M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[BunnyGo]

Bunny, can you post a reads list? Get ChatGPT to make it D&D-like if you must

He already did!

Yea but that was like 20 pages ago. A bunch happened since then.

You've got to be f***ing kidding me. Are you serious?!

You think the vibe reads list changes THAT MUCH when it's a speed read like this and I'm catching up while at work?

Guess what....my vibes are basically the same, but I have no clue what the f*** you're thinking.

Still haven't even read how EOD went down. I only posted that last minute switch back to HamBone when I saw my 3-4 options and nothing else caught up.

[BunnyGo]

Can't tell if Dip and I just see the world differently due to playstyle or if my tinfoil Dip and Ghug scumteam is true. Either way it would take a lot for me to day 1 vote for such an active player. They'll continue to incriminate themselves if they actually are scum

That tinfoil is interesting.

This isn't the scum!Dip I remember though. This Dip seems....confused and wanting to DO something, but has no idea how.

[ghug]

Considering there's hasn't been a single argument for me being scum yet outside "I might be lying about x", it makes me think this might be coordination to protect Brian

Is there serious noise about you? You’re not in top wagons

Paranoid Flum

[ghug]

the quoted post literally talks about ghug. wtf u on about

Ok but its still vague you cant just say someone feels different without explaining those little things. If you saw something I didnt, we need those little things to build a case against someone, and then I say whoever has the biggest case is who we should go for(obv)

if you only kill the ghugs of this world based on a case with solid reasoning, scum wins every game.

Aww

[ghug]

Trying to catch up in the little bit of time I have free. This makes me think HB is town. Seems too sloppy to be scum.

Oh, that's interesting, I missed this before. I would actually say this catch by Jamie is a scum point for HB. It suggests the lists were prefabricated and re-arranged and something got missed in the spellcheck.

YOOOOOO THIS IS A SCUMSLIP BY HB

Is Flavius powerwolfy as scum or is he just town here?

[BunnyGo]

We need to consolidate. Only half of the players are voting for the top three wagons, total. All the 1-vote wagons (kotp included because he's currently voting himself) need to go. And NO TYING.

Found one boys!

[BunnyGo]

Yo, peeps

HOUR LEFT

SINGLES NEED TO MINGLE

Oooh...did they coordinate this in scum chat?

[ghug]

##VOTE worcej

My guts are jiggling in this direction.

Town points.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Yo, peeps

HOUR LEFT

SINGLES NEED TO MINGLE

Oooh...did they coordinate this in scum chat?

We need to consolidate. Only half of the players are voting for the top three wagons, total. All the 1-vote wagons (kotp included because he's currently voting himself) need to go. And NO TYING.

Found one boys!

I don't get it. Me and Demon said the same thing and therefore we're both scum?

[ghug]

I'm just confused now. If Vecna votes someone reasonable that is not damo I think I will sheep.

Gross.

[ghug]

Where's ghug and Vecna telling us these wagons are stupid and leading us to the correct vote?

im not sure whether the damo / HB wagon are stupid.

They might be. But I do feel theres enough reason to be voting there.

Flum / D&W / Flavius would all be atrocious wagons imo.

I feel like you. None of the juicy stuff I want to actually kill it on the table.

I STRONGLY feel bona is not getting anywhere near enough pressure. slot has been completely vapid.

I wouldnt mind S&C being an option

I always applaud a Chaqa wagon, and he's been awfully quiet (probably so he can N1 me again as he always does before I get a read on him )

Well, Vecna and I appear to be on the same page, at least.

[BunnyGo]

Hmmm why do I get the feeling that mafia is very happy with the current wagons? Maybe it's Dip telling everyone to consolidate

Squigs saying what I'm thinking...my man...

[FlaviusAetius]

Oh, that's interesting, I missed this before. I would actually say this catch by Jamie is a scum point for HB. It suggests the lists were prefabricated and re-arranged and something got missed in the spellcheck.

YOOOOOO THIS IS A SCUMSLIP BY HB

Is Flavius powerwolfy as scum or is he just town here?

I flipped real quick on this one so just a town

[BunnyGo]

Yo, peeps

HOUR LEFT

SINGLES NEED TO MINGLE

Oooh...did they coordinate this in scum chat?

We need to consolidate. Only half of the players are voting for the top three wagons, total. All the 1-vote wagons (kotp included because he's currently voting himself) need to go. And NO TYING.

Found one boys!

I don't get it. Me and Demon said the same thing and therefore we're both scum?

Yes, you said the same very scummy thing within moments of each other. After generally not being towny in addition.

[ghug]

Please Hold



Here is a pleasant lava field to calm your nerves

That looks surprisingly similar to the one from Honor Among Thieves in that one scene in the Underdark...

Very bad form, Dip.

[ghug]

I got it wrong. So what?

I'll have further opinion after a catchup but there are v few in my towngroup.

nk will be ghug or Vecna

see ya tomorrow

noone is killing this instance of Ghug N1 lol.

Chaqa will do his usual

You killed me last game lol.

[aarodactyl]

If you are going to post analysis, do it at the last possible moment of N1 that way mafia cant change anything based on your analysis and we still have it in case you die

Strategizing what to do during the night though is not a bad idea, and I still think that should be laid at damo...leaving such unresolved stuff at D1 will not be good for us to solve things. Damo will always be a target with whatever strategy he is attempting at

"Don't talk about the game for half the game."

The fuckers have a daychat ya? Not too much point in being super quiet imo.

Im not saying we shouldnt talk Im just saying things that would change who they kill at night, that kind of stuff shouldnt be talked about, until its too late for them to change it

I think this is true if someone has a hard clear. I don’t think that’s possible at this point. So essentially it’s a question of whether you want the mafia to have more info or less info on people vibe reads. And I don’t think that’s a clear answer to that

[ghug]

Hmm. Does a PR kill Demon tonight and we wagon Damo tomorrow, or does a PR kill Damo tonight and we wagon Demon tomorrow? So many options...

Why are you so confident about Demon?

[BunnyGo]

Like Flaviois I don't understand you. You say it's anti town to talk about the tadpole and I literally agree which is why I'm saying anyone who talks about wanting it should die.

Like I'm beginning to think there's a language barrier here and why I asked if you lived outside of North America.

EDITED?!?!

[aarodactyl]

Like Flaviois I don't understand you. You say it's anti town to talk about the tadpole and I literally agree which is why I'm saying anyone who talks about wanting it should die.

Like I'm beginning to think there's a language barrier here and why I asked if you lived outside of North America.

EDITED?!?!

He got scolded already