M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[FlaviusAetius]

What's with the quick Jamie wagon right out of the gate? That's absurd.

Vecna, Sweet, Squigs...giving you three the hairy eyeball.

Why is it absurd?

Why is any fast wagon absurd in a 24h game?

Do you think the reason of jamiet potentially faking anger is not a good one?

Why make this statement and point at all 3 people?

None of this feels like a natural towny thought.

Because its not even based on anything :facepalm: jamie being unpleasant is not indicative of ANYTHING! Not him being a mafia not him being a townie. Its just how Jamie is, the fact that so many people JUMPED on him RIGHT AWAY is what is ridiculous

[Foxcastle]

I'll be around for another 45 minutes or so but then will be on a long drive. I'll check in on mobile as I'm able.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

@HB what's your read on damo?

[sweetandcool]

He has made six posts.

Which of them "scream" scum, and why?

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

##VOTE Flum

What about my conversation, with Damo, about Hamilton, makes you scumread Fluminator?

I don't get it.

It's more about setting my vote for you down.

[BunnyGo]

dang I missed so much Im like 20 pages behind, Im gonna do a big catchup; but not my usual way, I'll only respond to very important things I guess o things that reference me. Until I get closer to the page number we are on

This is the most disappointing thing I’ve read. I was really looking coward to some Flavius catch ups.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Rereading damo's posts via bot it seems like he's just behind. Jamiet, you said damo is repeatedly not responding to questions. Is there any evidence that he just hasn't read them yet?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Rereading damo's posts via bot it seems like he's just behind. Jamiet, you said damo is repeatedly not responding to questions. Is there any evidence that he just hasn't read them yet?

That it's not that he hasn't read them yet... whatever. You know what I mean.

[Hamilton Brian]

I understand there are 5 town PR roles and 3 mafia PR roles, but what's the breakdown of town:mafia? I didn't see that written on the first game post from brain.

@HAMILTONBRIAN
When you wrote this, were you aware I (and others) had already asked the same question?

I don't think you're asking the question in good faith, similar to how you've been misrepresenting my play so far. If mafia, why would I answer with a ÿes?" It would be expected to lie. As town, of course my reply would be, "no, I didn't know you had asked the question."

I think that was my 2nd post the entire game, and look at the spread I had between posts.

So which mafia teammate in your never-closed chat told you to keep haranguing me and push the miskill?

[FlaviusAetius]

Yknow only now did I realize I cannot read ghug. I have the exact same null (he could be either) read every game

Bunny is trying to pocket everyone and it makes me nervous. His playstyle is extremely different than mine

Also hello Bona.

This game is actually the first game in quite a while where I dont feel Ghug is obv-town (not counting last for obv reasons).

Its still early ofcourse, but he's done some of the small things that give me a little reason to be worried.

Vague. Great, and why even reply to something and that not comment on anything being said. This is so random, and seems like you are trying to take people off of Bunny, if you think he isnt mafia then just say it

[FlaviusAetius]

dang I missed so much Im like 20 pages behind, Im gonna do a big catchup; but not my usual way, I'll only respond to very important things I guess o things that reference me. Until I get closer to the page number we are on

This is the most disappointing thing I’ve read. I was really looking coward to some Flavius catch ups.

i basically just lied to myself here i cant resist responding to everyone

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

I understand there are 5 town PR roles and 3 mafia PR roles, but what's the breakdown of town:mafia? I didn't see that written on the first game post from brain.

@HAMILTONBRIAN
When you wrote this, were you aware I (and others) had already asked the same question?

I don't think you're asking the question in good faith, similar to how you've been misrepresenting my play so far. If mafia, why would I answer with a ÿes?" It would be expected to lie. As town, of course my reply would be, "no, I didn't know you had asked the question."

I think that was my 2nd post the entire game, and look at the spread I had between posts.

So which mafia teammate in your never-closed chat told you to keep haranguing me and push the miskill?

This is a very large and moderately impressive post that almost made me miss the fact that you're avoiding the question.

[brainbomb]

(Meanwhile in suburbia)
Wife: I know you've been on that app again. I want a divorce.

Husband: Good. I'm running away with Shadowheart and we're going to change religions!

Wife: (gasps) You would give up this life of Scientology we built together?!

Husband: yes, Im a shar worshipper now. Bow to her imperiousness indoors eating cake!

Vote Tally
damo666 (5) worcej Squigs44 Jamiet99uk Dousing foodcoats
Hamilton Brian (5) damo666* DiplomacyandWarfare Fluminator Ezio FlaviusAetius
lfischl (4) Kakarroto Chaqa Foxcastle DemonRHK
kingofthepirates (2) kingofthepirates BunnyGo
Jamiet99uk (1) Vecna
Vecna (1) TheMadMonarch
BunnyGo (1) ghug*
FlaviusAetius (1) JustAGuyNamedWill
ghug (1) Bonatogether
Fluminator (1) sweetandcool
JustAGuyNamedWill (1) Col7by

Unvote (1) aarodactyl

Non-votes (These people are out of compliance for minimum participation requirement, and must vote)
Hamilton Brian, lfischl

No one is Scheduled to Die
3 hours remain

[Hamilton Brian]

What's flum's question to me again?

And what question are you referring to, Dip?

[Squigs44]

@HAMILTONBRIAN
When you wrote this, were you aware I (and others) had already asked the same question?

I don't think you're asking the question in good faith, similar to how you've been misrepresenting my play so far. If mafia, why would I answer with a ÿes?" It would be expected to lie. As town, of course my reply would be, "no, I didn't know you had asked the question."

I think that was my 2nd post the entire game, and look at the spread I had between posts.

So which mafia teammate in your never-closed chat told you to keep haranguing me and push the miskill?

This is a very large and moderately impressive post that almost made me miss the fact that you're avoiding the question.

I think the avoidance was on purpose given that he said its a bad question with no value. Which I tend to agree with.

Do you agree with his characterization of your question as being loaded?

[Hamilton Brian]

##Vote ilfischl

May as well start by voting a slot I don't particularly care for, is a high wagon, and it serves to save my skin at the present moment.

I'd be happy to see a wagon, as much as it'd be OMGUS on Dip.

[Squigs44]

Can't tell if Dip and I just see the world differently due to playstyle or if my tinfoil Dip and Ghug scumteam is true. Either way it would take a lot for me to day 1 vote for such an active player. They'll continue to incriminate themselves if they actually are scum

[Hamilton Brian]

Screw it. I don't care that it's non-competitive at this point.

##VOTE DiplomacyandWarfare

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

What's flum's question to me again?

And what question are you referring to, Dip?

When you wrote that post (on page 16), were you aware I and others had already asked it?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Screw it. I don't care that it's non-competitive at this point.

##VOTE DiplomacyandWarfare

You're trying to act like angry town, but I don't think you are.

[sweetandcool]

I think this is a great reason why Kak isn't scum, actually. Actual scum would think this through just like this, determine that they're probably going to to get heat for suggesting it, realize that town might just lie, and so it's not worth it. The scum team is much more likely to discuss who they think is the best player that they can successfully turn is rather than relying on anything that anyone has said in the thread about accepting a tadpole.

Hmmm, so if you are Mafia, Kak is your teammate. Noted.

Sure, go ahead and note that down, but I don't see scum going this far out of their way to engage with a newer player in such an obvious defense when Kak isn't even a wagon...

I completely disagree. Though I think you are Town anyways, but it is good to note these things.