M1027: Community - Game Thread

[BK3K]

This is insane. This is BK and sweet trying to deflect (and Chaqa too for some reason)

Holy shit, you had me coming along with you until 3 posts ago. If your plan is guaranteed, why not let people prove it? What's the rush of it's perfect? You went from my most town to my most scum in less than a page.

[BK3K]

##VOTE ghug
##END

Peace out, friends, and please hold.

You have to play to win

[heartthrob24909]

REVISED EDITION bc I cannot spell

INVESTIGATE SWEET/ BK3K PLAN
——————————————————
(I will be using (A) as an example of the investigator’s target and sweet as the community target for simplicity’s sake)

In any case: ghug will be killed and someone else will as well. This leaves it 5-2 at the beginning of D5

OPTION 1: (A) was found be the investigator to be a DIFFERENT ALIGNMENT from sweet
In this scenario it is smartest to kill (A). If (A) is found to be mafia, we have two confirmed clears. This means we would have 4-1 going into D6 with one confirmed clear (if mafia is smart enough to kill one of the clears)

If (A), after being killed, is found to be town, we win the game, as that would mean BK and sweet are the two remaining mafia

OPTION 2: (A) was found by the investigator to be the SAME ALIGNMENT as sweet

In this scenario we have three confirmed clears [BK,
sweet, and (A)], and one investigator who (at that point if they were not NKed), should reveal themselves. We
would then have 4 clears in a 5-2 scenario. We win the game by process of elimination.

Oversights I see which I want to throw out in the interest of speed, and then will consider implications:
- fake investigator claims
- the investigation target "(A)" also being the nightkill

[Chaqa]

We should cease posting until Bunny can process the hammer.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Jesus these arguments do not discredit my plan. @BK do you think my plan should be implemented if we get a scan the same night the investigator is killed?

[heartthrob24909]

Why rush it? If it's as guaranteed as you say, let's prove it out

Agreed.

Anyways, I'm confident that Will's plan is bad unless GM verifies that the investigation goes through.

If necessary, I will show why it's bad, but it has actually already been covered.

Instead, I'm going to focus on showing why my method works, since we're apparently eager to end and just fuck ourselves for no reason.

Please. You're the only one I trust. Everyone, please unend. It's scummy to try to rush us without thinking it through.

Agree

Let's not forget that we can also solve this the old fashioned way... reading through old posts. Which I, at least, am hoping to have some time for now that I'm back at work

[BK3K]

We should cease posting until Bunny can process the hammer.

Bunny is watching Rashoman

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

REVISED EDITION bc I cannot spell

INVESTIGATE SWEET/ BK3K PLAN
——————————————————
(I will be using (A) as an example of the investigator’s target and sweet as the community target for simplicity’s sake)

In any case: ghug will be killed and someone else will as well. This leaves it 5-2 at the beginning of D5

OPTION 1: (A) was found be the investigator to be a DIFFERENT ALIGNMENT from sweet
In this scenario it is smartest to kill (A). If (A) is found to be mafia, we have two confirmed clears. This means we would have 4-1 going into D6 with one confirmed clear (if mafia is smart enough to kill one of the clears)

If (A), after being killed, is found to be town, we win the game, as that would mean BK and sweet are the two remaining mafia

OPTION 2: (A) was found by the investigator to be the SAME ALIGNMENT as sweet

In this scenario we have three confirmed clears [BK,
sweet, and (A)], and one investigator who (at that point if they were not NKed), should reveal themselves. We
would then have 4 clears in a 5-2 scenario. We win the game by process of elimination.

Oversights I see which I want to throw out in the interest of speed, and then will consider implications:
- fake investigator claims
- the investigation target "(A)" also being the nightkill

1. Fake investigator claims: Now there are two people, and one is lying. We caught one mafia at least.
2. (A)- now we know the alignment of sweet and BK, and the investigator can now reveal.

[ghug]

We should cease posting until Bunny can process the hammer.

[BunnyGo]

I’m told the day has been hammered. PLEASE HOLD.

[sweetandcool]

Bunch of lousy morons.

[Chaqa]

No, seriously.

Quit posting.

[heartthrob24909]

REVISED EDITION bc I cannot spell

INVESTIGATE SWEET/ BK3K PLAN
——————————————————
(I will be using (A) as an example of the investigator’s target and sweet as the community target for simplicity’s sake)

In any case: ghug will be killed and someone else will as well. This leaves it 5-2 at the beginning of D5

OPTION 1: (A) was found be the investigator to be a DIFFERENT ALIGNMENT from sweet
In this scenario it is smartest to kill (A). If (A) is found to be mafia, we have two confirmed clears. This means we would have 4-1 going into D6 with one confirmed clear (if mafia is smart enough to kill one of the clears)

If (A), after being killed, is found to be town, we win the game, as that would mean BK and sweet are the two remaining mafia

OPTION 2: (A) was found by the investigator to be the SAME ALIGNMENT as sweet

In this scenario we have three confirmed clears [BK,
sweet, and (A)], and one investigator who (at that point if they were not NKed), should reveal themselves. We
would then have 4 clears in a 5-2 scenario. We win the game by process of elimination.

Oversights I see which I want to throw out in the interest of speed, and then will consider implications:
- fake investigator claims
- the investigation target "(A)" also being the nightkill

1. Fake investigator claims: Now there are two people, and one is lying. We caught one mafia at least.
2. (A)- now we know the alignment of sweet and BK, and the investigator can now reveal.

2 no longer has the airtight numerical advantage that makes this plan "perfect" though.

[BunnyGo]

End of day 4

His mom was in the ER. She’d not taken her medication; she hadn’t picked them up and then stubbornly not told anyone.

This was her way of telling him he was missed. It was sick, it was petty, and it made him feel awful.

DAY HAS ENDED EARLY

GHUG HAS DIED HE WAS MAFIA SCUM

Night will end in 21 hours.

You may now post.

[BunnyGo]

DEADLINE HAS MOVED 2 D EARLIER

[heartthrob24909]

So, what was the point of hammering that? Felt unnecessary

[sweetandcool]

All end voters are super suspicious. Mafia plan worked like a charm and it makes me sick.

WTF guys?

##CALL GM

If the investigator is night killed, do we still get the result of his investigation?

[sweetandcool]

I'm not going to, but I really want to go on a Jamiet style rage rampage.

Okay, just going to try to play the game now, no more complaining.

[heartthrob24909]

I can't tell if that mech business was town on town garbage or mafia garbage. I didn't like that at all. I also don't think VTs have come anywhere near a consensus on how to direct their target so was it really worth it?

[BK3K]

I can't tell if that mech business was town on town garbage or mafia garbage. I didn't like that at all. I also don't think VTs have come anywhere near a consensus on how to direct their target so was it really worth it?

It wasn't worth it. And I don't get why Just cared so much. Everything bugs me about it