M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[FlaviusAetius]

unordered bc they are all weak
TRs

Dip
Jamie
Vecna
Bona
Kak

SRs

Bunny
Flav

Naked lists are shit.

AGREED! EXPLAIN your reasonings! You can't just parachute in make a whole bunch of reads and then fly away, you arent actually doing anything

[FlaviusAetius]

too real! this is why we should massclaim

We should NOT massclaim, there's already so many people here, mass claiming seems like chaos guranteed and the kind of chaos mafia would thrive in. This is like a last resort option ONLY.

Also waiting for the HB & Damo thing to pick up I havent see anything scummy against them yet and im on page 23 or something like that rn.

I agree with Senator Aetius.

Massclaiming in such an opaque setup would be very dim witted.

No wonder Bona suggested it.

I think with even just a little thought its pretty obvious a massclaim is a bad idea. So now I think Bona thought about it too much...a mafia thing to push, but he hasnt pushed it it was just a thought, if someone has pushed massclaiming or even tried to start the train on it THEN I think suspecting them of being mafia is A-OKAY

[sweetandcool]

I've been gone for a while. Has there been a huge shift in Damo's meta or something? This does not seem like either his town game or his scum game. So if he's doing something different, it either has to be sustainable as scum (which I don't think this is), or be able to come up with a justification for why he dropped it that looks towny (risky), or he is just playing loose as town and not caring (likely).

He definitely is strange this game, to the point I'm tempted to vote him myself.

[sweetandcool]

##vote damo

I will join you, I think a number of people noticing damo is off is indicative of damo's scum game (as he is usually most obvscum D1 when he draws it).

##VOTE damo

Woah party member, please remember that damo is "obvscum" as Town D1 as well.

[Hamilton Brian]

Revising the earlier post as things develop.

Key town vibes: Jamie, Chaqa (hope things are alright), king (I kind of like the decision to no-kill), Monarch, worcej, bunny,

Leaning town: dousing, aaro, flum, fox, flaevius, sweet, Just, squiggs

Negative feelings: ghug, damo; foodcoats, bona, Dip, flum, vecna (moving up...I don't like the long-standing vote on jamie but there hasn't been a rush to get on a lead wagon).

Sus: Kakarroto, ilfischl,

Wait a moment.

Why do you have Fluminator listed as a townlean and a scumlean at the same time?

Forgot to delete it?

[sweetandcool]

Here's my theory: damo is town and the wagon on him contains scum trying to stop the Hamilton wagon.

If you disagree, please quote something scummy damo has said and explain how that post is scummy.

This is scum Dip?

[sweetandcool]

Are you ever going to be surprised if I flip.

Or maybe not.

But then it becomes "guess the mafia who jumped on to Brian to save damo."

Why aren't you voting damo then?

Why should I vote damo?

A man of principle. Shall we keep Ham in for now?

[BunnyGo]

Okay I’m 10 pages in right now and have two scum possibilities but will wait until I am done just updating everyone

I don’t think you’re going to catch up. Better just start posting thoughts.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

HB wagon is largely based off his weird readlists, which seem to be heavily reactionary.
Damo wagon is based on the way he reacted to some criticism or other of Jamiet's
lfischl wagon is based off whatever lfischl wagon is based off
Out of these three (and the 4th place, the Fluminator wagon, to which I say Fluminator), the HB wagon is just the strongest.

Either way Ham is really not doing anything good. His play so far is basically just scumreading everyone who scumreads him and then making up reasons for scumreading us.

[Ezio]

HB wagon is largely based off his weird readlists, which seem to be heavily reactionary.
Damo wagon is based on the way he reacted to some criticism or other of Jamiet's
lfischl wagon is based off whatever lfischl wagon is based off
Out of these three (and the 4th place, the Fluminator wagon, to which I say Fluminator), the HB wagon is just the strongest.

Either way Ham is really not doing anything good. His play so far is basically just scumreading everyone who scumreads him and then making up reasons for scumreading us.

Are read lists not supposed to be reactionary? What else are they supposed to be?

[sweetandcool]

Goodness, you are hard to please.

Alright then, here is a picture of a Japanese woman playing tennis:

Cruyff.png

Is that better?

Last time I tried to appease someone here on webdip I actually offered Chaqa some reallife chipotle.

I feel like theres a better deal here that youre not yet putting on the table.

Alright, you drive a hard bargain, but here you are, a picture of something from the menu at Chipotle:
.
Cruyff.png
.
That's the last one you're getting for now.

What country is that from? Pretty sure they just slip the food into the bowl. This looks too tidy.

[brainbomb]

(In a stinky basement, old pizza boxes everywhere)

Dean: (yelling) Mom! I need some more pizza. I cant beat Act 3 on livestream without pizza. Im on a timer here mom!. I have to beat Act 3 in 45 minutes or less to beat this troll Gary. Thinks he can speedrun me. Ill show him a speedrun.

MOM! Can I get a bowl of chili too? Do we still have that Chili from last week? Ill take some Chili to dip my pizza in!

damo666 (5) worcej Squigs44 Jamiet99uk Dousing foodcoats
Hamilton Brian (5) damo666* DiplomacyandWarfare BunnyGo Fluminator Ezio
lfischl (4) Kakarroto Chaqa Foxcastle DemonRHK
Fluminator (2) FlaviusAetius sweetandcool
kingofthepirates (1) kingofthepirates
Jamiet99uk (1) Vecna
Vecna (1) TheMadMonarch
BunnyGo (1) ghug*
FlaviusAetius (1) JustAGuyNamedWill

Unvote (1) aarodactyl

ghug (1) Bonatogether

Non-votes (You must vote to meet participation requirements for this game)
Col7by, Hamilton Brian, lfischl

No one is scheduled to die!
4 hours remain

[FlaviusAetius]

This reads like a lie. Why would you assume that town PR's are exempt from a tadpole?

##vote Fluminator

Also the possibility that a tadpole sent to a town PR could fail brings up a weird alternate universe where the mafia could've used the tadpole to figure out if a person was a town PR or not (ie: the mafia would know a person was a town PR if the tadpole failed)

Im calling it, unless something changes Fluminator gotta go for what he said here
##vote Fluminator

I can forgive an obviously weak case at the beginning when we're all grasping at straws but surely something else has come up since then in the last 20 pages

From this point I got several cases against people;

Those who bandwagoned Jamie right out of the gate are super sus, they jumped on an easy target for his attitude, and even voted for him! Like that's not even playing the game seriously.

Kak super defended himself against that troll thing he did in the beginning with the no-vote people D1, like sure explain yourself and move on but he KEPT ON TALKING ABOUT IT. That isnt normal

Vecna & HamiltonBrian both asked about how many mafia there are, so either they didnt pay attention at ALL to the signup thread(mega DOUBT!) or their asking a mafia type useless question...clearly no one is going with my Flum catch so Im voting HamiltonBrian since he's the only one I have on my suspicions lists...but im still reading so I might flip ##VOTE HamiltonBrian

I also suspect D&W slightly for putting me as Lawful Good, but need more

[Squigs44]

HB wagon is largely based off his weird readlists, which seem to be heavily reactionary.
Damo wagon is based on the way he reacted to some criticism or other of Jamiet's
lfischl wagon is based off whatever lfischl wagon is based off
Out of these three (and the 4th place, the Fluminator wagon, to which I say Fluminator), the HB wagon is just the strongest.

Either way Ham is really not doing anything good. His play so far is basically just scumreading everyone who scumreads him and then making up reasons for scumreading us.

Hams wagon is based off of a readslist he posted after the wagon was formed? Was there no reason before his readslist was posted?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Here's my theory: damo is town and the wagon on him contains scum trying to stop the Hamilton wagon.

If you disagree, please quote something scummy damo has said and explain how that post is scummy.

This is scum Dip?

I'm just going to put this out there:
I have played four game on WebDip: M85, M1028, M87, and M88, in that order.
Of those, all but M85 I have been scum in.
In M85 (and you can go to the bot and check this yourself) I made 12 posts, most of which were low quality.
So I have played very little town on this site. "Normal Dip play" as you know it is scum.

Take that how you will.

[damo666]

In pub. Not read since last post.

Don't know why I'm lead wagon.

Popularity I guess.

Anyway I'm not gonna hardclaim anything other than hardclaim not mafia which is kinda worthless.

Pick the bones out of that.

If you think I may be of value later in game don't vote me. If you don't well I don't care.

[sweetandcool]

Here's my theory: damo is town and the wagon on him contains scum trying to stop the Hamilton wagon.

If you disagree, please quote something scummy damo has said and explain how that post is scummy.

What'd change if you look at it like HB is town and the wagon on him contains scum?

It seems like a lot of energy to openly claim the belief the damo wagon is town and HB's isn't.

Why are you talking about yourself in third person?

Dip spewing stuff he has heard previously. Do you really find that odd, ord do you just remember a few people saying that to me in the past?

[Squigs44]

In pub. Not read since last post.

Don't know why I'm lead wagon.

Popularity I guess.

Anyway I'm not gonna hardclaim anything other than hardclaim not mafia which is kinda worthless.

Pick the bones out of that.

If you think I may be of value later in game don't vote me. If you don't well I don't care.

You tell me if you're gonna be useful later? Cause right now it doesn't look like it

[Col7by]

After being caught up with mild skimming my scum reads are possibly dip and will. Will trying to befriend me as new early and comments dip has made on the game I find odd. Also I have no clue what tadpoling is

[Jamiet99uk]

Revising the earlier post as things develop.

Key town vibes: Jamie, Chaqa (hope things are alright), king (I kind of like the decision to no-kill), Monarch, worcej, bunny,

Leaning town: dousing, aaro, flum, fox, flaevius, sweet, Just, squiggs

Negative feelings: ghug, damo; foodcoats, bona, Dip, flum, vecna (moving up...I don't like the long-standing vote on jamie but there hasn't been a rush to get on a lead wagon).

Sus: Kakarroto, ilfischl,

Wait a moment.

Why do you have Fluminator listed as a townlean and a scumlean at the same time?

Forgot to delete it?

Which one?

And why haven't you answered his question?