M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[Hamilton Brian]

I've come to the conclusion that damo wagon isn't great. Ham wagon is reasonable but I am sick of it.

I won't pretend that Flume wagon is great in that there is a serious case, but my gut says he is the best wagon right now.

Dip wagon would probably be good, but there is a chance he is Town. Idk, think that would be a good competitive wagon.

There's time for a Dip wagon.

##Vote DiplomacyAndWarfare

[Hamilton Brian]

Just need a lot of movement in a hurry. LOL.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Guys I have been open and honest that my Flum vote was based off of one thing and his tadpole stuff, and he's doubled and tripled down on it, but that cant be it; I was HOPING to find more stuff against this man but I dont have anything. The HB wagon is just silliness but the damo wagon? Im not sure its not nothing

would you think that D&W towncoring him for this while putting the blame of 'this tadpole stuff' on me makes Flum more likely mafia or less? Would you think D&W has more likelyhood of mafia by doing this?

Let's settle this. Fluminator made the following post:

Normally my style is to shitpost and spam at the beginning, but with 26 players and 24 hour phases we all have to be on better behaviour now. These first few days are going to be hell.

Hello to all the newer players I haven’t met yet but I’m not going to be able to get to know you in time lol.

Since 24 hours makes this even more of a gong show the first vote will likely be random so I’ll throw out a couple names for consideration to murder to get things started.
1. FlaviusAetius – Aetius has some epically cool moments, but for the most part he was overrated. Although it’s true his assassination triggered the beginning of the end of Rome, he shoulders a lot of the blame removing all other competent people in the first place so Rome had to rely on him. I was always more of a Stilicho fan.
2. Col7by – I don’t know how to say his name so it will be more tiring to read.
3. Dowsing – I really don’t think Dowsing rods are a good way to find mafia so he may be a liability for town either way.

Alternatively we kill whoever is at risk for accepting recruitment. Are there any players here that are known to prefer playing scum over town?

Most of which is fine. The question at the end might have led to some minor leans on whether or not people would accept recruitment, but not much. You responded:

Normally my style is to shitpost and spam at the beginning, but with 26 players and 24 hour phases we all have to be on better behaviour now. These first few days are going to be hell.

Hello to all the newer players I haven’t met yet but I’m not going to be able to get to know you in time lol.

Since 24 hours makes this even more of a gong show the first vote will likely be random so I’ll throw out a couple names for consideration to murder to get things started.
1. FlaviusAetius – Aetius has some epically cool moments, but for the most part he was overrated. Although it’s true his assassination triggered the beginning of the end of Rome, he shoulders a lot of the blame removing all other competent people in the first place so Rome had to rely on him. I was always more of a Stilicho fan.
2. Col7by – I don’t know how to say his name so it will be more tiring to read.
3. Dowsing – I really don’t think Dowsing rods are a good way to find mafia so he may be a liability for town either way.

Alternatively we kill whoever is at risk for accepting recruitment. Are there any players here that are known to prefer playing scum over town?

I think there are some players that fit that criteria. I would like to ask though, how about you? Would you accept a tadpole, if given to you? Would you like to play mafia this game?

The major problem with this response is that you ask about specifically playing mafia this game. General info about whether players prefer scum isn't very important one way or another, but people saying whether they would accept recruitment in this game give mafia the exact info they need.

So Fluminator came up with a vaguely bad idea, then you extrapolated it to the most scum-helping possiblity.

[Vecna]

##vote Flavius

Get his teammate Ham 2m.

why vote the vanity wagon over the guy thats an actual contender?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

I actually kind of like the FlaviusAetius wagon.
##VOTE FLAVIUSAETIUS

[Fluminator]

Oh I forgot about my opening shitpost. Fair enough.

[DemonRHK]

I don't want HB to die just because I've seen his ass get D1d so much recently.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

I don't want HB to die just because I've seen his ass get D1d so much recently.

Fluminator wagon is pretty bad though.

[Kakarroto]

Second, note kotp agreeing with me and rejecting your scum-benefitting 'lets all reveal if we would accept a tadpole' proposal

STOP LYING ABOUT THAT! I NEVER SAID THAT! I POINTED THAT OUT WITH BACKUP SOURCES AND YOU REFUSE TO ACCEPT REALITY! YOU ARE EITHER JUST AWFULLY BAD TOWN OR MAFIA, AND THUS SHOULD BE VOTED OUT!!!

##vote DiplomacyandWarfare

[Vecna]

I don’t like that Squiggs had the only case on damo and drew 2 other voters…

I find the fact that you want cases on D1 to be sus. You know better than that. Hmm.

scumlean on worcej. worcej and damo not scum together.

I think this is the first game ever im liking foodcoats on d1.

maybe im just forgetting. I like foodcoats.

[DemonRHK]

Let's go to ##Vote FlaviusAetius

His posts don't make sense and they ticket me in a bad ND-like way

[foodcoats]

I don't want HB to die just because I've seen his ass get D1d so much recently.

Did you have to verify your age to see those videos, or...?

[Squigs44]

Flipping HB would probably give us the most info at the moment, and while i didn't really buy into the initial wagon, I haven't been all that impressed with his recent posts either.
Just the one response where he said Dip asked him a loaded question feels townie for some reason. I'm blinded by this tinfoil theory

[foodcoats]

I don’t like that Squiggs had the only case on damo and drew 2 other voters…

I find the fact that you want cases on D1 to be sus. You know better than that. Hmm.

scumlean on worcej. worcej and damo not scum together.

I think this is the first game ever im liking foodcoats on d1.

maybe im just forgetting. I like foodcoats.

Vote worcej with me?

If you don't you're a doo doo poo poo dumb head.

[FlaviusAetius]

##vote Flavius

Get his teammate Ham 2m.

why vote the vanity wagon over the guy thats an actual contender?

trueee, ive been back and forth over these guys just like everyone else has Im missing like 12 pages of knowledge on how the wagon formed on damo, this was just me going through the posts and going over the damo posts, I determined there wasnt enough time, and enough people are saying the HB wagn doesnt make sense and anything I have seen from him hasnt been scummy. So people chose that he is mafia based off of him defending himself, and not what he said before...which isn't great

[foodcoats]

##VOTE worcej

My guts are jiggling in this direction.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Second, note kotp agreeing with me and rejecting your scum-benefitting 'lets all reveal if we would accept a tadpole' proposal

STOP LYING ABOUT THAT! I NEVER SAID THAT! I POINTED THAT OUT WITH BACKUP SOURCES AND YOU REFUSE TO ACCEPT REALITY! YOU ARE EITHER JUST AWFULLY BAD TOWN OR MAFIA, AND THUS SHOULD BE VOTED OUT!!!

##vote DiplomacyandWarfare

Did you miss my post debunking this nonsense? Fluminator suggested somone made a list of general preferences, and you then suggested everyone revealed their preferences for this particular setup

[FlaviusAetius]

I actually kind of like the FlaviusAetius wagon.
##VOTE FLAVIUSAETIUS

##vote diplomacyandwarfare

[Vecna]

Strong dislike for Flum wagon.

##vote ham

agreed

[Vecna]

I actually kind of like the FlaviusAetius wagon.
##VOTE FLAVIUSAETIUS

##vote diplomacyandwarfare

even stronger dislike for this wagon