Mafia 88: Murder at the Meadery - GAME THREAD

[bozotheclown]

Just a reminder, scum is currently pushing hard to DK Town sweetandcool.

Would very much appreciate if y'all would consolidate soonish.

Who is voting for you that you think is mafia?

[sweetandcool]

##CALL GM

Vote count?

[BunnyGo]

I am up to Page 128 and now I need to go and get something to eat.

I will be back before EoD hopefully, but just in case I am not, my scans were:

N1: Balki (innocent)
N2: Damo (innocent)
N3: Worcej (guilty)

Wait wait wait wait wait wait wait.

Jamie was role blocked Night 1?

Damn it! You're right.

This is what the cop should have done though to throw off the scent even more…

Hypo-pathetically

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm convinced this was a slip. Regardless of whether or not you were claiming to be the Cop, you came up with a scan list that was inconsistent with your previous role block claim (which now I am questioning). So, until I am convinced otherwise:

##VOTE Jamiet99uk

How should I best convince you?

I was just doing the hypo scan thing. It did not occur to me to put in the actual roleblock.

We're both town.

The fact that you didn't tell us that explicitly, and your mistake, made your post pretty darn useful PR fishing, friend.

I explicitly previously stated that I agreed with Bunny's plan and would do it.

I explicitly stated I was posting Cop scans in case I wasn't on at EoD.

It's only likely to be "useful PR fishing" if Worcej is PR. I voted and pressured him already in the phase.

If Scum RBed me, only they know for sure that they did so.

[bozotheclown]

##VOTE Balki

I still don't like Balki's D1 vote for damo, or him pushing to DK damo at D1 EOD.

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm going to meet a friend shortly.

Are we flipping Worcej, or are we flipping Sweet?

[Jamiet99uk]

##VOTE Balki

I still don't like Balki's D1 vote for damo, or him pushing to DK damo at D1 EOD.

It's Day Four.

Your case on Balki is that he scumread Damo on D1.

Is that all?

[sweetandcool]

I'm going to meet a friend shortly.

Are we flipping Worcej, or are we flipping Sweet?

If you are going to be away, and consolidation is critical I guess worcej.

##VOTE worcej

[Balki Bartokomous]

##VOTE Balki

I still don't like Balki's D1 vote for damo, or him pushing to DK damo at D1 EOD.

How about my reconsideration of my read on Damo on Day 2 after he shot foodcoats? How does that work into your theory?

[bozotheclown]

##VOTE Balki

I still don't like Balki's D1 vote for damo, or him pushing to DK damo at D1 EOD.

It's Day Four.

Your case on Balki is that he scumread Damo on D1.

Is that all?

No, I don't remember Balki making any significant case for any scum read all game, including against me, who he has voted for repeatedly.

[Chaqa]

M88 Day 4 Vote Count 5
sweetandcool (3): DiplomacyandWarfare, Vecna, Bonatogether
worcej (3): Hamilton Brian, kingofthepirates, sweetandcool
bozotheclown (2): Jamiet99uk, Balki Bartokomous
Balki Bartokomous (1): BunnyGo
Hamilton Brian (1): worcej [END]
Jamiet99uk (1): Spartaculous
Balki Bartokomous (1): bozotheclown

Currently NO ONE is set to be killed.

85 minutes remain

[sweetandcool]

Just a reminder, scum is currently pushing hard to DK Town sweetandcool.

Would very much appreciate if y'all would consolidate soonish.

Who is voting for you that you think is mafia?

Vecna and rdr.

Starting to think there is a chance Bona is actually just coasting by only tunneling me.

Like, I still assess Bona as Town D1, but if he managed to fool us all then his following play is super scummy because his ONLY contribution so far is to lazily tunnel me.

[bozotheclown]

##VOTE Balki

I still don't like Balki's D1 vote for damo, or him pushing to DK damo at D1 EOD.

How about my reconsideration of my read on Damo on Day 2 after he shot foodcoats? How does that work into your theory?

Since damo was town, you could have been doing that to look "correct" about him later.

[Balki Bartokomous]

##VOTE Balki

I still don't like Balki's D1 vote for damo, or him pushing to DK damo at D1 EOD.

It's Day Four.

Your case on Balki is that he scumread Damo on D1.

Is that all?

No, I don't remember Balki making any significant case for any scum read all game, including against me, who he has voted for repeatedly.

I think I've made short cases on Bozo, Vecna, and worcej.

But you are right that most of my effort has been on town reads.

[Balki Bartokomous]

##VOTE Balki

I still don't like Balki's D1 vote for damo, or him pushing to DK damo at D1 EOD.

How about my reconsideration of my read on Damo on Day 2 after he shot foodcoats? How does that work into your theory?

Since damo was town, you could have been doing that to look "correct" about him later.

That's true. So you really need to engage with my stated reasons and judge whether they seemed sincere.

[bozotheclown]

Just a reminder, scum is currently pushing hard to DK Town sweetandcool.

Would very much appreciate if y'all would consolidate soonish.

Who is voting for you that you think is mafia?

Vecna and rdr.

Starting to think there is a chance Bona is actually just coasting by only tunneling me.

Like, I still assess Bona as Town D1, but if he managed to fool us all then his following play is super scummy because his ONLY contribution so far is to lazily tunnel me.

I still consider Bonatogether a possible mafia.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Just a reminder, scum is currently pushing hard to DK Town sweetandcool.

Would very much appreciate if y'all would consolidate soonish.

Who is voting for you that you think is mafia?

Vecna and rdr.

Starting to think there is a chance Bona is actually just coasting by only tunneling me.

Like, I still assess Bona as Town D1, but if he managed to fool us all then his following play is super scummy because his ONLY contribution so far is to lazily tunnel me.

That's a fair point. Bona has not really been participating in a meaningful way since Day 1, or least that's my sense of it.

[bozotheclown]

How about my reconsideration of my read on Damo on Day 2 after he shot foodcoats? How does that work into your theory?

Since damo was town, you could have been doing that to look "correct" about him later.

That's true. So you really need to engage with my stated reasons and judge whether they seemed sincere.

I know your reasons and I think they were accurate, but that does not make you town.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I'll move over to worcej if the Bozo wagon does not become more of a thing.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Since damo was town, you could have been doing that to look "correct" about him later.

That's true. So you really need to engage with my stated reasons and judge whether they seemed sincere.

I know your reasons and I think they were accurate, but that does not make you town.

Fair.