M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[Jamiet99uk]

This is silly talk, the whole point of mafia is the town strategizing in public, and seeing who is picking decisions that benefit the town or people who are trying to steer us away. PLUS the mafia can talk 24/7 this time around, and more likely than not they have people who know people who play here, we need things out in the OPEN! That's more important especially at such an early stage

too real! this is why we should massclaim

We should NOT massclaim, there's already so many people here, mass claiming seems like chaos guranteed and the kind of chaos mafia would thrive in. This is like a last resort option ONLY.

Also waiting for the HB & Damo thing to pick up I havent see anything scummy against them yet and im on page 23 or something like that rn.

I agree with Senator Aetius.

Massclaiming in such an opaque setup would be very dim witted.

No wonder Bona suggested it.

[Jamiet99uk]

He screams scum.

He has made six posts.

Which of them "scream" scum, and why?

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

##VOTE Flum

What about my conversation, with Damo, about Hamilton, makes you scumread Fluminator?

I don't get it.

[Bonatogether]

This is silly talk, the whole point of mafia is the town strategizing in public, and seeing who is picking decisions that benefit the town or people who are trying to steer us away. PLUS the mafia can talk 24/7 this time around, and more likely than not they have people who know people who play here, we need things out in the OPEN! That's more important especially at such an early stage

too real! this is why we should massclaim

We should NOT massclaim, there's already so many people here, mass claiming seems like chaos guranteed and the kind of chaos mafia would thrive in. This is like a last resort option ONLY.

Also waiting for the HB & Damo thing to pick up I havent see anything scummy against them yet and im on page 23 or something like that rn.

jimmit has already started the chain. it is too late. the lemmings are jumping off the cliff

[Hamilton Brian]

Why should I vote damo?

If you think mafia are jumping on you to save Damo, then you think Damo is scum right?

This is good

I think you're buddying.

[Vecna]

too real! this is why we should massclaim

We should NOT massclaim, there's already so many people here, mass claiming seems like chaos guranteed and the kind of chaos mafia would thrive in. This is like a last resort option ONLY.

Also waiting for the HB & Damo thing to pick up I havent see anything scummy against them yet and im on page 23 or something like that rn.

I agree with Senator Aetius.

Massclaiming in such an opaque setup would be very dim witted.

No wonder Bona suggested it.

im like 94% sure it was a joke

[sweetandcool]

I understand there are 5 town PR roles and 3 mafia PR roles, but what's the breakdown of town:mafia? I didn't see that written on the first game post from brain.

O h l o o k a n o t.h e r t o w.n s l i p.

ghug powerwolfing yet again

I think you are confused. Ghug is just a powerful player.

[ghug]

To be clear, I am claiming ghug is powerwolfing by the following definition:

powerwolf. v,
1. To make aggressive statements and directly or indirectly pressure others to agree with those statements as mafia

This is definitely not something town should be doing, as it discourages open communication and problem-solving.

proposal: ban subordinate clauses. too complicated. we can do away with passive voice too

I didn't realize you were a Jamie-accredited simpleton.

Ghug being aggressive and shaming bona

Yes, I'm using aggression to force others to agree with my opinion on subordinate clauses. Obvious mafia behavior.

[Hamilton Brian]

Revising the earlier post as things develop.

Key town vibes: Jamie, Chaqa (hope things are alright), king (I kind of like the decision to no-kill), Monarch, worcej, bunny,

Leaning town: dousing, aaro, flum, fox, flaevius, sweet, Just, squiggs

Negative feelings: ghug, damo; foodcoats, bona, Dip, flum, vecna (moving up...I don't like the long-standing vote on jamie but there hasn't been a rush to get on a lead wagon).

Sus: Kakarroto, ilfischl,

[ghug]

I understand there are 5 town PR roles and 3 mafia PR roles, but what's the breakdown of town:mafia? I didn't see that written on the first game post from brain.

O h l o o k a n o t.h e r t o w.n s l i p.

ghug powerwolfing yet again

l o.l

[Jamiet99uk]

O h l o o k a n o t.h e r t o w.n s l i p.

ghug powerwolfing yet again

l o.l

s t o p b e i n g s o s c u m m y , g r e g.

[sweetandcool]

Why is it scummy?

If everyone stated whether they would accept a tadpole, mafia would know who they could successfully recruit. We're better off not revealing whether we would accept so mafia has like a 50% chance or whatever at successful recruitment.

I think this is a great reason why Kak isn't scum, actually. Actual scum would think this through just like this, determine that they're probably going to to get heat for suggesting it, realize that town might just lie, and so it's not worth it. The scum team is much more likely to discuss who they think is the best player that they can successfully turn is rather than relying on anything that anyone has said in the thread about accepting a tadpole.

Hmmm, so if you are Mafia, Kak is your teammate. Noted.

[Jamiet99uk]

Revising the earlier post as things develop.

Key town vibes: Jamie, Chaqa (hope things are alright), king (I kind of like the decision to no-kill), Monarch, worcej, bunny,

Leaning town: dousing, aaro, flum, fox, flaevius, sweet, Just, squiggs

Negative feelings: ghug, damo; foodcoats, bona, Dip, flum, vecna (moving up...I don't like the long-standing vote on jamie but there hasn't been a rush to get on a lead wagon).

Sus: Kakarroto, ilfischl,

Can you address Fluminator's questions, please, Hamilton Brian?

[Squigs44]

Revising the earlier post as things develop.

Key town vibes: Jamie, Chaqa (hope things are alright), king (I kind of like the decision to no-kill), Monarch, worcej, bunny,

Leaning town: dousing, aaro, flum, fox, flaevius, sweet, Just, squiggs

Negative feelings: ghug, damo; foodcoats, bona, Dip, flum, vecna (moving up...I don't like the long-standing vote on jamie but there hasn't been a rush to get on a lead wagon).

Sus: Kakarroto, ilfischl,

Why kak and lfischl?

[Jamiet99uk]

Revising the earlier post as things develop.

Key town vibes: Jamie, Chaqa (hope things are alright), king (I kind of like the decision to no-kill), Monarch, worcej, bunny,

Leaning town: dousing, aaro, flum, fox, flaevius, sweet, Just, squiggs

Negative feelings: ghug, damo; foodcoats, bona, Dip, flum, vecna (moving up...I don't like the long-standing vote on jamie but there hasn't been a rush to get on a lead wagon).

Sus: Kakarroto, ilfischl,

Wait a moment.

Why do you have Fluminator listed as a townlean and a scumlean at the same time?

[FlaviusAetius]

##VOTE FLAVIUS

Bunny is hard to read bc he is committed to his bit

Also his lingo is literally the stereotype of a dandd player

So voting me is the correct decision in this case, what a great idea! Bunny already broke the bit at our insistence so we can get actual talking out of him. Yet you still vote me for no reason, after saying Bunny is hard to read??? This is out of the blue

[Col7by]

step one: take the players list:

1. chaqa
2. kingofthepirates
3. JustAGuyNamedWill
4. Jamiet99uk
5. Bonatogether
6. damo666
7. Hamilton Brian
8. Dousing
9. foodcoats
10. BunnyGo
11. ghug
12. Ezio
13. FlaviusAetius
14. DiplomacyandWarfare
15. Kakarroto
16. Worcej
17. lfischl
18. Vecna
19. foxcastle
20. TheMadMonarch
21. DemonRHK
22. Col7by
23. Squiggs44
24. sweetandcool
25. fluminator
26. aarodactyl

step two, remove six names from there which I personally think shouldn't be day one'd (except they absolutely are proven mafia, but I doubt I come to that conclusion D1), and refill the numbers in order, 1 to 20

(for the record, removed were: 5. Bonatogether, 11. ghug, 15. Kakarroto, 16. Worcej, 22. Col7by, 24. sweetandcool)

1. chaqa
2. kingofthepirates
3. JustAGuyNamedWill
4. Jamiet99uk
5. damo666
6. Hamilton Brian
7. Dousing
8. foodcoats
9. BunnyGo
10. Ezio
11. FlaviusAetius
12. DiplomacyandWarfare
13. lfischl
14. Vecna
15. foxcastle
16. TheMadMonarch
17. DemonRHK
18. Squiggs44
19. fluminator
20. aarodactyl

step three, use hobbit luck and roll a d20 -> 13 lfischl

step four, vote the result

##vote lfischl

step five:

Thank you for step two right choice :) sorry still catching up

"Still catching up" on post #16 of 668. I don't think Col7by is going to make it...

Look how far I’ve made it work in progress just believe

[FlaviusAetius]

Revising the earlier post as things develop.

Key town vibes: Jamie, Chaqa (hope things are alright), king (I kind of like the decision to no-kill), Monarch, worcej, bunny,

Leaning town: dousing, aaro, flum, fox, flaevius, sweet, Just, squiggs

Negative feelings: ghug, damo; foodcoats, bona, Dip, flum, vecna (moving up...I don't like the long-standing vote on jamie but there hasn't been a rush to get on a lead wagon).

Sus: Kakarroto, ilfischl,

I dont even know why people are voting you yet I havent gotten there, but are you like gonna do anything to actually defend yourself?? You can't just pretend you dont have a large wagon on yourself when you are one of the top two people cmon man

[Ezio]

##vote hamilton

[Col7by]

step one: Collect underpants.
step two: ???
step five:

Thank you for step two right choice :) sorry still catching up

Good afternoon, Col-seven-by.

Have you played Mafia before, elsewhere, or is this your first game?

Else where but never here so I didn’t know how to find this thread hence being so behind

[Foxcastle]

If everyone stated whether they would accept a tadpole, mafia would know who they could successfully recruit. We're better off not revealing whether we would accept so mafia has like a 50% chance or whatever at successful recruitment.

I think this is a great reason why Kak isn't scum, actually. Actual scum would think this through just like this, determine that they're probably going to to get heat for suggesting it, realize that town might just lie, and so it's not worth it. The scum team is much more likely to discuss who they think is the best player that they can successfully turn is rather than relying on anything that anyone has said in the thread about accepting a tadpole.

Hmmm, so if you are Mafia, Kak is your teammate. Noted.

Sure, go ahead and note that down, but I don't see scum going this far out of their way to engage with a newer player in such an obvious defense when Kak isn't even a wagon...