M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[aarodactyl]

Does anyone who's played with Kak before know if he does this as town? (Preparing multiple posts before sending them all together)
I know it would be a scum tell for me if I did that. As town I fire from the hip.

I’ve played with town kak before and he sends a lot of long posts. I can’t remember if them being consecutive is something that’s happened but it didn’t seem unusual to me.

[FlaviusAetius]

I understand there are 5 town PR roles and 3 mafia PR roles, but what's the breakdown of town:mafia? I didn't see that written on the first game post from brain.

O h l o o k a n o t.h e r t o w.n s l i p.

ghug powerwolfing yet again

ADVOCATING and POINTING OUT when someone does a scumslip is NOT powerwolfing!!

[lfischl]

Does anyone who's played with Kak before know if he does this as town? (Preparing multiple posts before sending them all together)
I know it would be a scum tell for me if I did that. As town I fire from the hip.

I’ve played with town kak before and he sends a lot of long posts. I can’t remember if them being consecutive is something that’s happened but it didn’t seem unusual to me.

he always sends a lot of long posts iirc, I remember him as town in a lot of them but not 100% sure

[aarodactyl]

Does anyone who's played with Kak before know if he does this as town? (Preparing multiple posts before sending them all together)
I know it would be a scum tell for me if I did that. As town I fire from the hip.

I’ve played with town kak before and he sends a lot of long posts. I can’t remember if them being consecutive is something that’s happened but it didn’t seem unusual to me.

he always sends a lot of long posts iirc, I remember him as town in a lot of them but not 100% sure

It feels like it’s NAI to me. Which I understand is not that helpful for this situation.

[Vecna]

Vague. Great, and why even reply to something and that not comment on anything being said. This is so random, and seems like you are trying to take people off of Bunny, if you think he isnt mafia then just say it

the quoted post literally talks about ghug. wtf u on about

Ok but its still vague you cant just say someone feels different without explaining those little things. If you saw something I didnt, we need those little things to build a case against someone, and then I say whoever has the biggest case is who we should go for(obv)

if you only kill the ghugs of this world based on a case with solid reasoning, scum wins every game.

[Kakarroto]

Alr I'm caught up on the thread again.
New alignment chart:
7x7_blank - with names - Copy.jpg
A few notes:
ghug feels like he is powerwolfing
Bunny seems to be playing as town but is doing it an extremely messy fashion (ChatGPT), so he is Anarchic Good
Hamilton has not made a single good post this game
Fluminator

I'm also going to ##VOTE HAMILTONBRIAN

please explain your read on lfischl in more detail

I also want your explanation for the placement of dargo, please.

And if you be so kind and have still time for it, please tell me the difference between Hamilton and kotp.

I forgot why I townread lfischl. 26 people and a very complex setup. It's hard to remember everything.
Dargorygel is lawful exalted because he's a moderator and Co-GM
Kotp was doing useful contributing before the NoKill arc. Hamilton didn't do anything useful until he became a major wagon, and now he's just reacting to the wagon on him. In other words, kotp has done some good stuff and questionable stuff. Ham's only done questionable stuff.
My townread on kotp has a bit of personal intuition thrown in. My HB scumread, however, has a very provable point: Ham has done no analysis this game that is not specifically biased for and pointed towards stopping his wagon.

oh boy, where to begin?

well at least you didn't forget that dargo was just a gm

now this:

Kotp was doing useful contributing before the NoKill arc

these are all kotp posts before:

Howdy folks! I dunno what my gimmick is going to be this game, but whatevs, yo! Let's get this show on the road! lock in, buckle your seat belts, and prepare to shoot any stray Illithids you find along the way!

Again, let's please not tell mafia who would accept a tadpole.

hard agree with dipandwar here, we don't to give mafia any more advantages.

We need a magic dude or smthn

AHA! A gimmick for me to steal! rolling... a 19! Mine now! I shall not cast fireball just yet though, lol.

I say it's very bad when strange things are a foot, especially when you are only three foot tall

well since you are 3 feet, you clearly are not a strange thing. though you may very well be 3 strange things in a trench coat... but I would know nothing about that (just rolled investigation)!

##vote no kill
In such a massive game, I don't see the point in not skipping when there is not enough info. unless there is a major scum slip, or some other great realization, this is my vote for the day.

please, point out here, exactly where in your opinion Kotp is doing this useful stuff.



Brian on the other hand has provided his thoughts of his reads and shown a bit of him. Your arguments and statements don't represent the reality.


It's the same with Fluminator and me, you read him as "Absolute Exalted" and suspect me with the argument I was pushing to everyone the tadpole question, yet it was HE who did it, while I tried to mirror it to himself, to present it as the flaw it is.

I'm heavily doubting you are of a sound logic in your arguments for your classification. You either need to cleanse yourself, or you are just mafia trying to give misinformation into the game.

[FlaviusAetius]

Okay I’m 10 pages in right now and have two scum possibilities but will wait until I am done just updating everyone

I know you're new but its VERY important you let us know who you think is mafia and more importantly WHY

[aarodactyl]

I have 40 minutes before my next meeting and about 10-20 of those minutes need to be filled with work and likely not consecutive

[lfischl]

Okay I’m 10 pages in right now and have two scum possibilities but will wait until I am done just updating everyone

I know you're new but its VERY important you let us know who you think is mafia and more importantly WHY

how likely do you think it is mafia just fed him names to say?

[aarodactyl]

Okay I’m 10 pages in right now and have two scum possibilities but will wait until I am done just updating everyone

I know you're new but its VERY important you let us know who you think is mafia and more importantly WHY

Can you give a 3 sentence explanation of why you’re voting flum. It’s really hard to read this thread considering how many names I don’t recognize and how much some of you are posting

[Kakarroto]

Okay I’m 10 pages in right now and have two scum possibilities but will wait until I am done just updating everyone

I know you're new but its VERY important you let us know who you think is mafia and more importantly WHY

how likely do you think it is mafia just fed him names to say?

what is your opinion on the gamestate?

If you had a bullet right now, who would you choose to shoot? Who would you definitely spare?

[Jamiet99uk]

Rereading damo's posts via bot it seems like he's just behind. Jamiet, you said damo is repeatedly not responding to questions. Is there any evidence that he just hasn't read them yet?

Yes.

Clearly YOU have not been reading.

[brainbomb]

(Couples Therapy)
Agnes: I cant get him to talk about anything other than Baldurs gate. Its all he thinks about.

Jim: Thats not true. Just last week we went out to dinner with Kethrick and Dame Aylin and we talked about all sorts of things.

Agnes: KEVIN and AMY. Youre just lost in your own Baldurs Gate world.

Therapist: Sorry I couldn't hear you I was finishing up this battle vs a Bulette. Man the underdark is crazy.

damo666 (5) worcej Squigs44 Jamiet99uk Dousing foodcoats
lfischl (4) Kakarroto Chaqa Foxcastle DemonRHK
Hamilton Brian (4) damo666* DiplomacyandWarfare Fluminator Ezio
kingofthepirates (2) kingofthepirates BunnyGo
Fluminator (2) sweetandcool FlaviusAetius
Jamiet99uk (1) Vecna
Vecna (1) TheMadMonarch
BunnyGo (1) ghug*
FlaviusAetius (1) JustAGuyNamedWill
ghug (1) Bonatogether
JustAGuyNamedWill (1) Col7by
DiplomacyandWarfare (1) Hamilton Brian

Unvote (1) aarodactyl

lfischl has not met participation requirements

Damo is scheduled to die

[sweetandcool]

We are running out of time, as I go back Im trying to find stuff about Flum but I havent found anything but this one thing we found on him I know someone said we dont have a lot to work off on D1 but we are urnning out of time, I dont want my vote to be useless, Im trying to decid ebetween Ham and Damo right now if this Flum thing doesnt work out and apparently fish now? MAN I just want to figure out what the cases are for these people

Your principles are correct. Feel free not to "waste" your vote.

I suggest you hold out a little longer (unless you no longer feel convicted).

The Flum wagon may still take off. But not if you move right now.

why do you explicitly want me to move of lfischl now but not want Flavius to move now? Or did I misunderstand you?

Huh? I'm not following what wagon you are on, so that you are voting fisch is irrelevant to me. Would like more energy going after Flum. Do not want Flavous to move, because he is on Flum.

[FlaviusAetius]

Why are there almost 40 pages already

Time to try to catch up... you all better be making D&D references to make up for the length of this game (I'm sure Kak will, and because of that I will sheep him in case I get sidetracked)

##Vote Lfischl

Has Lfishcl even talked at this point? Such an odd vote to make I dont remember him playing any major role in the past 40 pages

[lfischl]

I know you're new but its VERY important you let us know who you think is mafia and more importantly WHY

how likely do you think it is mafia just fed him names to say?

what is your opinion on the gamestate?

If you had a bullet right now, who would you choose to shoot? Who would you definitely spare?

I'm still kind of catching up, trying to understand stuff, the amount of people makes it more confusing for me.

for the second part, I think I'd rather not do the brian wagon, and out of the leading wagons rn I think I would lean more towards flum, but I've gotta go back and re-read stuff, should be around until EOD

[damo666]

will switch yo lfischl if necessary obviously.

I got 5 mins if anyone wants to repeat unanswered qs.

[FlaviusAetius]

worcej Squigs44 Jamiet99uk DemonRHK Dousing foodcoats
At least two of the above people (currently wagoning damo) are scum.

Thats funny because I think YOU are mafia...but I agree I think thats the mafia strategy there will guranteed be a mafia on the D1 wagon that wins, if its a townie, then probably more mafia than not. If its a mafia probably maximum TWO. But more likely one. Especially with the votes being so close

[Kakarroto]

Your principles are correct. Feel free not to "waste" your vote.

I suggest you hold out a little longer (unless you no longer feel convicted).

The Flum wagon may still take off. But not if you move right now.

why do you explicitly want me to move of lfischl now but not want Flavius to move now? Or did I misunderstand you?

Huh? I'm not following what wagon you are on, so that you are voting fisch is irrelevant to me. Would like more energy going after Flum. Do not want Flavous to move, because he is on Flum.

oh, I missed that. Thought it was strange wanting me to move but not Flavius, but I didn't realized that he was on flum already. Now it makes total sense. Sorry my bad

[FlaviusAetius]

will switch yo lfischl if necessary obviously.

I got 5 mins if anyone wants to repeat unanswered qs.

Explain why you INITIALLY voted for HamiltonBrian without telling me to do my own research, he hasnt done anything majorly bad but you voted for him and TRIPLED DOWN on it!