Mafia 88: Murder at the Meadery - GAME THREAD

[Bonatogether]

no more futzing around with roles and scans and whatever

[bozotheclown]

Why would I be anybody's top scumread?

I don't think I have seen Just obviously pocket someone as mafia like it appears he was doing with you D1, I think he would be more likely to do it to a mafia teammate knowing it would look like pocketing.

Your certainty during D1 that there was exact one mafia between Just and Bonatogether does not make sense to me.

sweetandcool had conflicting reads about you D1, which could be an indication he was distancing.

Your low level suspicion of sweetandcool D2 looks like possible bussing, as well as sweetandcool ignoring your vote while reacting to LoW and Vecna voting for him.

Your decision to vote for Bonatogether D1 EOD instead of one of the top 3 wagon was unusual, as brainbomb pointed out at the time.

Bona was one of the top wagons at EoD1, Bozo. Go and check.

Your certainty that Bona vs Sweet was pure scum theatre does not make sense to me.

The rest of your argument here is entirely based on your suspicion that Sweetandcool is Mafia. You are making this assumption and then finding connections based on the assumption you have made.

It was 4-3-3-2 when you voted for Bonatogether the second time, and you chose Bonatogether over the top 3 wagons. I agree the wagons were close, but it was your preference for Bonatogether that I was noting.

It is sweetandcool interactions with other players that make me suspect him.

[bozotheclown]

^ I agree with Jamiet.

About what, specifically?

[sweetandcool]

can we just kill the damn pr claim

Scumclaim?

[bozotheclown]

@Bozo:

Why did you do that?

##VOTE Bonatogether

##VOTE BunnyGo

##VOTE worcej

I think at least one of these bussed D1.

I was documenting this in case I ended up being the DK.

##Vote Bozo, but why did you feel the need to do this by voting, instead of just, you know, saying it? If you think it is necessary to vote for someone, ##Vote Bozo, every time you want your points to be noticed, I think that is a bit silly.

It is more prominent in the voting history on the bot.

[bozotheclown]

You could just have made a post like this:

If I am DKed, please note that I think at least one of Bonatogether, BunnyGo, and Worcej bussed JustAChapCalledWill on D1.

Please take note of this, as I, Bozo, Robot Detective, King of the Circus, consider it to be important.

This would have made your point without putting weird markers down in the vote history.

What is the scum motivation for doing it by voting?

[bozotheclown]

To be clear, I don't really agree with a point about vote tagging and creating weird vote tracker data. Doesn't really seem like a #scumpiracy to me.

It's not necessarily scummy, but it is unnecessary.

I recall him doing it in at least one previous game. I don’t recall the game and don’t have time to dig for it.

@bozo: can you find it?

Spartaculous already said he did at the request of sweetandcool, but he did not give the game numbers.

[bozotheclown]

People I feel suspicious about right now and the order in which I'd like to flip them:

1. Bozo
2. Vecna
3. worcej
4. Damo
5. Hamilton

Did you ever say why you suspect me?

[Spartaculous]

It's not necessarily scummy, but it is unnecessary.

I recall him doing it in at least one previous game. I don’t recall the game and don’t have time to dig for it.

@bozo: can you find it?

Spartaculous already said he did at the request of sweetandcool, but he did not give the game numbers.

M1025 is one

[Jamiet99uk]

no more futzing around with roles and scans and whatever

No, we must have mechanics, mechanics, MECHANICS!

[Jamiet99uk]

It is sweetandcool interactions with other players that make me suspect him.

Yes but you are also using your scumread of him, as a key reason for scumreading ME. I am not scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

I was documenting this in case I ended up being the DK.

##Vote Bozo, but why did you feel the need to do this by voting, instead of just, you know, saying it? If you think it is necessary to vote for someone, ##Vote Bozo, every time you want your points to be noticed, I think that is a bit silly.

It is more prominent in the voting history on the bot.

It also makes the vote history misleading because they were not genuine votes.

[Jamiet99uk]

You could just have made a post like this:

If I am DKed, please note that I think at least one of Bonatogether, BunnyGo, and Worcej bussed JustAChapCalledWill on D1.

Please take note of this, as I, Bozo, Robot Detective, King of the Circus, consider it to be important.

This would have made your point without putting weird markers down in the vote history.

What is the scum motivation for doing it by voting?

I'm not entirely sure, but I am sure it is annoying.

[bozotheclown]

I recall him doing it in at least one previous game. I don’t recall the game and don’t have time to dig for it.

@bozo: can you find it?

Spartaculous already said he did at the request of sweetandcool, but he did not give the game numbers.

M1025 is one

Thanks, did you notice I hit all 3 mafia in the 5 players I voted?

[bozotheclown]

##Vote Bozo, but why did you feel the need to do this by voting, instead of just, you know, saying it? If you think it is necessary to vote for someone, ##Vote Bozo, every time you want your points to be noticed, I think that is a bit silly.

It is more prominent in the voting history on the bot.

It also makes the vote history misleading because they were not genuine votes.

They were real votes in that they were players I was willing to vote for.

[bozotheclown]

It is sweetandcool interactions with other players that make me suspect him.

Yes but you are also using your scumread of him, as a key reason for scumreading ME. I am not scum.

The are other reasons, like this:

Is anyone interested in flipping Bozo or Damo?

I’m fairly interested in flipping Bozo.

##Vote Bozotheclown

Come along then.

However, I am OK finding out about sweetandcool first.

[bozotheclown]

Fair. Well just remember it's a path to getting me to potentially Town you.

You already town read me, though:

Conclusions so far:

Town:

Bozo
Bona
sweetandcool
Jamiet

I feel good at least with the Bozo read because I independently Town read them.

The other two I'm just going to have to accept as town until we run out of suspects.

Bozo: Quotes old reads list from beginning of D2 where sweetandcool towns them.
sweetandcool: But I scumread you because you saved your scumbuddy LoW (amongst other things), which happened EoD2.

Okay, I'm just going to ignore Bozo's smear campaign since it's pointless to waste my time on it.

Calling it now, scumteam is: Vecna, LoW, Bozo.

We just need to make sure to consolidate on one of them today. I have an extremely slight preference of LoW or Bozo because one of them being scum pretty much confirms the other, however we can't go wrong with Vecna either, so I am happy with that as well.

How could you be so certain about me and LoW being on the same team?

[bozotheclown]

##VOTE Jamie

[bozotheclown]

##VOTE Bonatogether

[bozotheclown]

##VOTE sweetandcool