M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[DemonRHK]

Anyway. Flava Flav over there came off odd. Trying to use THE CAPS to make things feel MORE important. Ya know when people just keep repeating things louder and LOUDER thinking it makes them more right? Yea that.

Flum, on a one round glance parked on Ham 6 hours out and didn't move. No likey.

I mentioned someone, Dip and war I think, pre-emptively laying the groundwork for a HB town flip like 8 hours ago. Then someone discover-wagoned him into the lead and he never fell below a tie. Hold on. Nevermine it was an if red.

Anyway. Why haven't we ever had a proper PbP game? I know brains has tried a few ties.

[damo666]

Damo. Hello.

Please discuss:

1) Why you thought it was "OBVIOUS" that Hamilton Brian was scum?
2) Why you repeatedly refused to explain why you thought this?

1) His posts
2) I did by referring to his posts

WHAT ABOUT HIS FUCKING POSTS?

JESUS STOP THIS TROLLING AND FUCKING COMMUNICATE.

I would strongly advise you not to shout at me.

[Vecna]

This is a strange reaction to a town death.

I’m scum.

Since everyone beat me to saying Demon is scum, I'll change it to lets kill foodcoats tomorrow

or how about lets sheep foodcoats tomorrow. After reading his fingerpointing at worcej while eod was processing I had this "this makes sense" feeling.

[Fluminator]

Well, that sucks. HB voters lookin kinda sus. Really sus. sus +1 if you will.

There were plenty of competitive counterwagons.

Let's kill Demon tomorrow

Why? Its true, if damo is mafia then obv mafia tried to save HB, Demon's right for pointing that out

It's much easier to be right and say "I told you so" when you're mafia. He said that with a little too much enthusiasm.

[damo666]

It's not the fact that you were "wrong".

It is the manner you went about it.

You mean with strong conviction as opposed to hedgy wishy-washy crap?

Apparently strong conviction about nothing.

Wrong. Merely misplaced.

[DemonRHK]

Yo multiple people I sus want me dead leggo!

That is how you know you are playing the game right, regardless of if you are actually right.

[Kakarroto]

hmm ... do you agree with the names I removed from the list? Would you have removed someone else there (well, I guess your own name, but, other than that)? With whom would you have changed your name instead, if you totally agree with the names I had removed?

Again, let's please not tell mafia who would accept a tadpole.

why do you think the names I removed are people I think would not accept a tadpole?

so, I tried to calm down going back and looking, in the far small possibility you are onto something and not just make stuff up, and this is the only other time in the next five posts I even mention tadpoles.

This is what you had said:

Fluminator suggested somone made a list of general preferences, and you then suggested everyone revealed their preferences for this particular setup

it just doesn't represent what I did. You didn't bother to go back and point out that I, indeed, spoke of tadpoles in a post other than mirroring back flum, but you still grossly misrepresent of what I did here.

I asked this question to inquire your opinion about those players, I was offput by why you focus on the tadpoles when I was talking about my stuff of how to come to the names putting out of my random dice roll for the vote. I NEVER, EVER, IN THIS WHOLE GAME put forth the incent for everyone to claim and share their thoughts on tadpole targets. Yet you keep harbouring and nourishing the thoughts I did so. You failed to provide any evidence for your reasoning, and you ignore any evidence against your reasoning.

At this point, I think there is no way we can allow you to proceed in this game, and we should vote you out at the earliest possible point. You are just a net negative for town, whatever your alignment is, and it resembles very closely your style when we were both mafia together. If I didn't knew I was town this game, with all this I would suspect myself of being mafia too.

[damo666]

I suspect no scum have posted since EOD

[sweetandcool]

If anyone hast he ability as a PR to kill damo, DO IT

[Vecna]

anyways, squigs is a prime NK candidate as well, and might warrant more saving over me. Im fine enjoying my vacation without having to live on webdip.

[sweetandcool]

This is probably not the best time, but I teamsolve sweet, ghug, (either damo or HB), food, and Kak.

If serious, this may well be the most hilarious post of the game.

[Col7by]

Sorry so I’m caught up. I couldn’t follow all of the Brian stuff but appeared to me he was town just not catching up which I think a few people are in that boat. I mentioned will before because he reached out to me for being new which I appreciate but also felt like a way for him to get in my good graces as a scum. Let’s not forget scum could be trying to frame the people on the Brian bandwagon and start coasting so maybe one or two in the bunch that voted him but I’d look more towards one of the other speedwagons for most of the scum.

[Fluminator]

If there's one thing I'm good at, it's stirring up discussion in the shitpost phase if people are still talking about it after the first miskill.

[Vecna]

I suspect no scum have posted since EOD

while i like this post, it seems unlikely with 12 non-gm people posting during the night so far.

[Vecna]

did ghug excuse himself for missing eod somewhere?

I cant for the life of me remember an eod without him present lol

[Squigs44]

My new tin foil is BunnyGo and Flum scum pair, maybe I'll do some tin foil deep dives tonight

Ive really liked Bunnies content so far, but at the back of my head keeps playing that little voice that says "when bunny makes too much sense, he is scum".

I was looking at vote interactions

[Fluminator]

I’m scum.

Since everyone beat me to saying Demon is scum, I'll change it to lets kill foodcoats tomorrow

or how about lets sheep foodcoats tomorrow. After reading his fingerpointing at worcej while eod was processing I had this "this makes sense" feeling.

Help me with Worcej,

Every game I feel like his playstyle is eternally catching up to the game, and he rarely interacts in the moment. He does this as town and scum and makes it very hard for me to read. I'll re-read him but I'm interested in your scum read on him.

[Vecna]

at any rate, its a breath of fresh air having you back again squigs.

(in before balki starts charging into the thread coming after my head for being nice again)

[Squigs44]

Why was Demon not a wagon if so many people want him voted out tomorrow?

[Vecna]

Since everyone beat me to saying Demon is scum, I'll change it to lets kill foodcoats tomorrow

or how about lets sheep foodcoats tomorrow. After reading his fingerpointing at worcej while eod was processing I had this "this makes sense" feeling.

Help me with Worcej,

Every game I feel like his playstyle is eternally catching up to the game, and he rarely interacts in the moment. He does this as town and scum and makes it very hard for me to read. I'll re-read him but I'm interested in your scum read on him.

its very vibey and icky if I have to describe it.

It just felt like he was in there doing the bare minimum, while still tryharding to appear towny if that makes sense.

The last few games he's just been unapologetically absent, in a DEAL WITH IT and fu if u vote me type of way.

I might be completely wrong here.