M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[sweetandcool]

What's with the quick Jamie wagon right out of the gate? That's absurd.

Vecna, Sweet, Squigs...giving you three the hairy eyeball.

EXACTLY. Its almost as if they waited for Jamie to post to come swinging right at him. That the start of their voting...I dont like it! Its someone easy to bandwagon off of, and no need to actually put any thought into it, just what a mafia wants to do on D1

Not only did it come across as Jamiet faking it, but I am tired of unprovoked unpleasantness. So I prefer this vote, and I can tell you it is NAI because I would do it if we were both Town, and I would do it if I was Mafia and he was Town, and I would do it if we were both Mafia.

[FlaviusAetius]

A new player would be most likely to scumslip and answer this question, which might explain Squiggs posting - preventing his scumteammate from slipping.

Mafia can talk 24/7, this isnt necessary to do at all, if there's a new mafia player they are being extremely coached

I have been intrigued by this Flavius person who, cowardlyly, chose to play only in the time I was absent from the community. Sure enough, we seen likely to butt heads.

NOOO we dont have to be enemies, I just went inactive for a few years, real life got in the way ;( but im back now

[Fluminator]

I got distracted playing Baldur's Gate 3

[Fluminator]

Wait you just caught me townslipping for not even knowing mafia can convert a PR. Thank you
Sweet!
and Cool

This reads like a lie. Why would you assume that town PR's are exempt from a tadpole?

##vote Fluminator

Also the possibility that a tadpole sent to a town PR could fail brings up a weird alternate universe where the mafia could've used the tadpole to figure out if a person was a town PR or not (ie: the mafia would know a person was a town PR if the tadpole failed)

Im calling it, unless something changes Fluminator gotta go for what he said here
##vote Fluminator

I can forgive an obviously weak case at the beginning when we're all grasping at straws but surely something else has come up since then in the last 20 pages

[Fluminator]

I was ghug before Bona was ghug. Now I'm different but sometimes I have to spend the whole evening at the Hop Shop because my power is out and I revert.

the future is now, millennial

My mom thinks I'm a zoomer too. She read a book after my dad got the vasectomy.

What the heck are you smoking this game Ghug. Is this all Gen Z references I'm missing?

[Fluminator]

Message to Mafia:

While I won't accept a tadpole if given it, I want to be clear that buddying works on me, and I will likely townread you for it. Do with that info as you will.

Dip is a strong townread for calling me Absolute Exalted.

Hey Flum, you have... uhhhh... great hair. Yeah! Great hair! And ummm... good reads! Yeah! The greatest reads!


(did it work?)

A for effort but my receding hairline makes this less effective.
I don't think I've ever played with you before, what's your background? Are you new or experienced?

[Fluminator]

Can anyone tell me what Kingofpirates was like in previous games?

[Dousing]

What's with the quick Jamie wagon right out of the gate? That's absurd.

Vecna, Sweet, Squigs...giving you three the hairy eyeball.

EXACTLY. Its almost as if they waited for Jamie to post to come swinging right at him. That the start of their voting...I dont like it! Its someone easy to bandwagon off of, and no need to actually put any thought into it, just what a mafia wants to do on D1

Not only did it come across as Jamiet faking it, but I am tired of unprovoked unpleasantness. So I prefer this vote, and I can tell you it is NAI because I would do it if we were both Town, and I would do it if I was Mafia and he was Town, and I would do it if we were both Mafia.

Sweet isn’t actually lying, he is consistently anti-throwing/unplesantness

The first example I can think of is our first game together when Sweet voted KoalaAttack because Koala voted for themselves (& sweet was a town PR that game).

Source: http://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?p=337251#p337251

***I’m not saying that the anti-Jamie wagon isn’t mafia-led but (at least for Sweet) it’s not COMPLETELY out-of-the-blue***

[Fluminator]

How dare you! I am a man of integrity. I would not eat a tadpole, that's murder.

Plus, Mafia shouldn't be looking to recruit a VT.

##VOTE Flum for scumslipping.

Wait you just caught me townslipping for not even knowing mafia can convert a PR. Thank you
Sweet!
and Cool

This reads like a lie. Why would you assume that town PR's are exempt from a tadpole?

##vote Fluminator

Also the possibility that a tadpole sent to a town PR could fail brings up a weird alternate universe where the mafia could've used the tadpole to figure out if a person was a town PR or not (ie: the mafia would know a person was a town PR if the tadpole failed)

This might be a Townslip actually. Town can reject the tadpole and this post assumed it can't. Do people who have played with Dousing before know if he'd fake a townslip like?

[Dousing]

This reads like a lie. Why would you assume that town PR's are exempt from a tadpole?

##vote Fluminator

Also the possibility that a tadpole sent to a town PR could fail brings up a weird alternate universe where the mafia could've used the tadpole to figure out if a person was a town PR or not (ie: the mafia would know a person was a town PR if the tadpole failed)

Im calling it, unless something changes Fluminator gotta go for what he said here
##vote Fluminator

I can forgive an obviously weak case at the beginning when we're all grasping at straws but surely something else has come up since then in the last 20 pages

I honestly think my case against you isn’t the strongest…

There 100% was a few posts that I wanted to respond to but I can’t remember what they were and I don’t wanna reread a bunch of spam just to find it.

If I *had* to change my vote rn though… I’d say there’s AT LEAST one mafia in Vecna, sweetandcool, or Squigs44

[Fluminator]

Or is it a scum slip because all townies should know it's optional to be recruited. Hmmm

[Dousing]

Wait you just caught me townslipping for not even knowing mafia can convert a PR. Thank you
Sweet!
and Cool

This reads like a lie. Why would you assume that town PR's are exempt from a tadpole?

##vote Fluminator

Also the possibility that a tadpole sent to a town PR could fail brings up a weird alternate universe where the mafia could've used the tadpole to figure out if a person was a town PR or not (ie: the mafia would know a person was a town PR if the tadpole failed)

This might be a Townslip actually. Town can reject the tadpole and this post assumed it can't. Do people who have played with Dousing before know if he'd fake a townslip like?

Love the compliment, but I wasn’t talking about the tadpole being accepted/rejected

I was talking about a scenario in which a tadpole could’ve been blocked bc the recipient was a town PR. ie: the mafia would get a message like “the tadpole couldn’t be received by the recipient player” or smt.

That would basically CONFIRM that the player was a PR. (But that’s all besides the point since that’s not how the tadpole works)

[Fluminator]

Im calling it, unless something changes Fluminator gotta go for what he said here
##vote Fluminator

I can forgive an obviously weak case at the beginning when we're all grasping at straws but surely something else has come up since then in the last 20 pages

I honestly think my case against you isn’t the strongest…

There 100% was a few posts that I wanted to respond to but I can’t remember what they were and I don’t wanna reread a bunch of spam just to find it.

If I *had* to change my vote rn though… I’d say there’s AT LEAST one mafia in Vecna, sweetandcool, or Squigs44

If you think the case is a weaker one, what do you think of Aetius sheeping it 15 pages later?

[Dousing]

Or is it a scum slip because all townies should know it's optional to be recruited. Hmmm

Tbh, I have no clue what your point is. BOTH mafia and town know that the tadpole could be rejected. Classic WIFOM; you’re reading far too deep into the “why does person X know this information that is clearly defined in the setup for everyone to see??????”-type thinking

[Dousing]

I can forgive an obviously weak case at the beginning when we're all grasping at straws but surely something else has come up since then in the last 20 pages

I honestly think my case against you isn’t the strongest…

There 100% was a few posts that I wanted to respond to but I can’t remember what they were and I don’t wanna reread a bunch of spam just to find it.

If I *had* to change my vote rn though… I’d say there’s AT LEAST one mafia in Vecna, sweetandcool, or Squigs44

If you think the case is a weaker one, what do you think of Aetius sheeping it 15 pages later?

I mean… I didn’t make an illogical argument. Besides, if you have to listen to someone, I’d listen to the smartest person in the room ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[Dousing]

I mean… I didn’t make an illogical argument. Besides, if you have to listen to someone, I’d listen to the smartest person in the room ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Also I put a portion of that post in red so that might’ve caught their eye

[Dousing]

what does your pfp say?

"We'd do well to stop and get some rest."
"Gale, it's been one fight."

(Fun fact: I don't know anything about Tintin or Baldurs Gate. I just like the vibes.)

[damo666]

29pp?

Summary please.

[damo666]

##vote Ham

##end

@bunny please stop it with the role playing shit already. Nobody will read your posts. If you persist I will assume you are scum and act accordingly.

[Vecna]

jamiet is only overly dramatic like this when he is drunk.

your defence feels like it carries ulterior motives

oh, and he sometimes fakes it when he's mafia, because he knows everyone townreads him for his emo outbursts

itd be funny if this post was only liked by mafia (ghug/bunny/sweet)