M1028: The Sweet Food Consensus - Game Thread

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Okay at this point:

I have a feeling that its brain but its just a feeling

I have a feeling that its D&W but its just a feeling

I have a feeling that its Bunny but its just a feeling

I’ve known why I’ve scumread Kak at least

##VOTE KAK

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Sorry GT if I’m off, that’s on me

[BunnyGo]

Sorry GT if I’m off, that’s on me

That’s cool. Walk me through it.

Why kak?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

So, I've been gone for about 10 hours. Let's see what's going on.

I would be very surprised if it's brain. There was no doc counter claim, so I guess will is confirmed. So for me it looks like it's just d&w and bun/wor.

But lets ##vote diplomacy&warfare for now.

Behold: Yet another kak decision to vote me out. This is ridiculous. I guarantee you that at least once every 5 pages, kak has posted either voting me or describing why everyone should vote me.

So, brain made a claim to be cop that the mafia apparently saw through. This is either a very smart mafia team that knew brain's claim was false or brain's scum. Brain reads as probably not scum to me, just based on the generally helpful nature of brain's play. I teamsolve bunny and kak.
##vote bunnygo
Btw I voted docsave damo N2, which appears to have failed.

[BunnyGo]

So, I've been gone for about 10 hours. Let's see what's going on.

I would be very surprised if it's brain. There was no doc counter claim, so I guess will is confirmed. So for me it looks like it's just d&w and bun/wor.

But lets ##vote diplomacy&warfare for now.

Behold: Yet another kak decision to vote me out. This is ridiculous. I guarantee you that at least once every 5 pages, kak has posted either voting me or describing why everyone should vote me.

So, brain made a claim to be cop that the mafia apparently saw through. This is either a very smart mafia team that knew brain's claim was false or brain's scum. Brain reads as probably not scum to me, just based on the generally helpful nature of brain's play. I teamsolve bunny and kak.
##vote bunnygo
Btw I voted docsave damo N2, which appears to have failed.

Why vote me rather than the “team solved” kak whom the only clear is voting?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Let me cook right now

actually I tend to see you more to town than mafia here, but there were some things to consider: I have bad reads early and usually get some stuff wrong, and brain proved to have a better nose for some things like the game where I thought food was mafia and he thought he was town and was right, and stuff like that. I also thought "what would happen if I vote Jamie here", who would jump on it, and who would not.

well, I didn't consider that only one vote would be left to hammer you, so I'm sorry to put you through this, but I think we got some nice data out of it: after me, will and d&w did vote you, even endvoted you. Might be just a feeling, might be just being drawn in by the mood, but I think we have to look at them a bit closer. Between both, I'd say d&w is a bit more sus while it is more likely for it being in will's ballpark (with his chaotic e-Will-ness and stuff )

I do think, however, the most crucial information we got is that ghug didn't endvoted you out, even when he (jokingly) wanted to just for the memes. I think, if you are town, jamie, that ghug would've had an easy way as mafia to just get you out of the game. Would let him have a good excuse and the blame would probably go to brain who started it.

There is a chance however, that both jamie and ghug are mafia, so in that case, ghug would most likely not have end voted jamie here out. But I think we can say with all of that, that ghug is town, if anyone else than jamie flips mafia.

so with all that, I'll ##vote diplomacy&warfare . RD and worcej are just off the table D1 for me, just D1 policy since neither of them screams mafia right now. brain looks good too, and if I'm wrong, he'll sort himself out anyway. Still have a feel that damo might be mafia, but I guess I'll trust brain for that. I'm not going to vote ghug unless jamie flips mafia, and jamie looked quite ok in all of that, though I do concur with RD and ghug that something was a bit strange. Ah well, still a town lean from me. If brain was right, he can yell at me later.

I find this to be overjustification for a vote. Possible bussing, more than likely he’s trying overly hard to not look suspicious.

Hmm, I don't like that neither jamie nor d&w did answer my posts. I was a bit busy and maybe they just are, but I really don't like them ignoring me.

checking the thread again it seems they just weren't here, guess bad timing from my side. so in case you two overlooked it before:

@d&w: what exactly was it that you thought Jamie needs to be hammered this early? You jumped on brain and will who had their sights on jamie before and were quite involved with each other, so you doing that feels quite opportunistic

@jamie: you don't feel buster's vote on you was opportunistic?

I feel this was weirdly critical of D&W hammering Jamie but not me or brain. Also this post just feels icky. This isn’t the only time when mentioning two players, one of them beind D&W, that he gave a longer, more in depth analysis on him for no good reason. Justifying a bus maybe? Town Kak would probably not do this.

even if I'm wrong, I think we can't let progress d&w here much further. Imagine d&w in a final 5 or final 3 and think hard about it if you want that.

Yucky post

With the whole will claiming, I second damo's advice, it should be best to let the doc choose and the rest voting for cop. Was thinking of discussing this a bit together, but held back since it feels like it could be manipulated by mafia and their strange powers this game.

Snip

This is his worst example. Kak solves. Kak as town would not pitch a plan that would allow for mafia to misdirect my PR vote, and kill me. Then because no one else voted for doc save, they still had their PR action guess in tact, which would allow them to also flip the cop scan. Kak is a better mech guy then this.

who do you think the maf team is? brain + (?) and what are your thoughts on d&w?

Why do you think ghug was targeted? I come up with a few ideas but I want your input first, as a double check. And from worcej too, if he finds the time.

Finally, this. I don’t think he ever said his ideas.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

The main thing keeping brain in my #2 slot for mafia instead of #1 is that his fake doc claim also happened last game so it is within town brain’s range of play.

[brainbomb]

Bunny
Top two suspects and why

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I know my case isn’t super paragraph-ey but that aint my style so if you don’t like it then oh well ur not getting a whole wall post

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I know my case isn’t super paragraph-ey but that aint my style so if you don’t like it then oh well ur not getting a *whole wall* post

*of my thoughts

[BunnyGo]

Bunny
Top two suspects and why

D&W POE and skimming his vote history.

I’ve been going back and forth on you and kaka.

I think your “CC” was towny. But you did it in a scummy way.

I think kaka isn’t as good as playing scum as you, he doesn’t enjoy it, but I think he CAN do it.

I wonder about his missing EON if he’s scum? Maybe…but not paired with you…hence D&W again is scum.


I haven’t digested Just’s case.

[brainbomb]

##vote bunny go
##end

[BunnyGo]

##vote bunny go
##end

[BunnyGo]

##vote bunny go
##end

Again…why are you ending on a player who the ONE CLEAR isn’t voting. If we’re both town scum can win here.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Honestly if you end up placing the deciding vote on the mafia ur essentially townclear

[BunnyGo]

Honestly if you end up placing the deciding vote on the mafia ur essentially townclear

What do you think of brain endvoting me?

What about diplomacy voting me when he also scums kaka and you’re voting kaka?

[BunnyGo]

Honestly if you end up placing the deciding vote on the mafia ur essentially townclear

Do you have time to search for pairs?

Assume your read on kaka is correct and search for his partner?

I’ll do the same later with D&W. I have to do kids bedtimes now.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Honestly if you end up placing the deciding vote on the mafia ur essentially townclear

What do you think of brain endvoting me?

What about diplomacy voting me when he also scums kaka and you’re voting kaka?

No endvoting please guys

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Honestly if you end up placing the deciding vote on the mafia ur essentially townclear

Do you have time to search for pairs?

Assume your read on kaka is correct and search for his partner?

I’ll do the same later with D&W. I have to do kids bedtimes now.

I do but I won’t reveal in case it affects game decisions. If he flips scum then I will

[BunnyGo]

Honestly if you end up placing the deciding vote on the mafia ur essentially townclear

Do you have time to search for pairs?

Assume your read on kaka is correct and search for his partner?

I’ll do the same later with D&W. I have to do kids bedtimes now.

I do but I won’t reveal in case it affects game decisions. If he flips scum then I will

Are you likely to change your vote? Or are you sure enough you’re gonna gamble it all on kaka?