Mafia 86: Accidents Happen... - Game Thread

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I just don’t wanna be the miskill to lose the game like M83.

If damo is setting up a Kakarroto win, then that would be very fitting for me lol

[bozotheclown]

Bozo: wallpost and your next question.

Frogsterking's long post was a good defense, but I think the scum motivation for bringing up that post I made about Hamilton's D2 EOD vote is more likely than the town motivated reasons he provided.

Also, I think the evidence points to Frogsterking being the remaining mafia.

You don't have to talk about me like I'm not here; that's how you got tunneled in the first place lol. I am going back on desktop so I can respond to the other thing you noticed. This conclusion about "more or less likely" you are only arriving at because you are assuming a priori that I am scum. There is no evidence against my slot which doesn't get shredded by logic.

The thing all of your scum!frog posts are missing: you can deduce that the final scum player has a good enough range so you need to figure out what would motivate a scum player with a good range to vote out the godfather D1. There is only one theory posited in this game which resolves this.

The evidence I was referring to was everyone except you voting for Hamilton D2. Why do you think damo or Just would bus Hamilton D2?

[damo666]

The not doc was also hinting he was doc.

Will you're caught.

Unlucky.

He is saying he was doing that to try to get the mafia to think he was the doctor. Do you not think that is possible?

It's possible but if Will isn't mafia then Frog must have seen through it but then why kill Bunny? I may have been the doc. Unless Frog saw whatever Will saw and Will has had extremely bad luck.

I think the latter so unlikely it must be Will.

[bozotheclown]

If Frog were scum he'd have seen Will's nondoc and assumed either Bunny or I was doc, RBd one of us and killed Bozo.

It has to be Will.

@Bozo I'm right aren't I?

Bunny being the NK changes everything.

I am not sure what you are saying.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

@damo

If I were in this situation as mafia, I would RB Bunny and kill bozo. Now my #1 defender is alive and Frog has plenty of suspicion on him.

[bozotheclown]

The not doc was also hinting he was doc.

Will you're caught.

Unlucky.

He is saying he was doing that to try to get the mafia to think he was the doctor. Do you not think that is possible?

It's possible but if Will isn't mafia then Frog must have seen through it but then why kill Bunny? I may have been the doc. Unless Frog saw whatever Will saw and Will has had extremely bad luck.

I think the latter so unlikely it must be Will.

Did you know BunnyGo was the doctor?

[damo666]

No

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Can’t really tell us damo is bad town or has been setting up a miskill for a while.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Can’t really tell us damo is bad town or has been setting up a miskill for a while.

if*

[bozotheclown]

As you all can see, the first letter of the first two sentences of each paragraph spell KILLBAIT

I was subtly trying to hint that I was the doc

I thought you were talking about the "Not doc" part. Why did you do that?

To try and bair the night kill so doc could claim

That is what I assumed but I was wondering about the other crumb, since the "Not doc" part seemed obvious enough.

[Frogsterking]

Looking only at the voting, Just, Frogsterking, BunnyGo, and damo were the first 4 votes on sweetandcool D1. However, Just, BunnyGo, and damo all voted for Hamilton D2 EOD when the DK was not decided (and while I was trying to prevent the Hamilton DK), while Frogsterking voted off the wagons.

The important part is understanding why a scum player with a good range would vote out the godfather D1.

As I said previously, I believe you thought sweetandcool was under to much pressure already.

That doesn't make any sense?

[bozotheclown]

No

Did you have any idea on who the doctor was?

[bozotheclown]

The important part is understanding why a scum player with a good range would vote out the godfather D1.

As I said previously, I believe you thought sweetandcool was under to much pressure already.

That doesn't make any sense?

Why, the GF is not any good if he gets DKed D2.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I thought you were talking about the "Not doc" part. Why did you do that?

To try and bair the night kill so doc could claim

That is what I assumed but I was wondering about the other crumb, since the "Not doc" part seemed obvious enough.

Which crumb? I was hinting for a lot of the previous night

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Can someone please check on my scumtell?

My scumtell vote on sweet was genuine. I saw a pattern and played accordingly

[damo666]

If Frog were scum he'd have seen Will's nondoc and assumed either Bunny or I was doc, RBd one of us and killed Bozo.

It has to be Will.

@Bozo I'm right aren't I?

Bunny being the NK changes everything.

I am not sure what you are saying.

Don't you find Will's doc crumbs and stating it after the reveal when the NK is the doctor and not you as too big a coincidence. Why would scumFrog (or scumdamo) risk killing Bunny who might turn out to be vt eliminating a suspect?

I cannot see that Frog would have seen it and worked it out in time to change his NK on a 50/50 gamble (assuming he sussed Will as a bluff).

It's all too convenient.

If it turns out to be Frog then he has played magnificently and Will has shot himself in the foot.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

The reason I was gonna wait to do my reads and say my scumtell was because I was hoping mafia would kill me to keep that info secret.

Damo has to be setting up a miskill.

[bozotheclown]

The not doc was also hinting he was doc.

Will you're caught.

Unlucky.

He is saying he was doing that to try to get the mafia to think he was the doctor. Do you not think that is possible?

It's possible but if Will isn't mafia then Frog must have seen through it but then why kill Bunny? I may have been the doc. Unless Frog saw whatever Will saw and Will has had extremely bad luck.

I think the latter so unlikely it must be Will.

I saw what Just was doing and I thought it looked more like he was trying to draw the NK than crumb doctor, because there was no reason for the real doctor not to stay hidden. I think the only scum motivation would be to prepare to CC the doctor if necessary.

If Just is town, I think the mafia also figured Just was trying to draw the NK.

[damo666]

No

Did you have any idea on who the doctor was?

I suspected it was Bunny

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

If Frog were scum he'd have seen Will's nondoc and assumed either Bunny or I was doc, RBd one of us and killed Bozo.

It has to be Will.

@Bozo I'm right aren't I?

Bunny being the NK changes everything.

I am not sure what you are saying.

Don't you find Will's doc crumbs and stating it after the reveal when the NK is the doctor and not you as too big a coincidence. Why would scumFrog (or scumdamo) risk killing Bunny who might turn out to be vt eliminating a suspect?

I cannot see that Frog would have seen it and worked it out in time to change his NK on a 50/50 gamble (assuming he sussed Will as a bluff).

It's all too convenient.

If it turns out to be Frog then he has played magnificently and Will has shot himself in the foot.

I was genuine. You have shot the entire town in the foot. If Frog hops on me it will be a miraculous occurrence you lived so long to set up the mk, damo.