Mafia 88: Murder at the Meadery - GAME THREAD

[Spartaculous]

Chiming in, I'm off work for the weekend, so I'm around to answer questions directly if you'd like.

Just going over Will's reads list.

It'd also be helpful to know if there is a post bookmarking function here. Still getting used to the layout.

I'm now more convinced by Jamie's earlier case.

##VOTE Lord

Sparta moves off me to join me lol

If you can't beat 'em, join 'em!

In any case, I had made up my mind that I was going to vote LoW if there were no more posts after a couple more hours. I saw that you beat me to this by just a few minutes.

[bozotheclown]

You didn't ask me either, but I am suspicious of everyone who was "correct" about Just at EOD, because no one suspected him enough to vote for him all of D1 except for the last 1.5 hours. I would not be surprised if all of the mafia ended the day voting for Just.

Ok I hate to be that guy, but I'm bringing the math back real quick. If all mafia where on will, they could've all migrated onto one of the 3 person wagons and saved will and got rid of a town (even 2 mafia on will could've tied, but at EOD, it would be suspicious). so I doubt it's 3 mafia on will.

If all three mafia voted for Just, what you explained is what they would have been trying to get town to assume.

[damo666]

You didn't ask me either, but I am suspicious of everyone who was "correct" about Just at EOD, because no one suspected him enough to vote for him all of D1 except for the last 1.5 hours. I would not be surprised if all of the mafia ended the day voting for Just.

Ok I hate to be that guy, but I'm bringing the math back real quick. If all mafia where on will, they could've all migrated onto one of the 3 person wagons and saved will and got rid of a town (even 2 mafia on will could've tied, but at EOD, it would be suspicious). so I doubt it's 3 mafia on will.

If all three mafia voted for Just, what you explained is what they would have been trying to get town to assume.

All 3 bussing the GF with no N0 chat? Highly unlikely.

[ghug]

I still think it possible that sweetandcool was bussing all 3 of his teammates in that post.

Bozo is doing the thing he does as scum where he focuses on the possible instead of the probable.

I think you typically accuse me of doing that as town.

Perhaps I have in the past, but currently I think it's scummy.

[ghug]

You didn't ask me either, but I am suspicious of everyone who was "correct" about Just at EOD, because no one suspected him enough to vote for him all of D1 except for the last 1.5 hours. I would not be surprised if all of the mafia ended the day voting for Just.

Ok I hate to be that guy, but I'm bringing the math back real quick. If all mafia where on will, they could've all migrated onto one of the 3 person wagons and saved will and got rid of a town (even 2 mafia on will could've tied, but at EOD, it would be suspicious). so I doubt it's 3 mafia on will.

Town points for pirates

[Lord of Words]

When is end of day?

Currently writing up scum/town reads now.

[sweetandcool]

like Bozo Jamie Vecna for instance?

Yes, that would be an example team that would do that. But that team doesn't mesh with what actually happened in the game, with two RB claims.

Why not brain RB ghug, scum hold and Jamie fakeclaims? That works.

You think Jamiet would do that? Do you have supporting evidence as to why Jamiet could be scum? How do you explain Will's treatment of Jamiet?

[damo666]

When is end of day?

Currently writing up scum/town reads now.

22 and a bit hours

[bozotheclown]

Cheers to Honey and good fortune

scum

Oh as per official newb shield Spartaculous will not receive my vote until day 3 or later. Lord of Words maybe bc hes played elsewhere

fake!

sparta may be cringe but he doesn't have the votes

vote for will for a better town

Will is obvtown

you will see your error soon

Bonatogether was apparently scum reading Just after his first post, and was confident Just was mafia at EOD. That is not very consistent with not voting for Just for 47 hours of D1. I don't think everyone should assume Bonatogether is town.

The GF is only useful if he gets cop scanned, Bonatogether could have been trying to make that happen.

[damo666]

Yes, that would be an example team that would do that. But that team doesn't mesh with what actually happened in the game, with two RB claims.

Why not brain RB ghug, scum hold and Jamie fakeclaims? That works.

You think Jamiet would do that? Do you have supporting evidence as to why Jamiet could be scum? How do you explain Will's treatment of Jamiet?

I'm not saying I think that's the case I'm just laying out how it's possible.

My best guess now is Ham LoW and perhaps Balki or Vecna

[sweetandcool]

Oh yeah! LordofWords not voting messed with my PoE. Also a prime candidate.

[bozotheclown]

Ok I hate to be that guy, but I'm bringing the math back real quick. If all mafia where on will, they could've all migrated onto one of the 3 person wagons and saved will and got rid of a town (even 2 mafia on will could've tied, but at EOD, it would be suspicious). so I doubt it's 3 mafia on will.

If all three mafia voted for Just, what you explained is what they would have been trying to get town to assume.

All 3 bussing the GF with no N0 chat? Highly unlikely.

If I were mafia I would have voted for Just at about the time worcej and BunnyGo did, and I typically do not like bussing.

[bozotheclown]

Bozo is doing the thing he does as scum where he focuses on the possible instead of the probable.

I think you typically accuse me of doing that as town.

Perhaps I have in the past, but currently I think it's scummy.

Why would I do that as mafia?

[bozotheclown]

When is end of day?

Currently writing up scum/town reads now.

This is a fairly good town slip also.

[ghug]

Cheers to Honey and good fortune

scum

Oh as per official newb shield Spartaculous will not receive my vote until day 3 or later. Lord of Words maybe bc hes played elsewhere

fake!

Will is obvtown

you will see your error soon

Bonatogether was apparently scum reading Just after his first post, and was confident Just was mafia at EOD. That is not very consistent with not voting for Just for 47 hours of D1. I don't think everyone should assume Bonatogether is town.

The GF is only useful if he gets cop scanned, Bonatogether could have been trying to make that happen.

The GF is not only useful if he gets cop scanned. We can now trust all innocent scans, which we couldn't do while he was alive.

[ghug]

I think you typically accuse me of doing that as town.

Perhaps I have in the past, but currently I think it's scummy.

Why would I do that as mafia?

It's leaving your options open. You can go out and cast a bunch of shade without actually committing to opinions.

[bozotheclown]

scum

fake!

you will see your error soon

Bonatogether was apparently scum reading Just after his first post, and was confident Just was mafia at EOD. That is not very consistent with not voting for Just for 47 hours of D1. I don't think everyone should assume Bonatogether is town.

The GF is only useful if he gets cop scanned, Bonatogether could have been trying to make that happen.

The GF is not only useful if he gets cop scanned. We can now trust all innocent scans, which we couldn't do while he was alive.

It is not like town is going to go killing players scanned as town just because the GF is still around.

[worcej]

ghug, bunny, worcej (anyone else really), I need your help here.

What does it mean to you when Mafia RB someone other than the NK?

My takeaway is scum were trying to RB the jailor to prevent shenanigans maybe?

[bozotheclown]

Perhaps I have in the past, but currently I think it's scummy.

Why would I do that as mafia?

It's leaving your options open. You can go out and cast a bunch of shade without actually committing to opinions.

I find that risky as mafia because it can lead to getting DKed.

[worcej]

I don't think Brain was obviously a PR in any fashion from my read of his analysis.

I wonder if the intent of killing him was to lock his reads in to cause us to wander on re-read of him