M1028: The Sweet Food Consensus - Game Thread

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Yknow in hindsight it looked like ghug was trying to buddy me

"In hindsight" ??

What new information has been revealed to allow you to review things from a position of hindsight??

Hindsight essentially means “looking back”

I looked back

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Can I get to 100 posts by EOD?

[brainbomb]

Can I get to 100 posts by EOD?

fluffing post count was your goal last game also. you were very determined to be high volume at all times and beat me in posting.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Can I get to 100 posts by EOD?

fluffing post count was your goal last game also. you were very determined to be high volume at all times and beat me in posting.

True.

[Jamiet99uk]

by voting you for 19 hours?

Did you forget the part where Ghug explained that his first D1 vote is a mark of respect, which is why he has apparently never voted for you early on D1.

Wait why did you ask me why i thought ghug was buddying me and then literally one post later argue with brain for the fact that ghug was probably buddying me?????

I asked different questions.

[Jamiet99uk]

and Kak.

So who do want?

Jam or Ghug

Explain what I have done that makes me scum?

Explain my scum motivation for the things you find scummy.

Why is Will avoiding this question?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Jam or Ghug

Explain what I have done that makes me scum?

Explain my scum motivation for the things you find scummy.

Why is Will avoiding this question?

Ah my bad

Truth is I don’t know. You do scummy things for reasons I cannot understand. But you do them anyway for some reason

[brainbomb]

I think ghug pointed out that he probably has voted for me first before. Also I do not think ghug means respect in the same way you are probably hoping he means.

I do think ghug is just playing very much like a kitty cat tapping its paw in the bowl of milk. thats what really matters. its very timid, very non comittal, and occasionally he throws out some bland "sort of truth" to dismiss someones train of thought.

[Jamiet99uk]

Explain what I have done that makes me scum?

Explain my scum motivation for the things you find scummy.

Why is Will avoiding this question?

Ah my bad

Truth is I don’t know. You do scummy things for reasons I cannot understand. But you do them anyway for some reason

I purport that an action is not scummy if you cannot come up with any suggestion about why it is scum motivated.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Explain what I have done that makes me scum?

Explain my scum motivation for the things you find scummy.

Why is Will avoiding this question?

Ah my bad

Truth is I don’t know. You do scummy things for reasons I cannot understand. But you do them anyway for some reason

I’m tryna think if Jamie’s multiple scummy things without a reason trump Ghug’s few things with a plausible reason

[Jamiet99uk]

Why is Will avoiding this question?

Ah my bad

Truth is I don’t know. You do scummy things for reasons I cannot understand. But you do them anyway for some reason

I’m tryna think if Jamie’s multiple scummy things without a reason trump Ghug’s few things with a plausible reason

Why are any of my actions scummy if you cannot suggest a reason why scum would do them?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Ah my bad

Truth is I don’t know. You do scummy things for reasons I cannot understand. But you do them anyway for some reason

I’m tryna think if Jamie’s multiple scummy things without a reason trump Ghug’s few things with a plausible reason

Why are any of my actions scummy if you cannot suggest a reason why scum would do them?

Ah no I think you misunderstand.

For example the 7 players thing had no reason to be done. But you did it anyway.

And I just don’t believe you did it as a test sooo

[Jamiet99uk]

I’m tryna think if Jamie’s multiple scummy things without a reason trump Ghug’s few things with a plausible reason

Why are any of my actions scummy if you cannot suggest a reason why scum would do them?

Ah no I think you misunderstand.

For example the 7 players thing had no reason to be done. But you did it anyway.

And I just don’t believe you did it as a test sooo

Sooooo.... what?

What was my scum motivation for that post?

Why is that post scum indicative just because you found it odd?

You have made several odd posts in this game yourself...

[Jamiet99uk]

We are nearing the realms of performative ignorance here.

"I didn't understand X" =/= "X is a scum action".

[brainbomb]

well Jamie, I did come up with reasons why you were scummy. and it comes down to wether you would lie as mafia or not. which, you would. so you can keep repeating you arent lying, and get angry and snarl at being called a liar. but thats what evidence is in mafia; youre either lying or you arent.

So, yea, you cant expect people to give reasons to you if your only rebuttal is "but im not a liar"

I have not necessarily moved on from you being scum either. but your statements about voting town being counter intuitive to the game were a sign that you dont see the value in miskills is actually as useful for town as it is for mafia. *I UNDERSTAND why you feel like miskills for town is bad for town* but it isnt always true. in fact, day 1 towns tend to perform better when they fuck up first, and go better later.

your overall simplistic view of trying to shrug off votes by telling me its against my wincon to be voting town assumes that A: I even am town, which has been something you seem to have never questioned. In fact youve fumed and have become incensed at D&W implying you scumread me. I dont know why you are playing so rigid and close to the vest where your scumread or non scumread of me really matters. Like if you think I could be scum for pushing you, thats fine to articulate.

I am unclear on why you think anyone is anything to be honest. I havent seen a reason why you townread me? or why you stopped scumreading/stopped voting D&W?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Why are any of my actions scummy if you cannot suggest a reason why scum would do them?

Ah no I think you misunderstand.

For example the 7 players thing had no reason to be done. But you did it anyway.

And I just don’t believe you did it as a test sooo

Sooooo.... what?

What was my scum motivation for that post?

Why is that post scum indicative just because you found it odd?

You have made several odd posts in this game yourself...

I know I have. But I know I’m not scum so I’m not gonna vote myself.

I see zero reason for you to do it as town.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Ya know I just realized how bad I am at getting my point across.

[brainbomb]

you are excessively defensive, which is a trait more common to your scumgame as well. where you hone in on argument loops to keep them going relentlessly because thats how you know people here identify you incorrectly as *angry jamie*

[Jamiet99uk]

well Jamie, I did come up with reasons why you were scummy. and it comes down to wether you would lie as mafia or not. which, you would. so you can keep repeating you arent lying, and get angry and snarl at being called a liar. but thats what evidence is in mafia; youre either lying or you arent.

So, yea, you cant expect people to give reasons to you if your only rebuttal is "but im not a liar"

I gave an explanation, which was the truth.

You have accused me of lying.

What else do you want me to do besides repeating my original explanation, which was the truth?

I cannot provide an alternative explanation, because that would be lying, because my original explanation was the true explanation.

[Jamiet99uk]

Brainbomb you don't have any evidence that meets your own standard, which you just stated, because you cannot prove that I have lied, because I did not lie.