Mafia 86: Accidents Happen... - Game Thread

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

GM Note:
Consider this a formal announcement that the following things are not to be done during the game:

1. Editing the names in a post quote
2. Editing the contents of a post after it is made

I won't use any names, but you know who you are. Stop doing these things.

worcej warned the person who was doing this 9 minutes before he died.

I hate to do this but scum straight up must have changed the nightkill in those last 9 minutes, because worcej would not have probably worried about this if the person hes warning is just dying

Can we come back to this? I feel like this was forgotten.

[Chaqa]

If brain is town, knowing I am town, I could see Chaqa being scum here trying to get points for asking cooler heads to prevail. Chaqa certainly hasn't really done anything for town.

This is awful rich when you didn't vote for Sweet.

You said you would not vote for sweet yesterday and then you did. I misread sweet, but you made an inconsistent and opportunistic vote.

You're treating me as if I'm guilty of voting out a town member, but my "opportunistic" vote helped kill a mafia.

Being inconsistent is not a mafia trait, it's a town one. Mafia are careful to cross their teas and dot their eyes. Town are not.

[Vecna]

As of right now I want to continue with my gut. I've done some following with brain's thinking but I don't know if I am ready to run on to Food. I felt this way on D1 and right now I feel it D2.

##Vote BunnyGo

Why not vote me if you think my reasoning for scumreading you is fabricated?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

This is awful rich when you didn't vote for Sweet.

You said you would not vote for sweet yesterday and then you did. I misread sweet, but you made an inconsistent and opportunistic vote.

You're treating me as if I'm guilty of voting out a town member, but my "opportunistic" vote helped kill a mafia.

Being inconsistent is not a mafia trait, it's a town one. Mafia are careful to cross their teas and dot their eyes. Town are not.

Lol

[Vecna]

I dno, I suddenly feel pretty bored with this game.

All this yapping about the bussing is so corny and uninteresting. Like theres suddenly no other way to get to some reads.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I dno, I suddenly feel pretty bored with this game.

All this yapping about the bussing is so corny and uninteresting. Like theres suddenly no other way to get to some reads.

Nooooo. We should make a voting bloc with damo and Frog. Nooooo

[BunnyGo]

@Bunny
@brain

Could you guys give us an all-encompassing reads list?

Later. At work catching up as I can between meetings and writing.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

@Bunny
@brain

Could you guys give us an all-encompassing reads list?

Later. At work catching up as I can between meetings and writing.

No worries. Ive definitely got a lot more free time then yall

[BunnyGo]

If brain is town, knowing I am town, I could see Chaqa being scum here trying to get points for asking cooler heads to prevail. Chaqa certainly hasn't really done anything for town.

This is awful rich when you didn't vote for Sweet.

You said you would not vote for sweet yesterday and then you did. I misread sweet, but you made an inconsistent and opportunistic vote.

He said it was because he loves me more.

Fellow urban cyclists unite!

[BunnyGo]

I dno, I suddenly feel pretty bored with this game.

All this yapping about the bussing is so corny and uninteresting. Like theres suddenly no other way to get to some reads.

How are you so perfectly mimicking my emotions and thoughts this game. I KNEW I was right to be waiting for you.

I miss Jamie and EMC. Need some graphics of a rabbit doodling with the “i”s all dotted with hearts.

[foodcoats]

This is awful rich when you didn't vote for Sweet.

You said you would not vote for sweet yesterday and then you did. I misread sweet, but you made an inconsistent and opportunistic vote.

You're treating me as if I'm guilty of voting out a town member, but my "opportunistic" vote helped kill a mafia.

Being inconsistent is not a mafia trait, it's a town one. Mafia are careful to cross their teas and dot their eyes. Town are not.

That's true, and when you voted it was only 5-4 sweet / Bunny, so if you really felt that way about Bunny, it makes sense. It was unlikely a final ditch bus for credit. You get a townie point after all.

[BunnyGo]

Note for reading later:

Possible pairs:

Brain-Ham
Ghug-Ham
Frog-food
Dargothrob-Brain

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Note for reading later:

Possible pairs:

Brain-Ham
Ghug-Ham
Frog-food
Dargothrob-Brain

Brain Ham is what I think. Both are equally suspicious

[damo666]

Note for reading later:

Possible pairs:

Brain-Ham
Ghug-Ham
Frog-food
Dargothrob-Brain

Yuk no

What about Ham dargo

And what about Bozo?

[ghug]

For the record I don’t think I’ve made anything personal. I think what are you doing is bad for town. It’s just business.

I mean, you've outed yourself as town in response to our tomfoolery, so I consider it good for town.

Brain doesn't agree, but alas.

Can you confirm you are saying you are NOT the cop?

Why do you think the way I responded was scummy and not townie?

I'm not saying I am the cop.

I think the way you responded was towny and not scummy.

[ghug]

Food just seems relieved it isnt a real scan.

Right, but he clearly believed I was serious scum fakeclaiming and challenged me to commit to it. Given that he didn't understand what was happening, I find it hard to believe he'd fake that response so well as scum.

Okay, you claim you are town and fakeclaimed. Personally I think that is an awful thing for town to do for several reasons. Can you explain why you thought it would help town win?

Honestly, I didn't think anyone would take me seriously because I was just playing off brain. That you did was a happy accident.

I can't speak to brain's motivations.

[brainbomb]

There are two scum voting me. I can absolutely promise you that. They are desperate and frothing at the mouth to get me out. All three of these players on me have been desperate to see me die from game start. One of these three is town. The other two are not. This is what mafia has based their entire game around.

The case for each.
Will is scum because when he was the last voter on sweet he began shopping every other option possible, and moved to vote alongside sweet instead. When sweet sees that he has no choice to call it out. It looks bad. So sweet says will is scum at that point.
They both back and forth keep saying each other is scum, then will realizes that he needs to move back to sweet to maintain the wagons, which at the time were hamilton-bunny-heart-food.

The argument for why food could be town:
counter wagon to sweet, pushed by scum bunny?

Overall I think the fight between sweet and bunny reads like a co fight, maybe will wanted to also get in on that action and just bungled a perfect opportunity.

when bunny sees me posturing as cop, he votes will and end votes anticipating that I scanned his buddy.

Bunny calls me naughty for claiming so soon but doesnt know who I scanned.

The vote for will could be a good look here is bunny is mafia and will isnt. but up to then bunny had been openly guiding will in the thread which is less a w/w thing to do. so this could just be wolf bunny painting will as a target or bunny wanting me to bite on it to verify im not really a cop.

Food has a great case for being scum, and it stands. it still feels like the more obvious answer but then who among bunny and will is actually town. I cant come up with an answer for which is town if food flips mafia.

If will is scum I think bunny is just his scum partner and food probably is town, and most of this is that maybe at SOD 2, bunny thought I had a guilty on will and was just like... shit, I gotta do this, were fucked now.
(I actually dont think this is the case though, for whatever reason) (like my brain just keeps saying that will is so scummy, too scummy to even be real, but his play is all just shading and mental games.)

eliminating me is a suitable option. I absolutely need to be dead and know that I was right. and when I am right, please be aware, that if you told me I was wrong at some point on foodcoats. I will remind you for the rest of your natural life that I had it all along.

(My vote is staying here, there is an overwhelming body of evidence that food is mafia, and one of my voters is just playing a really bad game here)

[brainbomb]

nah screw it. It has to be will here. at least foods posts are not jokes

##vote will

[ghug]

Anyone role blocked will be sent a "You were Roleblocked!" message,

Yes, non-PR targets will receive that message.

A saved person will be notified they woke up with a bunch of bandages on them (something like that - don't quote me yet)

A cop will be told the alignment of the scanned individual. Reminder - the Godfather role scans as town.

We have an uncc roleblocked claim lol, that's kind of cool.

It's worth noting that the webDip meta is often to roleblock the nightkill to shield this information. I believe food in this instance, bit it's far from a free townie.

[ghug]

Well, review the math I posted above. If the cop actually had a guilty scan there would be no reason to withhold it. I wasn’t PR hunting, I was testing to see if ghug was fakeclaiming scum, because a real town cop with a guilty scan can greatly simplify things for town and there is no benefit to holding the scan to EON2.

It seems to me that ghug was fake fake-claiming. Does that make a difference to you? Innuendo is not fake claiming. I also still don't see that he was faking a claim on YOU, until you responded to him. He implied (maybe) your guilt because you pushed back on him. That is how I read the sequence of events.

Ghug said he had a guilty scan and then voted for me. Bozo also jumped on that wagon. Since I know my alignment and ghug cannot possibly have a guilty scan on me, I fought back.

I am curious to hear from bozo.