Mafia 86: Accidents Happen... - Game Thread

[brainbomb]

I mostly want to see what happens when Will no longer has me to false tunnel, and hes forced to regularly voice to others why someone not named bb is mafia. Once that happens I have a strong suspicion it will be overwhelmingly obvious to others that this guy would say just about anything or shade just about anyone and there is zero substance to his posts

[brainbomb]

his play this game has been to just keep talking as much as possible and treat anyone being serious like they are just mistaken or its all a joke to him.

[BunnyGo]

I won’t be back again. Gave you my reads. Come try to kill me again tomorrow.

[Frogsterking]

Will what do you find most scummy about chaqa

Read on Chaqster:

Chaqa: Chaqa has been inconsistent. On D1 he did that whole charade with brian, which I thought had a small chance of being scum theater, but obviously we know it isn’t. Chaqa voted sweet at a time after sweet was leading, which looks like mafia make a last second decision to bus, much like Ghug. He voted damo earlier, which I don’t like as well, but at the time, damo was not towncore like he is now. D2, he votes bozo alone. This is very suspicious, as he never made moves, and it seemed to me like he was really reluctant to vote Hamilton, and just tried to fade away into the background and hope Hamilton didn’t get booted. SCUMLEAN

Why do you keep caling it a charade? This is the second or third time you’ve done that.

That's right, let's be respectful and call it the chaqade.

[ghug]

Read on Chaqster:

Chaqa: Chaqa has been inconsistent. On D1 he did that whole charade with brian, which I thought had a small chance of being scum theater, but obviously we know it isn’t. Chaqa voted sweet at a time after sweet was leading, which looks like mafia make a last second decision to bus, much like Ghug. He voted damo earlier, which I don’t like as well, but at the time, damo was not towncore like he is now. D2, he votes bozo alone. This is very suspicious, as he never made moves, and it seemed to me like he was really reluctant to vote Hamilton, and just tried to fade away into the background and hope Hamilton didn’t get booted. SCUMLEAN

Why do you keep caling it a charade? This is the second or third time you’ve done that.

That's right, let's be respectful and call it the chaqade.

That name is already taken by the Chipotle margarita mix.

[Frogsterking]

Their play fits exactly in the narrative.

Bozo refusing to vote his teammate HB to save his life (its an autoloss vs 9 town including a cop/doc)

HB refusing to vote his teammate Bozo to save his life

Bozo spinning this whole narrative to only focus on the bussers. He had to. Everyone killing the GF was TOWN.

This is a good example of how evidence can support the wrong conclusion. It is also why Hamilton had me fooled, he protected me and ended up getting himself DKed for doing so, not what I expected from one of the remaining mafia.

I wonder what it means if I hear villain music playing every time I read a bozotheclown post.

[Frogsterking]

Why do you keep caling it a charade? This is the second or third time you’ve done that.

That's right, let's be respectful and call it the chaqade.

That name is already taken by the Chipotle margarita mix.

LOL

[BunnyGo]

I’d hardly call some of the reasoning you all used to vote Sweet a masterclass.

Damo voted him because he hadn’t moved his vote

Vecna voted him because he didn’t want to vote Bunny or Damo

Will found a scumtell which maybe could be considered a “masterclass” but id need to get some more perspective on it

I definitely have a soapbox here as the most miskilled person in WebDip history, but generally I don’t think there’s anything special to how these two mafia were caught

I’m too pretty to kill

[BunnyGo]

You had a bad stretch where?








Do you believe Bunny, brainbomb and I are the scum team or are you just unhappy to see us?

aged GREAT for froggy

I really fucked up D2

I didn’t have time to do N1/D2

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I found it. I think it doesn’t matter. Ghug has differing reads from mine, but I do not scumread him for it.

You found it? the post where ghug has different reads?

New evidence: these posts indicate a lack of reading

Will, when you read this you first called it cherry picking on my part. but you also think food is scum. So why did you dismiss these parts of foods reads list at the time?

and then when I asked you what you thought of foods reads list you made some comment about ghug and I never asked you about ghug at all?

I dismissed his criticisms because they were based on the assumption sweet was town. Sweet was not town. Therefore his criticisms were invalid.

I used ghug as an example, I guess I didn’t make that clear, and that is on me.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

VOTE COUNT 1.4 "Maybe I should actually use the bot and not miss a vote like I did with Bunny, which was not intentionally, I'm sorry, [insert theme of the game]"-edition

BunnyGo (3) - sweetandcool, foodcoats, damo666
foodcoats (3) - brainbomb, ghug, BunnyGo
sweetandcool (1) - JustAGuyNamedWill
bozotheclown (1) - Jamiet99uk
Chaqa (1) - Vecna



No one seems to be getting involved with involuntary contact with the thresher machine.


Looks like everyone has met posting requirements.

Five people still need to vote or face something unexpected.

About 3 hours an 15 minutes left for day one.

I don’t particularly like Bunny as the leading wagon. 2 votes, sure. But leading? This gives off hella darg vibes from M1027

I have a feeling that the sweet wagon isn’t going anywhere.

I don’t want to waste my vote on someone who’s wagon has no traction.

I think this is Bunny, realizing he is fucked if he doesn’t do something, trying to appeal to brain’s suspicion of me.

Hard scumread on sweet, but no one else seems to think so.

##VOTE BUNNY

Not necessarily one big reason, more like a compounding of little reasons.

Man, what the heck is this wishy-washy shit.

Frog, then me, then sweet, then ghug, then food, then back to me, then Frog?

Just in case anyone wanted to know why I still think Will is the last mafia

I’ll pay off to it. Will can keep me alive to EOG and guarantee a win.

Will smirked with a devilish grin. Had Bunny made his path to victory so obvious? A fool, Will thought XD.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

As much as town would like to go for a clean sweep win, I think eliminating myself or will tomorrow ensures that you wont have to deal with either of us in endgame.

Scan one of the two of us, and kill the other. that is my suggestion

Nah I'm going with noble plan Everyone* Gets Out Alive

I am fairly confident that brain or bozo is the last one, so we may guess wrong and have another of us killed.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

his play this game has been to just keep talking as much as possible and treat anyone being serious like they are just mistaken or its all a joke to him.

I guess so. Works for me, town is going to win.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I mostly want to see what happens when Will no longer has me to false tunnel, and hes forced to regularly voice to others why someone not named bb is mafia. Once that happens I have a strong suspicion it will be overwhelmingly obvious to others that this guy would say just about anything or shade just about anyone and there is zero substance to his posts

If you die and flip town, then I do bozo. Simple. But I don’t think mafia is going to get past a brain flip.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

If Bunny is mafia, congratulations.

Just in case anyone wanted to know why I still think Will is the last mafia

I’ll pay off to it. Will can keep me alive to EOG and guarantee a win.

Will smirked with a devilish grin. Had Bunny made his path to victory so obvious? A fool, Will thought XD.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I’ll pay off to it. Will can keep me alive to EOG and guarantee a win.

Will smirked with a devilish grin. Had Bunny made his path to victory so obvious? A fool, Will thought XD.

The quotes of this post got screwed up. Disregard

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

VOTE COUNT 1.4 "Maybe I should actually use the bot and not miss a vote like I did with Bunny, which was not intentionally, I'm sorry, [insert theme of the game]"-edition

BunnyGo (3) - sweetandcool, foodcoats, damo666
foodcoats (3) - brainbomb, ghug, BunnyGo
sweetandcool (1) - JustAGuyNamedWill
bozotheclown (1) - Jamiet99uk
Chaqa (1) - Vecna



No one seems to be getting involved with involuntary contact with the thresher machine.


Looks like everyone has met posting requirements.

Five people still need to vote or face something unexpected.

About 3 hours an 15 minutes left for day one.

I don’t particularly like Bunny as the leading wagon. 2 votes, sure. But leading? This gives off hella darg vibes from M1027

I have a feeling that the sweet wagon isn’t going anywhere.

I don’t want to waste my vote on someone who’s wagon has no traction.

I think this is Bunny, realizing he is fucked if he doesn’t do something, trying to appeal to brain’s suspicion of me.

Hard scumread on sweet, but no one else seems to think so.

##VOTE BUNNY

Not necessarily one big reason, more like a compounding of little reasons.

Man, what the heck is this wishy-washy shit.

Frog, then me, then sweet, then ghug, then food, then back to me, then Frog?

Just in case anyone wanted to know why I still think Will is the last mafia

I’ll pay off to it. Will can keep me alive to EOG and guarantee a win.

Touche. If Bunny is scum I will be thoroughly shocked.

[Frogsterking]

aged GREAT for froggy

I really fucked up D2

I didn’t have time to do N1/D2

I didn't do great, these posts are funny though IMO:

I am going to try my best Frog, since there's some suspicion swirling around them.

1) How much time elapsed between your deciding to vote sweet and actually casting the vote?
2) What was your clear-cut 100 proof factor in Sweet's play that informed your decision that they were scum?
3) When you got your PM did you decide to distance or closely buddy your teammates? Which ones?
4) What is your biggest criticism of your D1 play? What was your reaction when Jamie suggested that your reads were coming too early in the game? Did that alter your plans?

I'm assuming night ends at 6 pm EST, correct me if I'm wrong please. I'm at work and I've been thinking about the game.

@darg (heart replacement)
@hamilton brian

#1 What do you know about the bussers on the sweet wagon?
#2 Is it possible sweet spewed anything of interest on your respective slots?
#3 Is there anything else you need to tell me about your D1 play?

1) I don't know anything about the bussers on sweet wagon. I don't even know that there are any. I think we can assume there are some; those 7 out of 11 voters suggest to me the odds are pretty good. The last five names are an interesting mix.

2) It's possible but nothing I've picked up on. We seem to have a mutual antipathy toward one another through past games where I deem them scum and vice versa. To my knowledge it's only worked out one time in my favour. I feel like I was willing to give them a little more leash this game.

3) I don't know; what specifically?

@ghug
@darg

#1

How did the sweet (godfather) elimination affect your plans for this game?

#2

Is there any possibility ghug was distancing from sweet d1 and didn't actually want to kill sweet?

#3

What have you noticed about each other that you haven't shared?

1) not at all. I think I would have been townreading him though. But i haven't really thought through his case.
2) sure. He voted sweet early, iirc. He might have been making himself look good. But that doesn't prove his scum. Just something he would do IF scum.
3) i like his abs, his sweet smile, and his collection of butterflies.

Frog, have you considered that asking a lot of deep questions during the night aids scum?

[brainbomb]

I expect you guys to teach new players good habits.

telling them that vanity wagons are scummy is just categorically untrue on any forum anywhere in the world where they play mafia. it is a regular thing, and a part of the game. Dogpiling onto someone with 7 and 9 wagons in games with 14 players provides zero information to anyone, its just a giant pile of assholes most of the time. in no way is that more meaningful or telling of anything at all

[brainbomb]

Now if there are entrenched ties, and the vote is close, then I agree that if a whole bunch of players are on vanity wagons this is problematic. watching season 1 of traitors where every day phase was always 2 wagons and no deviation, thats how the bad guys coasted in that season for so long. I wont tell you who won it but town legit would always just only ever vote down party lines, and both lines were almost always town vs town.