Mafia 88: Murder at the Meadery - GAME THREAD

[Vecna]

although its probable that one of the people voting me for it is indignant town, and the other 2 happily sheeping that since its an easy vote atm.

[Bonatogether]

Only one way to interpret this so who did you scan town last night?

It's very possible a panicked Ham fakeclaiming doesn't know which roles are still there to claim, so I don't like this framing from damo.

That said, Ham, with no night talking and no doctor, you need to tell us who you scanned now.

Ghug looking scummy af here

i mean in real terms, isn't that right?

[Bonatogether]

jailor doesn't protect jailed target, does it?

[Bonatogether]

Remaining scum predictions:

Vecna: Hamilton sweetandcool worcej
ghug: bozo Hamilton rdrivera
bozo: Bonatogether rdrivera worcej
sweetandcool: Vecna rdrivera LoW
Jamie: LoW bozo damo/rdrivera/sweetandcool
Spartaculous: rdrivera LoW Bonatogether
Hamilton: Vecna damo LoW
LoW: sweetandcool Jamie BunnyGo

oof, lotta things happened since last night, I'm honestly pretty lost rn... but I see something to do, so here's mine

LoW, then 2 of rdr/ham/vecna/damo. slight lean towards damo as 1 over everyone else, but nothing significant. slight lean against rdr, but similarly nothing significant. spartaculous's analysis wayyy earlier pushed them off my scum radar.

I don't have any other reasons to add, reasons that other ppl have mentioned have convinced me. Still super tired, but open to discussion.

you're always open to discussion and not discussing

[Bonatogether]

cops don't claim without posting reads

i'm not caught up but fundamentally we need something hard

[Bonatogether]

Haven't read anything since last posted so this is a naked post.

Made a claim as the cop/clerk since D1. I was pretty blatant about it as far as I thought. Go look for the posts with CLERK starting each sentence line. I knew that if I was going to have small time to devote to the game in general, I thought I would make the play to at least be a night kill.

That obviously didn't happen.

I did wonder if ghug was lying about the roleblock. I see now he was, but I thought his falsifying of it was a more nefarious purpose.

Was it a shitty town play? I don't know. I know it was done with only the most honourable of intent; how it rolled out had minimal impact...I think.

There were some things that troubled me about EOD 2. Where I thought ghug was being less than genuine, it turns out that my wonderings now lean more into worcej and bozo.

Why did Worcej land his final vote on bozo, a player he interacted with minimally throughout D2?

Why was he feeding to mafia the plan to setup a miskill (if Brian makes it through N2...)?

Is Bunny suggesting they are miller to absolve a guilty scan? Are they mafia? I don't think there's a CC.

Bozo thinks worcej is a good vote but then drifts votes through the Bs and Worcej, insinuating they're one of the bussers. About only half the group followed through the "survey."

So, do with me what you will. Kill me today, and/or hammer me, then it gives mafia an easy one today.

My gambit failed; it didn't help town and I am REALLY GODDAMNED SORRY about that. I effed up.

there's no claim of a clear here?

[worcej]

I always will crumb scans or at least make it really obvious who I would scan.

But I also cave under pressure usually if I am concerned I will not be around for a phase, but when I cave I would *immediately* spell out my explicit actions.

I think HB is scum but ya’ll will let him slip until it’s too damn late to flip him. I’ve yelled this multiple times but no one give a shit to pay attention, so yolo let’s kill Vecna

I have yet to hear a convincing case for business regarding Ham and much of the evidence presented by Sweet and Damo could've been laid with the scenario of Ham falling under suspicion in mind.

I wouldn't mind hearing your thoughts or what I'm missing from anyone else.

Sober me next morning - glad to see HB is back on the menu.

##vote Hamilton

With every game, I'm willing to entertain the possibility I am wrong and will kill our PR here with a DK, but the circumstances surrounding his role is entirely HB's own fault (the claim, lack of putting info in front ASAP before night, posts I've read so far) and leaves too much for me to believe it.

His behavior is far more consistent with a scum player who tried to bait a CC.

[Bonatogether]

i hate hate hate mechstalk

[Bonatogether]

Holy mother of all that is unholy!!! Are Jamie and bozo being intentionally obtuse as mafia or really confounded by what's happened.

Mafiareading you both now for just this shit.

If there is real CLERK out there that isn't me, don't CC. Don't talk about it anymore, and don't talk scans.

Go back to EOD on both days.

scans or nothing

[worcej]

Sorry for disappearing. Had only one “night post” lamenting the lack of DemonRHK and his “You tie, YOU FRY” posts.

Was all considering to blame ghug for not moving his vote like he always does.

I'm shocked I haven't seen more of this lol...

[worcej]

Holy mother of all that is unholy!!! Are Jamie and bozo being intentionally obtuse as mafia or really confounded by what's happened.

Mafiareading you both now for just this shit.

If there is real CLERK out there that isn't me, don't CC. Don't talk about it anymore, and don't talk scans.

Go back to EOD on both days.

We're nit flipping you today, but you're still scummy.

I feel good about flipping him today.

[damo666]

##vote Vecna

I am policy voting the highest wagon out of Ham voters

[damo666]

Holy mother of all that is unholy!!! Are Jamie and bozo being intentionally obtuse as mafia or really confounded by what's happened.

Mafiareading you both now for just this shit.

If there is real CLERK out there that isn't me, don't CC. Don't talk about it anymore, and don't talk scans.

Go back to EOD on both days.

scans or nothing

he has no scans, he's not clerk

[worcej]

##vote Vecna

I am policy voting the highest wagon out of Ham voters

As long as you don't cause a tie, you do you boo

[Bonatogether]

what are the odds scum thought ghug was soft counterclaiming hamilton

[Bonatogether]

GM Note:
Due to ongoing climate catastrophes in his town, Rivera has had to sub out to help volunteer and tend to things.

D&W has offered to sub in. Let's hope the bot likes this.

Diplomacy&Warfare has replaced rdrivera2005

you have been dubbed dew

[Bonatogether]

I was not sure about Vecna, but I like this post because I think his POE are all reasonable scum candidates, including his 3 alternates.

it's basically claiming a gamesolve on d2. this is a scummy post

saying that a group of people is "probable town" and that im unsure of 3 of the people in there due to bussing is not claiming a gamesolve.

Regardless, I still think my solution is not that far off. Funnily enough after I posted that all of them happily joined my wagon with some support from our good friends damo and balki.

i'm calling bonzo scummy

[Jamiet99uk]

I was just wondering about that.

I'm guessing Mafia just RB the NK.

They probably don't want to create anymore pseudo clears.

Obviously nobody would have believed Ham based on EoD2, so it is unsurprising they didn't even bother RBing him.

Or who knows, maybe I've got it all wrong and he is Mafia (insert shrug emoji)

The Jailor is dead. RBing the NK is the same as not using it.

If Ham were scum don't you think he'd have claimed RB?

Only if he was scum maintaining his cop claim.

[Bonatogether]

Holy mother of all that is unholy!!! Are Jamie and bozo being intentionally obtuse as mafia or really confounded by what's happened.

Mafiareading you both now for just this shit.

If there is real CLERK out there that isn't me, don't CC. Don't talk about it anymore, and don't talk scans.

Go back to EOD on both days.

scans or nothing

he has no scans, he's not clerk

too true damo!

[Bonatogether]

##vote hamilton