Mafia 86: Accidents Happen... - Game Thread

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

He is saying he was doing that to try to get the mafia to think he was the doctor. Do you not think that is possible?

It's possible but if Will isn't mafia then Frog must have seen through it but then why kill Bunny? I may have been the doc. Unless Frog saw whatever Will saw and Will has had extremely bad luck.

I think the latter so unlikely it must be Will.

I saw what Just was doing and I thought it looked more like he was trying to draw the NK than crumb doctor, because there was no reason for the real doctor not to stay hidden. I think the only scum motivation would be to prepare to CC the doctor if necessary.

If Just is town, I think the mafia also figured Just was trying to draw the NK.

I knew I wasn’t crazy! It was too obscure of a tactic.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

It's possible but if Will isn't mafia then Frog must have seen through it but then why kill Bunny? I may have been the doc. Unless Frog saw whatever Will saw and Will has had extremely bad luck.

I think the latter so unlikely it must be Will.

I saw what Just was doing and I thought it looked more like he was trying to draw the NK than crumb doctor, because there was no reason for the real doctor not to stay hidden. I think the only scum motivation would be to prepare to CC the doctor if necessary.

If Just is town, I think the mafia also figured Just was trying to draw the NK.

I knew I wasn’t crazy! It was too obscure of a tactic.

It wasn’t*

[damo666]

He is saying he was doing that to try to get the mafia to think he was the doctor. Do you not think that is possible?

It's possible but if Will isn't mafia then Frog must have seen through it but then why kill Bunny? I may have been the doc. Unless Frog saw whatever Will saw and Will has had extremely bad luck.

I think the latter so unlikely it must be Will.

I saw what Just was doing and I thought it looked more like he was trying to draw the NK than crumb doctor, because there was no reason for the real doctor not to stay hidden. I think the only scum motivation would be to prepare to CC the doctor if necessary.

If Just is town, I think the mafia also figured Just was trying to draw the NK.

But why kill Bunny? Why not RB him and kill you. From Frog's pov I may have been doc.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

@damo

If the KILLBAIT was obvious to everyone, it wouldn’t have worked anyway

[bozotheclown]

If Frog were scum he'd have seen Will's nondoc and assumed either Bunny or I was doc, RBd one of us and killed Bozo.

It has to be Will.

@Bozo I'm right aren't I?

Bunny being the NK changes everything.

I am not sure what you are saying.

Don't you find Will's doc crumbs and stating it after the reveal when the NK is the doctor and not you as too big a coincidence. Why would scumFrog (or scumdamo) risk killing Bunny who might turn out to be vt eliminating a suspect?

I cannot see that Frog would have seen it and worked it out in time to change his NK on a 50/50 gamble (assuming he sussed Will as a bluff).

It's all too convenient.

If it turns out to be Frog then he has played magnificently and Will has shot himself in the foot.

I think BunnyGo being the NK indicates the mafia thought he was the doctor but was not sure, and did not want to risk RBing BunnyGo and NKing me, which could have given us another mis-kill if BunnyGo was not the doctor and the doctor was targeting me again, as well as letting BunnyGo claim the RB.

Or, the mafia knew BunnyGo was the doctor and just preferred me to be around D7, which would make Just unlikely.

Frogsterking

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

It's possible but if Will isn't mafia then Frog must have seen through it but then why kill Bunny? I may have been the doc. Unless Frog saw whatever Will saw and Will has had extremely bad luck.

I think the latter so unlikely it must be Will.

I saw what Just was doing and I thought it looked more like he was trying to draw the NK than crumb doctor, because there was no reason for the real doctor not to stay hidden. I think the only scum motivation would be to prepare to CC the doctor if necessary.

If Just is town, I think the mafia also figured Just was trying to draw the NK.

But why kill Bunny? Why not RB him and kill you. From Frog's pov I may have been doc.

Well I mean you do scumread me for it sooooo

[bozotheclown]

Please ignore the last "Frogsterking".

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Either mafia knew I was killbaiting, or they didn’t see my crumb and killed Bunny anyway

[damo666]

@damo

If the KILLBAIT was obvious to everyone, it wouldn’t have worked anyway

It wasn't obvious to anyone. You only did it so you could reveal it.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

##VOTE DAMO

Frog, if you are scum, you’ve played a near perfect game. And you would be truly, an expert PR hunter

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

@damo

If the KILLBAIT was obvious to everyone, it wouldn’t have worked anyway

It wasn't obvious to anyone. You only did it so you could reveal it.

I revealed it cuz it didn’t work dumbass. Didn’t want people thinking I was actually the doc. Then I’d get miskilled.

But I guess you’re going to kill me anyway, so eh

[bozotheclown]

It's possible but if Will isn't mafia then Frog must have seen through it but then why kill Bunny? I may have been the doc. Unless Frog saw whatever Will saw and Will has had extremely bad luck.

I think the latter so unlikely it must be Will.

I saw what Just was doing and I thought it looked more like he was trying to draw the NK than crumb doctor, because there was no reason for the real doctor not to stay hidden. I think the only scum motivation would be to prepare to CC the doctor if necessary.

If Just is town, I think the mafia also figured Just was trying to draw the NK.

But why kill Bunny? Why not RB him and kill you. From Frog's pov I may have been doc.

Yes, and if Frogsterking was not sure you or BunnyGo was the doctor, he RBed BunnyGo and NKed me, and you were the doctor who had protected me, I would have been saved again and we would have another DK. I think it was optimal for the mafia to RB and NK his best doctor guess, that was the only way to guarantee a NK.

[damo666]

I am not sure what you are saying.

Don't you find Will's doc crumbs and stating it after the reveal when the NK is the doctor and not you as too big a coincidence. Why would scumFrog (or scumdamo) risk killing Bunny who might turn out to be vt eliminating a suspect?

I cannot see that Frog would have seen it and worked it out in time to change his NK on a 50/50 gamble (assuming he sussed Will as a bluff).

It's all too convenient.

If it turns out to be Frog then he has played magnificently and Will has shot himself in the foot.

I think BunnyGo being the NK indicates the mafia thought he was the doctor but was not sure, and did not want to risk RBing BunnyGo and NKing me, which could have given us another mis-kill if BunnyGo was not the doctor and the doctor was targeting me again, as well as letting BunnyGo claim the RB.

Or, the mafia knew BunnyGo was the doctor and just preferred me to be around D7, which would make Just unlikely.

Frogsterking

Frog wouldn't want you around would he?

[damo666]

I saw what Just was doing and I thought it looked more like he was trying to draw the NK than crumb doctor, because there was no reason for the real doctor not to stay hidden. I think the only scum motivation would be to prepare to CC the doctor if necessary.

If Just is town, I think the mafia also figured Just was trying to draw the NK.

But why kill Bunny? Why not RB him and kill you. From Frog's pov I may have been doc.

Yes, and if Frogsterking was not sure you or BunnyGo was the doctor, he RBed BunnyGo and NKed me, and you were the doctor who had protected me, I would have been saved again and we would have another DK. I think it was optimal for the mafia to RB and NK his best doctor guess, that was the only way to guarantee a NK.

Yes that makes sense.

[bozotheclown]

That was a risk since if Bunny was VT doc could claim so scum must have somehow sussed Bunny was doc. Will preparing his doccrumb which would have had no chance of being seen looks manufactured for this reason.

##vote Just

Final Answer

Why do you think Just bussed Hamilton D2?

[bozotheclown]

Don't you find Will's doc crumbs and stating it after the reveal when the NK is the doctor and not you as too big a coincidence. Why would scumFrog (or scumdamo) risk killing Bunny who might turn out to be vt eliminating a suspect?

I cannot see that Frog would have seen it and worked it out in time to change his NK on a 50/50 gamble (assuming he sussed Will as a bluff).

It's all too convenient.

If it turns out to be Frog then he has played magnificently and Will has shot himself in the foot.

I think BunnyGo being the NK indicates the mafia thought he was the doctor but was not sure, and did not want to risk RBing BunnyGo and NKing me, which could have given us another mis-kill if BunnyGo was not the doctor and the doctor was targeting me again, as well as letting BunnyGo claim the RB.

Or, the mafia knew BunnyGo was the doctor and just preferred me to be around D7, which would make Just unlikely.

Frogsterking

Frog wouldn't want you around would he?

No ideally I don't think, but he would not want to risk town getting another DK.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

@bozo
@frog

Please research the game and come to your own conclusions. If you find that it’s likely to be me, then oh well. But I know I played well, and I’m happy about that

[bozotheclown]

##VOTE DAMO

Frog, if you are scum, you’ve played a near perfect game. And you would be truly, an expert PR hunter

Why do you think damo bussed Hamilton D2?

[bozotheclown]

@bozo
@frog

Please research the game and come to your own conclusions. If you find that it’s likely to be me, then oh well. But I know I played well, and I’m happy about that

I think you played a great game regardless of whether you are town or mafia.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

@bozo
@frog

Please research the game and come to your own conclusions. If you find that it’s likely to be me, then oh well. But I know I played well, and I’m happy about that

I think you played a great game regardless of whether you are town or mafia.

Thank you! But since you think I’m town, that means I played a good town game to you