with (either in reads/content or just tone/posting style)?

Flumintor and flav then Damon and demon all have similar names.

Sweetandcool hasn’t really resonated with me in any way even I’ve seen their name come up as well as fisch. Others of course but for ones commonly brought up those two.

I feel solid with the first I shared comments with earlier which were flav and demon or Damon whichever one I talked with

[sweetandcool]

Well, Vecna and I appear to be on the same page, at least.

I like the idea of you two teaming up and solving this game.

Does anyone else find this sentiment from Sweet odd?

If Sweet continues like this I’m gonna start advocating for voting him up. EVEN IF he is a town, if he can get sheeped this easily he might as well just be mafia.

Vecna and ghug are in my eyes the two best solvers we have. So if either or both of them are town, and given ghug expressing approval of Vecna's read of the gamestate, then I think them teaming up would be a dream team type of situation.

I think normally they are at odds? So normally a team up is not plausible.

[Foxcastle]

@Foxcastle when I said I'm bad at sheets I meant I'm REALLY bad at sheets. How do I display the possible scumteams?

I do it in the first N columns, so 5 in this case, A-E. You just work through the list. So row 1 is: Chaqa, King, Will, Jamie, Bona and then you iterate through the rest of the names in the last slot, and so forth. It can take some time, but with HB out, it cuts out like 12,000 rows that you have to do, so that helps make it easier.