Mafia 87: Madness in Mega-City One - GAME THREAD

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

And in keeping with my prevoius statements on game presense, I will be missing from this post until after EOD.

Food is my vote; they're null to town, but definitely not mafia to my gut. I think others feel the same and the 1 vote on Food is safe and avoids powering up MMA.

Good luck, town.

Don't go yet.

You're voting someone you think is town?

Damo looks pretty good here to question this

Okay my brain says balki/brain

My gut says

##VOTE HAM

Will votes Ham and then next post goes right back to Balki. doesnt really look great.

##VOTE sweet

I don't want dip. I would do Ham.

weird but its ghug?

that food vote is weird

darg pinged by hamiltons vote for food

Oof I kind want to kill Ham now

well, we could do that too, if I'm wrong with my suspicion, we don't vote food out (which you town, but I don't especially, but some others, I think, saw him as good too?), and if Brian doesn't flip as a possible teammate, then food's chances of being that role is much lower

kak trying to understand what that all means

I want brain to go

##vote HamiltonBrian

lets do this

then starts the process

Brainbomb

But sure ##VOTE HAM

not sure why Will suddenly wants me now instead of balki, in fact wills end of day seems really weird.

##VOTE ham

Now will jumps off as soon as ghug jumps on

##VOTE DARG

I am not confident in anyone except balki and brain and somehow neither is a wagon

then will, darg and chaqa vote ham 3 posts in a row

and then will is suddenly screaming for everyone to vote Ham, and vecna pushes damo here.

sweet votes Ham, and at this point hamilton is landsliding to death

it seems to me that Will changed behavior to save damo or sweet

Yep. That is correct. I didn’t want another sweet D1 and damo was not nearly as scummy as others. And I felt no people trying to save damo, which kinda pinged me that it could be a townie. So I tried to not vote them.

But I didn’t vote Ham/darg to save them. It was just a consequence of my doing

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Also when you say ‘I suddenly want brain over balki, I was actually correcting somebody that mistook your name for Brian’s.

[brainbomb]

Also when you say ‘I suddenly want brain over balki, I was actually correcting somebody that mistook your name for Brian’s.

ah okay. interesting. I thought it was you calling for my head again lol

[brainbomb]

odds are pretty good that I die tonight so if that happens, you should be eliminating among rdrivera, worcej, Dr fid, Vecna, ND, Dip and war

I think thats a good group to contain quite alot of the mafia if not all

I would not kill food, pirate, balki, or snowy basically ever in this game.

[brainbomb]

strongest scumread is rdrivera.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

To all the scum: kill the other team

You will probably get townies during the Day Phases because we have nobody defending us

Especially you judges! If town gets to a point where they have to choose with scum team wins, we choose angels because they are more peaceful

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

odds are pretty good that I die tonight so if that happens, you should be eliminating among rdrivera, worcej, Dr fid, Vecna, ND, Dip and war

I think thats a good group to contain quite alot of the mafia if not all

I would not kill food, pirate, balki, or snowy basically ever in this game.

What happened to your wall on me

Also snowy? is it meta or what, because I’m not seeing it in this game

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

DrFid my beloved town

[brainbomb]

My wall on you was answered by you. you are not in my top tier of scumreads.

as for snowy, I concluded in my research he is probably town. Im not following what you mean by the meta remark, his meta history is to have very strong directions he wants to go for what he considers scum. and he tends to be fairly relentless in those pursuits.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Ay fair enough. I just wanted to know if there was a meta-basis for the townread rather than just this game alone

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Anyways updated reads list

Town

King
Food
Kak
DrFid
ND
Worcej
Ghug
Chaqa
Snowy
Sweet
Vecna
Dip & War
Rdr
Brainbomb
Damo
Darg
Balki

Scum

I can elaborate on any

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

##CALL GM will we be told what killed a player at night? Mean Machine, Judge Fire, Judge Death, etc

Also heres a thought if the answer is yes

Maybe instead of attempting to consolidate on one wagon (which we have learned will not work), we consolidate on three

That leaves two alive that had any votes
If MMA kills, then we have two suspects for who they are

But idk, I would assume the answer to above query is no

Just writing down some thoughts

[Jamiet99uk]

##CALL GM will we be told what killed a player at night? Mean Machine, Judge Fire, Judge Death, etc

GM NOTE

You have asked this question repeatedly and I have already answered it. The answer is NO.

[Kakarroto]

Back from drug store

Continued)

Town
Snowy
Balki
Food
Pirate

And adjusting for how eod went
Damo town

Null
Chaqa
Sweet
Kak
Darg
Will

Scum
Dr fid
Vecna
Rdrivera
ND
Dip and war

hmm ... so if you think that damo is town and sweet null, how do you think Brian got so many votes as town? Do you think it was more of a town 'oh shit somethings not right we need to do something' vibe and mafia was just leaned back since there wasn't one of them on the block?

[brainbomb]

many players locked themselves into entrenched axioms regarding sweet and damo

we always kill sweet so I dont wanna do that

damo is a boring day 1 and we do this all the time

and even if the wagons were t/w, w/w, t/t once a player makes that proclamation they will tend to wanna look consistent. I think alot of people from town/scum/scum all voted hamilton probably hopeful he was scum there. but there could be some saving that happened. if the saving happened the evidence suggests balki was driven up to save sweet, not damo

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

##CALL GM will we be told what killed a player at night? Mean Machine, Judge Fire, Judge Death, etc

GM NOTE

You have asked this question repeatedly and I have already answered it. The answer is NO.

My bad, didn’t see it

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

many players locked themselves into entrenched axioms regarding sweet and damo

we always kill sweet so I dont wanna do that

damo is a boring day 1 and we do this all the time

and even if the wagons were t/w, w/w, t/t once a player makes that proclamation they will tend to wanna look consistent. I think alot of people from town/scum/scum all voted hamilton probably hopeful he was scum there. but there could be some saving that happened. if the saving happened the evidence suggests balki was driven up to save sweet, not damo

Balki day one woulda been intersting…

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Hmmm now that I think about it, Mean Machine Angel killing Day 1 is an absolute trash strategy. We would catch them very quickly.

Another tinfoil incoming

Maybe the consolidate tactic was used by the mafia to limit the amount of information that we got from Day 1

And yes, I know I was also a perpetrator, I guess I just didn’t realize it.

So I will be looking into everyone who hard pushed a ‘consolidate the wagons’ strategy

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Maybe I’m throwing hard this game, idk

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

So, ironically, now I’m townreading those who did not pivot to Ham