Mafia 87: Madness in Mega-City One - GAME THREAD

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Wait no

2 docs+3 cops+ 2 townclears =7 so at least one cop/doc is lying

But that also means that DrFid, snowy, ghug, damo, demon are evil

So… huh

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Well aint this something

[kingofthepirates]

in my eyes, fid is the most clear scum of all of them. I'm holding my vote as is. we flip one, then we continue.

[Chaqa]

Is there not an unaccounted for VT?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

6 scum left
It seems impossible to me that both Chaqa AND Balki are lying about being doctor, as the real doctor would then counterclaim and both of them would end up on the chopping block

Therefore at least one of them is actually the doctor

Given the number of clears, the scum team has to include DrFidelis

Unless we believe that brainbomb is lying, which is not a reality I'm willing to entertain right now

This is good

I also forgot to unvote balki lmao

##VOTE DrFid

?

You know you're included in the "you must be scum" list right

No my guy I’m the SJS cop

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Is there not an unaccounted for VT?

No, worcej/rdr are VT

[kingofthepirates]

Is there not an unaccounted for VT?

no, 4 deaths so far, plus rdr/worcej is 6

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

WAIT WAIT

So 2 doc+3 cop+2 conf townies

There is a liar in this group. And they are the only hope of either team for town NOT to win

Unless its one of the docs, which it may be, i think brain realized this and is trying to play the long game

[Chaqa]

Is there not an unaccounted for VT?

no, 4 deaths so far, plus rdr/worcej is 6

I’m still not convinced they aren’t both mafia

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

So snowy, ghug, Chaqa, DrFid, and damo, how does it feel to be outed with 4 others lmao

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Is there not an unaccounted for VT?

no, 4 deaths so far, plus rdr/worcej is 6

I’m still not convinced they aren’t both mafia

Walk me through how the scans woulda got mixed up

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

This is funny ehheheheeh

Because all 5 of them know as soon as I flip SJS cop they are all caught lmao

[ghug]

Ok so it is Fidelis
Thought I was losing my mind here

How d'you figure?

6 scum left
It seems impossible to me that both Chaqa AND Balki are lying about being doctor, as the real doctor would then counterclaim and both of them would end up on the chopping block

Therefore at least one of them is actually the doctor

Given the number of clears, the scum team has to include DrFidelis

Unless we believe that brainbomb is lying, which is not a reality I'm willing to entertain right now

Wait a sec, something's wrong:
rd (multiple scans)
worcej (multiple scans)
brain (un-CCed)
kotp (un-CCed)
snowy (King's scan)
ghug (role PM)

Doesn't leave room for either doctor claimant. If we don't get a doc claim from rd or worcej, something's wrong with either a scan or a doctor. Obviously to the outside world here a more straightforward conclusion is that ghug is scum, which is concerning, as I am not.

But yes, I guess you're probably right about Fid.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Unless, of course, they dont vote me to keep that fact obscured

But I would never propose something like that

[Chaqa]

So snowy, ghug, Chaqa, DrFid, and damo, how does it feel to be outed with 4 others lmao

I forgot damo was in this game lmao

[Chaqa]

no, 4 deaths so far, plus rdr/worcej is 6

I’m still not convinced they aren’t both mafia

Walk me through how the scans woulda got mixed up

I don’t know how the mechanics work but I know what my gut says

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I’m still not convinced they aren’t both mafia

Walk me through how the scans woulda got mixed up

I don’t know how the mechanics work but I know what my gut says

Your gut? Not your PM? Lmao okay judge

[snowy801]

How d'you figure?

6 scum left
It seems impossible to me that both Chaqa AND Balki are lying about being doctor, as the real doctor would then counterclaim and both of them would end up on the chopping block

Therefore at least one of them is actually the doctor

Given the number of clears, the scum team has to include DrFidelis

Unless we believe that brainbomb is lying, which is not a reality I'm willing to entertain right now

Wait a sec, something's wrong:
rd (multiple scans)
worcej (multiple scans)
brain (un-CCed)
kotp (un-CCed)
snowy (King's scan)
ghug (role PM)

Doesn't leave room for either doctor claimant. If we don't get a doc claim from rd or worcej, something's wrong with either a scan or a doctor. Obviously to the outside world here a more straightforward conclusion is that ghug is scum, which is concerning, as I am not.

But yes, I guess you're probably right about Fid.

That is the reasonable conclusion, is it not?
I am open to counterarguments, at a convenient time (or now if you prefer)

[ghug]

Yeah ok it might make sense to just finish massclaiming at this point given that two thirds of the game has claimed.

[Chaqa]

Walk me through how the scans woulda got mixed up

I don’t know how the mechanics work but I know what my gut says

Your gut? Not your PM? Lmao okay judge

Are you not outed scum along with ghug?

I’m pretty lost here