M1028: The Sweet Food Consensus - Game Thread

[damo666]

I want to hear more from Kak and Dip please.

[damo666]

These questions dont seem to be related to who might be mafia.

I mean...it's pretty obvious.

I'm just trying to figure out why TWO people would be lying about being the cop.

Um what is this now?

I assume it's a desperate attempt at a cop claim lol.


Bunny is mafia.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

I mean...it's pretty obvious.

I'm just trying to figure out why TWO people would be lying about being the cop.

Um what is this now?

I assume it's a desperate attempt at a cop claim lol.


Bunny is mafia.

Bunny is probably mafia. As for brain and will, we have three options:
Brain is mafia and is falseclaiming, will is doc
Both are town, one is doc and the other wants to be sacrificed by the mafia killing them to protect the true doc. I have a 90% sure guess on which it would be if it's this option but I'm not going to share it because I have no desire for the mafia to figure it out.
Will is mafia and was falseclaiming in the first place. Brain is doc.

Out of the three, I think it's probably the third one. If brain is mafia, this is a play to make it seem like they want to be killed by the mafia to protect will, to get trust. If will is mafia, the entire thing was a very convenient way to get towncleared right before getting voted out. Assuming will is not doc, we have to consider the possibility that will might have been mafia the entire time. Either way, brain and will will probably claim it's the second option, but I think it's either the first or the third. Before will claimed to be doc, we had a lot of reasons to vote him. Now that he's not cleared (unless brain says "I was joking will is actually doc"), we have to once again take that evidence into consideration. Claiming to be a PR isn't a "get out of jail free" card for mafias.

[brainbomb]

Im not claiming anything. I simply am the cop. there is no claim when something is a fact

[brainbomb]

whats really funny is, youve been getting basic facts wrong all game, and remembering details completely incorrect. Meanwhile you are running an rpg on this forum where you have to read the players posts in order to come up with what actions they took, and it involves actually reading, and interpreting sometimes totally bonkers role playing.

yet here somehow you cant even remember correctly who instigated a fight, or what role people have claimed or what the setup roles entail - despite asking about them in pregame and getting an exact answer.

Yes, D&W is mafia. and his teammate is probably bunny here

[damo666]

whats really funny is, youve been getting basic facts wrong all game, and remembering details completely incorrect. Meanwhile you are running an rpg on this forum where you have to read the players posts in order to come up with what actions they took, and it involves actually reading, and interpreting sometimes totally bonkers role playing.

yet here somehow you cant even remember correctly who instigated a fight, or what role people have claimed or what the setup roles entail - despite asking about them in pregame and getting an exact answer.

Yes, D&W is mafia. and his teammate is probably bunny here

@Dip wanna reply to this?

[brainbomb]

been thinking a bit more on this, and what I think is sus about kak is the unwaivering love of status quo. and their total lack of urgency to do anything to find both mafia.

whereas I think D&W displays "some" signs of being scattered, frantic and trying to understand. some of it just looks so ridiculous and fake however.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Um what is this now?

I assume it's a desperate attempt at a cop claim lol.


Bunny is mafia.

Bunny is probably mafia. As for brain and will, we have three options:
Brain is mafia and is falseclaiming, will is doc
Both are town, one is doc and the other wants to be sacrificed by the mafia killing them to protect the true doc. I have a 90% sure guess on which it would be if it's this option but I'm not going to share it because I have no desire for the mafia to figure it out.
Will is mafia and was falseclaiming in the first place. Brain is doc.

Out of the three, I think it's probably the third one. If brain is mafia, this is a play to make it seem like they want to be killed by the mafia to protect will, to get trust. If will is mafia, the entire thing was a very convenient way to get towncleared right before getting voted out. Assuming will is not doc, we have to consider the possibility that will might have been mafia the entire time. Either way, brain and will will probably claim it's the second option, but I think it's either the first or the third. Before will claimed to be doc, we had a lot of reasons to vote him. Now that he's not cleared (unless brain says "I was joking will is actually doc"), we have to once again take that evidence into consideration. Claiming to be a PR isn't a "get out of jail free" card for mafias.

what

2 options for when I claimed doc after N1
I solemnly claim that I did not try to bait the nightkill to save another doc. Because I am doc

A. I’m the real doc. In 90% of cases I die. Doc dies in the end
B. I’m mafia. Real doc CCs. We both die. Doc dies in the end

Why wouldn’t doc counterclaim immediately

Now that I have been revealed to not be covering for any “real docs”, If there is someone who would like to contest my doc status, please let everyone know

[brainbomb]

Bump

Just wanna say that if will does not beleive I am town the game is already over and we cant win.

Among d&w, kak or bunny one of you has to be town and it would be great if you could validate that in some way. Lay out who you think it is and for the sake of having any chance whatsover of winning it isnt me

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Bump

Just wanna say that if will does not beleive I am town the game is already over and we cant win.

Among d&w, kak or bunny one of you has to be town and it would be great if you could validate that in some way. Lay out who you think it is and for the sake of having any chance whatsover of winning it isnt me

Well brain I have been absent for a while and I liked you as an option over rdr. I still need to do some thorough rereading. If you are actually town then I trust myself (maybe?) to figure that out, but I don’t know.

I think I’m better at figuring out who is town then who is mafia, and I’ll work with poe

[brainbomb]

supposing that you do all that and still conclude I am scum, who do you feel is second scummiest and why?

[brainbomb]

supposing that you do all that and still conclude I am scum, who do you feel is second scummiest and why?

actually, dont answer this tonight. answer it at end of night I guess.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

supposing that you do all that and still conclude I am scum, who do you feel is second scummiest and why?

Well if you do come across as scum I’d still stick with worcejgo

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

supposing that you do all that and still conclude I am scum, who do you feel is second scummiest and why?

actually, dont answer this tonight. answer it at end of night I guess.

Terrible timing for me to get back on

[brainbomb]

If worcej were town he would argue I made a mistake in my eliminations, he wouldn't attack an uncc'd cop claimant. He is clearly caught scum.

It is also apparent dip is not his partner (or has dropped him like a hot potato).

I attacked you because your pair analysis triggered me as it usually does because it’s incredibly subjective.

I didn’t read your claim until after I tilted.

Do you think I would be this lazy as scum?

this falls well within worcej scumtell. rereading his scum play from M85:

But I am not sorry for thinking your position that I did “nothing” on D1 is horseshit.

I am not sorry for thinking you’re a decent sacrifice on D1 - no one is immune to that. My vote ended up being meaningless because I left it on Chaqa.

And almost certainly, I am not sorry for being overly sarcastic right now. I did find your post to be aggravating and rubbed me the wrong way because you say I did “nothing” which isn’t true.

I continue to explain that I have little motivation to dump time and processing into this game because it’s now just a clustering of buckets and we’re going to get the buckets figured out and then kill in those groups, making the potential hours of D1 I could’ve wasted on my phone hours I would’ve lost with my kids. This game clearly became a mechanics argument on D1 and it’s sad to me that it is that way after we just had a game where we used mechanics to make the game a guess and check already.

Satisfied yet BB? Sorry if you’re not.

he tends to try to make it seem like he is offended at being scumread when someone scumreads him and he doesnt like the reasons why

[brainbomb]

also from M85

What about the stance that you or Jamie should die? Does that not count?

a total cop out basically.

Do you think I am that bad of player to need a cop out if I was scum on D1?

Serious question

he loves to ask these sort of questions about his skill proficiencies when he is mafia, and to force town players to have to decide between saying hes bad at the game or concluding their own logic is bad.

[brainbomb]

worcej scumtell is to create doubt by reverse psychology.

so the ghug kill makes a little more sense if its kak and worcej and yet, ghug also scumread d&W. so again, back to square one on which is last maf then

[brainbomb]

I think we should ask the real important question here. Like:

-) if we change the tomato sauce into ketchup, would a pizza become a sweet fruit pie?

-) is a cake filled and garnished with carrots a sweet dish?

-) why is damo, who's normally absent in the joke phase and a proponent of anti-bad townplay, suddenly voting the player who is a great PR but also prone to easily claim?

yeah, I don't like it a bit. ##vote damo

this set off some weird alarms to me that kak is mafia, and it always resonates to me that kak was quick to scumread damo and was trying to be overly protective of worcej. I just didnt think it was to protect a scum buddy.

[brainbomb]

It's probably just worcej/Kak.

ok, a bit confused here, do you mean Will + one of worcej/me or that the team is 'only' wor and me? Because I can guarantee you that the latter would be wrong

ah well, I guess you can't make a cake without breaking some eggs and stuff anyway

this is a scummy reply to ghug naming wor-kak as the scumteam

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I could literally see it being anybody depending out how the NK and CC work out.

I have nobody in my townleans