M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[Squigs44]

Hmmm why do I get the feeling that mafia is very happy with the current wagons? Maybe it's Dip telling everyone to consolidate

[damo666]

I understand there are 5 town PR roles and 3 mafia PR roles, but what's the breakdown of town:mafia? I didn't see that written on the first game post from brain.

Bad bluff

[Squigs44]

will switch yo lfischl if necessary obviously.

I got 5 mins if anyone wants to repeat unanswered qs.

I would like to know why you thought Jamie hard claiming was reasonable, but most other people seem not to care about that

[sweetandcool]

will switch yo lfischl if necessary obviously.

I got 5 mins if anyone wants to repeat unanswered qs.

Explain why you INITIALLY voted for HamiltonBrian without telling me to do my own research, he hasnt done anything majorly bad but you voted for him and TRIPLED DOWN on it!

Agreed. Damo, please elaborate, we'll listen, promise.

[FlaviusAetius]

I understand there are 5 town PR roles and 3 mafia PR roles, but what's the breakdown of town:mafia? I didn't see that written on the first game post from brain.

Bad bluff

You said you would answer the questions so answer it, I want to know why you initially chose to go after HamiltonBrian; if you LITERALLY just saw one of the only things that made HamiltonBrian sus rn then I suspect you had ZERO reason for it, and just wanted to vote someone, which begs the question; WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT

[damo666]

will switch yo lfischl if necessary obviously.

I got 5 mins if anyone wants to repeat unanswered qs.

Explain why you INITIALLY voted for HamiltonBrian without telling me to do my own research, he hasnt done anything majorly bad but you voted for him and TRIPLED DOWN on it!

He hasn't made many posts. I invite you to read and decide. I think it's it's screamingly obvious.

[damo666]

I understand there are 5 town PR roles and 3 mafia PR roles, but what's the breakdown of town:mafia? I didn't see that written on the first game post from brain.

Its been said a few times that there are 5 maf

Because Will knows this to be absolutely true because they are mafia?

its only a matter of time before mafia starts instructing their players to ask about the number of scum now. It wouldnt even surprise me if thats exactly what just happened to HB.

Since when is our boy HB actually concerned about the setup?

Vecna scumming to scatter potential miskills?

Panics

[Jamiet99uk]

What's flum's question to me again?

And what question are you referring to, Dip?

THIS QUESTION:

Why aren't you voting damo then?

Why should I vote damo?

If you think mafia are jumping on you to save Damo, then you think Damo is scum right?

[Foxcastle]

Hmmm why do I get the feeling that mafia is very happy with the current wagons? Maybe it's Dip telling everyone to consolidate

I also don’t like the lack of movement.

[sweetandcool]

##VOTE damo

If you have no reason other than vibes then fine. But I'm sick of not even trying to justify it.

[damo666]

That full-time mafia chat is going to be a PITA.

I wonder if a way around it is to consolidate in like 3, 4, 5 key blocs...who do you resonate as town with, then vote around that, making sure to avoid the tie.

But then the "vote once"" but you can also Unvote and still be in compliance is CAF.

Is this direceted at town or scummates???

[Foxcastle]

I don’t think it’s damo.

##vote ham

[sweetandcool]

##VOTE Flum

Don't want the wagon to die.

[Jamiet99uk]

So.

3.5, 4th, or 5th?

I'm one of the few fans of 4th myself.

2nd Edition for life, mate.

[FlaviusAetius]

Here's my theory: damo is town and the wagon on him contains scum trying to stop the Hamilton wagon.

If you disagree, please quote something scummy damo has said and explain how that post is scummy.

What'd change if you look at it like HB is town and the wagon on him contains scum?

It seems like a lot of energy to openly claim the belief the damo wagon is town and HB's isn't.

Im beginning to think both HB and Damo are both not mafia. Damo needs to explain himself though I wont stand for it that he just randomly votes someone out of the blue and refuses to explain himself townies would give a reason, throwing votes out like that is unacceptable

[FlaviusAetius]

will switch yo lfischl if necessary obviously.

I got 5 mins if anyone wants to repeat unanswered qs.

Explain why you INITIALLY voted for HamiltonBrian without telling me to do my own research, he hasnt done anything majorly bad but you voted for him and TRIPLED DOWN on it!

He hasn't made many posts. I invite you to read and decide. I think it's it's screamingly obvious.

you realize you are being ridiculous right now right? you dont have a reason so you are double down on this WHY. Just admit it, you made a mistake, I just want the reasoning behind why you would do this, because I cant think of ANYTHING that has ANYTING to do with being a townie

[aarodactyl]

But I do agree about Flum; feels like they've been picking at the low-hanging fruit others are lobbing out there.

Vote Flum, let's do it!

We are running out of time, as I go back Im trying to find stuff about Flum but I havent found anything but this one thing we found on him I know someone said we dont have a lot to work off on D1 but we are urnning out of time, I dont want my vote to be useless, Im trying to decid ebetween Ham and Damo right now if this Flum thing doesnt work out and apparently fish now? MAN I just want to figure out what the cases are for these people

Oh you ignored my question because you don’t have a reason to vote flum? Then why haven’t you moved yet?

##vote flavius

[Jamiet99uk]

I am a simple man. I am not executing some kind of convoluted strategy.

So you confirm that you revealed because you felt pressured? I just find it extremely strange that you felt that much pressure at that point, and that your remedy was to hard claim instead of addressing the requests/critiques made of you

Cmon jamie you had to have some kind of thought process for being the FIRST person to claim ANYTHING. Like?? This is insane that you just did it on a WHIM

I claimed because I was top wagon and it was a stupid wagon. I only claimed Vanilla Peasant anyway. Sue me.

[foodcoats]

So.

3.5, 4th, or 5th?

I'm one of the few fans of 4th myself.

2nd Edition for life, mate.

Fuckin' right on, Jamie.

[DemonRHK]

The fish is slowing down.

How bout a ##Vote flum to spice some stuff up? I like 3 D1 wagons.