M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[sweetandcool]

But I do agree about Flum; feels like they've been picking at the low-hanging fruit others are lobbing out there.

Vote Flum, let's do it!

[FlaviusAetius]

This game is actually the first game in quite a while where I dont feel Ghug is obv-town (not counting last for obv reasons).

Its still early ofcourse, but he's done some of the small things that give me a little reason to be worried.

Vague. Great, and why even reply to something and that not comment on anything being said. This is so random, and seems like you are trying to take people off of Bunny, if you think he isnt mafia then just say it

the quoted post literally talks about ghug. wtf u on about

Ok but its still vague you cant just say someone feels different without explaining those little things. If you saw something I didnt, we need those little things to build a case against someone, and then I say whoever has the biggest case is who we should go for(obv)

[worcej]

I don’t like that Squiggs had the only case on damo and drew 2 other voters…

[Kakarroto]

And Brian feels a bit more town here to me than usual.

There's a scumslip if I've ever read one!!!

Brian flips town, Kak can garner a bit of towniness for it.

Really, I appreciate the defense but I can't excuse my ADD/super-busy playstyle. That's for me to fix.

? I just tell my opinion of how I feel of your reactions. You not going for the pushed wagon but voting for D&W just looks to me what a town would do. If you think I'm mafia for it, well you are wrong about that.

I guess that's tunnel vision now and confirmation bias? I think that's another sign that brian is just town here.

[FlaviusAetius]

But I do agree about Flum; feels like they've been picking at the low-hanging fruit others are lobbing out there.

Vote Flum, let's do it!

We are running out of time, as I go back Im trying to find stuff about Flum but I havent found anything but this one thing we found on him I know someone said we dont have a lot to work off on D1 but we are urnning out of time, I dont want my vote to be useless, Im trying to decid ebetween Ham and Damo right now if this Flum thing doesnt work out and apparently fish now? MAN I just want to figure out what the cases are for these people

[Hamilton Brian]

And as much as I dislike Damo’s play…seems busy, lazy, distant, dismissive…I don’t think it’s mafia. I think the wagon is bonus.

[Kakarroto]

Same issue but now I have to evaluate how my joke vote on you is contributing to the lead wagon…

I know how you feel, there have been people who slapped on my early vote and I'm starting to rethink if my vote is a mistake. Especially since lfischl might be just modkilled if he doesn't vote in the next time.

I do think however with him getting this much heat it feels nice to target a known lurker, so for now lets stay and see what happens.

I am not too keen on the alternatives, though. Damo could very well be just town here, he is quite unusual, different than what he normally does, yes, but he doesn't pull me especially in either direction. Brian I don't want to be in consideration, he is usually a target of mis votes, and I myself did mistakenly vote him out as town D1 in jamies judges game. And Brian feels a bit more town here to me than usual.

I think though Flum might deserve some heat today. I don't get why he is so high in D&W's opinion, with what he mafreads myself, so maybe some scrutiny there is a good idea too.

Kak, you gotta join me on the Flum wagon. As a fellow party member I ask you for aid.

I might, and maybe I should, with your post here being number 1000, might be a sign. With the resurface of lfischl I want to see what happens there though, but stay vigilant, if I change, Flum is one of the best choices.

[Fluminator]

Considering there's hasn't been a single argument for me being scum yet outside "I might be lying about x", it makes me think this might be coordination to protect Brian

[sweetandcool]

But I do agree about Flum; feels like they've been picking at the low-hanging fruit others are lobbing out there.

Vote Flum, let's do it!

We are running out of time, as I go back Im trying to find stuff about Flum but I havent found anything but this one thing we found on him I know someone said we dont have a lot to work off on D1 but we are urnning out of time, I dont want my vote to be useless, Im trying to decid ebetween Ham and Damo right now if this Flum thing doesnt work out and apparently fish now? MAN I just want to figure out what the cases are for these people

Your principles are correct. Feel free not to "waste" your vote.

I suggest you hold out a little longer (unless you no longer feel convicted).

The Flum wagon may still take off. But not if you move right now.

[Fluminator]

I'm going to the gym, I should be back before deadline, but if not and mafia actually succeed at getting me, I trust Ghug, Aaron, and Damo will pick up how non-existent the case was and hold the correct people accountable

[worcej]

Considering there's hasn't been a single argument for me being scum yet outside "I might be lying about x", it makes me think this might be coordination to protect Brian

Is there serious noise about you? You’re not in top wagons

[aarodactyl]

Revising the earlier post as things develop.

Key town vibes: Jamie, Chaqa (hope things are alright), king (I kind of like the decision to no-kill), Monarch, worcej, bunny,

Leaning town: dousing, aaro, flum, fox, flaevius, sweet, Just, squiggs

Negative feelings: ghug, damo; foodcoats, bona, Dip, flum, vecna (moving up...I don't like the long-standing vote on jamie but there hasn't been a rush to get on a lead wagon).

Sus: Kakarroto, ilfischl,

Wait a moment.

Why do you have Fluminator listed as a townlean and a scumlean at the same time?

Trying to catch up in the little bit of time I have free. This makes me think HB is town. Seems too sloppy to be scum.

[Fluminator]

Considering there's hasn't been a single argument for me being scum yet outside "I might be lying about x", it makes me think this might be coordination to protect Brian

Is there serious noise about you? You’re not in top wagons

Kak, Brian, and Sweet are testing the waters to see if they have enough

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Alr I'm caught up on the thread again.
New alignment chart:
7x7_blank - with names - Copy.jpg
A few notes:
ghug feels like he is powerwolfing
Bunny seems to be playing as town but is doing it an extremely messy fashion (ChatGPT), so he is Anarchic Good
Hamilton has not made a single good post this game
Fluminator

I'm also going to ##VOTE HAMILTONBRIAN

please explain your read on lfischl in more detail

I also want your explanation for the placement of dargo, please.

And if you be so kind and have still time for it, please tell me the difference between Hamilton and kotp.

I forgot why I townread lfischl. 26 people and a very complex setup. It's hard to remember everything.
Dargorygel is lawful exalted because he's a moderator and Co-GM
Kotp was doing useful contributing before the NoKill arc. Hamilton didn't do anything useful until he became a major wagon, and now he's just reacting to the wagon on him. In other words, kotp has done some good stuff and questionable stuff. Ham's only done questionable stuff.
My townread on kotp has a bit of personal intuition thrown in. My HB scumread, however, has a very provable point: Ham has done no analysis this game that is not specifically biased for and pointed towards stopping his wagon.

[Kakarroto]

Vote Flum, let's do it!

We are running out of time, as I go back Im trying to find stuff about Flum but I havent found anything but this one thing we found on him I know someone said we dont have a lot to work off on D1 but we are urnning out of time, I dont want my vote to be useless, Im trying to decid ebetween Ham and Damo right now if this Flum thing doesnt work out and apparently fish now? MAN I just want to figure out what the cases are for these people

Your principles are correct. Feel free not to "waste" your vote.

I suggest you hold out a little longer (unless you no longer feel convicted).

The Flum wagon may still take off. But not if you move right now.

why do you explicitly want me to move of lfischl now but not want Flavius to move now? Or did I misunderstand you?

[kingofthepirates]

God damn, 15+ pages since I check at some point this morning… ngl I’m not reading through all that (not enough time, and not in the mood). I’m trudging through a mountain of schoolwork (1 paper, 1 presentation, 3 tests all upcoming), carrying 2 group projects, and juggling around summer class scheduling, so apologies for my lack of play (I remember seeing something that mentioned somewhere in the 30smth pages). Anyway, unless something else pops up before I finish, I’m going to go through all the votes on the bot to hunt for something to pickup.

[FlaviusAetius]

Ghugs comment doesn't even relate to anything in game

valid point. My method of finding aggressive ghug posts is basically finding ghug posts, so I guess that's my bad. Ghug is only mostly powerwolfing.

So you see ghug being blunt and that equates to "ghug is powerwolfing"?

I can't shake the feeling Dip and ghug are scum together and Dip had a TMI moment that colored his opinion of ghug, but d1 is a little early for me to tinfoil this hard

No tinfoiling is good they can talk to each other its 100% guranteed they have a master plan going on, and Dip saying gugh is powerwolfing off of simple banter is insane

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

We need to consolidate. Only half of the players are voting for the top three wagons, total. All the 1-vote wagons (kotp included because he's currently voting himself) need to go. And NO TYING.

[FlaviusAetius]

Vote Flum, let's do it!

We are running out of time, as I go back Im trying to find stuff about Flum but I havent found anything but this one thing we found on him I know someone said we dont have a lot to work off on D1 but we are urnning out of time, I dont want my vote to be useless, Im trying to decid ebetween Ham and Damo right now if this Flum thing doesnt work out and apparently fish now? MAN I just want to figure out what the cases are for these people

Your principles are correct. Feel free not to "waste" your vote.

I suggest you hold out a little longer (unless you no longer feel convicted).

The Flum wagon may still take off. But not if you move right now.

The best strategy after you vote for someone is to find any reason to take your vote off of that person, that way you dont get tunnelvisioned, if I cant find another reason to go onto Flum and no one else is going onto him we gotta move, Ill stick it out a bit longer maybe I can find something on this man

[DemonRHK]

Yo, peeps

HOUR LEFT

SINGLES NEED TO MINGLE