Mafia 87: Madness in Mega-City One - GAME THREAD

[ghug]

Okay maybe this is dumb but hear me out

Maybe like, a half-hour before EOD, we could pre-vote a target. Whoever has the most votes at 1:30pm PST would be the person we decide to kill. At that point we could ALL vote who we decided on

What if we pick a "mayor" who chooses who we kill?

I vote for ghug to be mayor

I don't endorse this strategy because we'll never actually do it and it would be bad even if we did and even if it were me but I do if it's me because I like power.

Parse that, assholes.

[brainbomb]

If we give an extra nightkill out every day, town gets outnumbered really fast.

It is of course always possible that 2p and 3p nk each other

this is great. angel killing machine guy targets judge who kills when you visit would be the best case scenario if that judge is in play!

[sweetandcool]

What if we pick a "mayor" who chooses who we kill?

I vote for ghug to be mayor

I don't endorse this strategy because we'll never actually do it and it would be bad even if we did and even if it were me but I do if it's me because I like power.

Parse that, assholes.

I'm not participating in this mayor stuff, but honestly I already determined that I would sheep you unless I feel strongly about someone. So I guess that is effectively a mayor vote.

[brainbomb]

you can make me the mayor but I can tell you right now if you do were gonna be killing damo or hamilton

[Balki Bartokomous]

Okay anyways Balki can you give me a quick rundown of how you solve

I think you owe him an answer to his question first.

Even if the answer is very obvious, he wouldn't know until you tell him.

+1

So....@JustAGuyNamedWill

I don't want to dwell on this any more. I just want you to answer a simple question:

How did you know that kotp and DrFidelis were new players?

I went back and looked at the sign-in thread, and it's very clear there that KOTP is brand new. It isn't clear there that DrFidelis is brand new.

How did you know on page 2 that DrFidelis is brand new? How did you know that nobody else (other than KOTP) is brand new?

I ask because this is obviously the sort of thing you might have learned or discussed in a separate Discord faction chat, and so I am trying to get your story straight.

[brainbomb]

I didnt think about that:

"how does will know Balki isnt brand new"

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Okay anyways Balki can you give me a quick rundown of how you solve

I think you owe him an answer to his question first.

Even if the answer is very obvious, he wouldn't know until you tell him.

+1

So....@JustAGuyNamedWill

I don't want to dwell on this any more. I just want you to answer a simple question:

How did you know that kotp and DrFidelis were new players?

I went back and looked at the sign-in thread, and it's very clear there that KOTP is brand new. It isn't clear there that DrFidelis is brand new.

How did you know on page 2 that DrFidelis is brand new? How did you know that nobody else (other than KOTP) is brand new?

I ask because this is obviously the sort of thing you might have learned or discussed in a separate Discord faction chat, and so I am trying to get your story straight.

Ok first of all sweet was referring to your Darg-dar comment that was directed to brain, not knowing it was for brain.

Second, I had not ignored it. I answered a while back.

Anyways, for more clarification, in my Hitman Diplomacy game signups, I asked if any of them wanted to play this mafia game. DrFid and kotp both said yes. Also they both said explicitly in either the signup thread or Hitman DIplomacy thread that it would be their first time playing

I don’t understand why you are continuing on this tangent when it should be fairly obvious.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I didnt think about that:

"how does will know Balki isnt brand new"

He actually asked me in the sign-up thread, if I recall correctly. So that one's easy.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I didnt think about that:

"how does will know Balki isnt brand new"

“Hi Balki! Are you new or a vet?”

Me in signup thread

[brainbomb]

#101 Post by Balki Bartokomous » Mon Mar 11, 2024 3:55 pm

JustAGuyNamedWill wrote: ↑
Mon Mar 11, 2024 2:07 pm
Hello Balki! Are you new or a vet?

I guess I'm a vet. Just been a long while since I've played. I drop by every now and again, until I'm run out of town, only to take another hiatus until memories fade.

I see what you said there Balkster. was looking for myself and boop there it was.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Also because I know this is coming:

I didn’t ask snowy because someone stated it was ‘long time no see’ or something of the sort

[Balki Bartokomous]

I think you owe him an answer to his question first.

Even if the answer is very obvious, he wouldn't know until you tell him.

+1

So....@JustAGuyNamedWill

I don't want to dwell on this any more. I just want you to answer a simple question:

How did you know that kotp and DrFidelis were new players?

I went back and looked at the sign-in thread, and it's very clear there that KOTP is brand new. It isn't clear there that DrFidelis is brand new.

How did you know on page 2 that DrFidelis is brand new? How did you know that nobody else (other than KOTP) is brand new?

I ask because this is obviously the sort of thing you might have learned or discussed in a separate Discord faction chat, and so I am trying to get your story straight.

Ok first of all sweet was referring to your Darg-dar comment that was directed to brain, not knowing it was for brain.

Second, I had not ignored it. I answered a while back.

Anyways, for more clarification, in my Hitman Diplomacy game signups, I asked if any of them wanted to play this mafia game. DrFid and kotp both said yes. Also they both said explicitly in either the signup thread or Hitman DIplomacy thread that it would be their first time playing

I don’t understand why you are continuing on this tangent when it should be fairly obvious.

Thanks.

I asked because I didn't know the answer (I was not a part of your Hitman Diplomacy game sign-ups). It was important to me, as I explained above, because it could have been information you learned in a factional Discord thread.

Super, let's move on.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Fair enough

[brainbomb]

and here I thought maybe someone other than myself reads old games in the downtime between matches to learn things.

you had me hopeful there for a second

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

and here I thought maybe someone other than myself reads old games in the downtime between matches to learn things.

you had me hopeful there for a second

I do. but only the games I played in so I can improve

Unless Demon is secretly Balki

[ghug]

I vote for ghug to be mayor

I don't endorse this strategy because we'll never actually do it and it would be bad even if we did and even if it were me but I do if it's me because I like power.

Parse that, assholes.

I'm not participating in this mayor stuff, but honestly I already determined that I would sheep you unless I feel strongly about someone. So I guess that is effectively a mayor vote.

Why would you do that? History suggests I'm only good at catching scum D1 if you're scum. Thus I can only conclude that you're inclined to sheep me because you're scum.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I don’t like the mayor thing. We pick the wrong person we’re done for

If player X wants player Y to be mayor, we should be suspicious of X and Y being paired

[Balki Bartokomous]

My heart right now is at ##vote damo666

I found his Post #338 to be appalling:

Balki is first to hit 4 votes, and the wagon completely evaporated.

We may have our first candidate for being the mean machine

So, we either ensure we DK him or have no votes on him.

Let's kill him.

##vote Balki

Seems like he ought to have a bit more curiosity and thought behind this action if he were trying to solve a puzzle here. Instead, he quickly endorses Brainbomb's theory, without any doubt or suspicion.

[Balki Bartokomous]

If player X wants player Y to be mayor, we should be suspicious of X and Y being paired

This is really the opposite of what we should be doing.

Mafia are trying to avoid being caught and trying to avoid associations with partners. They are unlikely to be running around on the first day campaigning for their secret buddies.

[brainbomb]

##vote damo