M1027: Community - Game Thread

[sweetandcool]

Sweet and Jamie had an altercation last night that I, in a very surprising turn of events, sided with Jamie on.

Then sweet has been weird again this morning.

I really wish bunny was in this game, he would understand.

Have you read his notes in the godthread for other Mafia games? He frequently reads people's alignment, ignoring the fact as Mafia or spectator he would know it.

I am baffled so many people on this website think it is impossible to make alignment reads as Mafia.

It's a weird way to describe it, but I get what you're talking about.

Is your persona supposed to be Bunny? Please don't be Bunny.

Howdy!! Na, I'm not bunny, just a coincidence that they are a good example.

[BK3K]

I'm on page 43 but also drunk. Probably not going to bother finishing catching up until tomorrow

[Hamilton Brian]

##vote ghug

Gotta start somewhere

I recognize that ghug did get a vote but only 1 and it was there very briefly. Main point of my thought is we avoid HB, Jamie, and Just at least to start

I'm probably a fine vote but we should not be avoiding people because they got attention yesterday. They're the ones we have more info on.

##VOTE Ham

A little drunk, a little high (maybe), but stoked that I got my bass player friend to open up on Miles Davis' So What. Just hanging on those two chords and hitting the pentatonics.

Then this shit. C'mon my pxychedeilic godson. WTF?

[Hamilton Brian]

##VOTE bozotheclown

Ordinarily love this guy but this gaem;;;; something on

[dargorygel]

Hi... rip damo, well played.

Been footballing with family. Not dine.

See you tomorrow.

I like bozi's push on ghug for now.

##vote ghuggles

[sweetandcool]

##VOTE bozotheclown

Ordinarily love this guy but this gaem;;;; something on

Bozo is allowed to be wrong.

[sweetandcool]

##VOTE bozotheclown

Ordinarily love this guy but this gaem;;;; something on

Bozo is allowed to be wrong.

But I really am thinking there is a chance Bozo is Mafia. I'm going to have to spend time building a case, but I think I will ##VOTE Bozo

[BunnyGo]

Day 2 Vote Count 1

Tom sat at the bar waiting for Adrienne to show up. After cancelling on her for several nights in a row, he was glad to be available. Tom looked around the restaurant, saw all the happy people–couples, families, friends–he enjoyed sitting there imagining their stories. But every time he saw someone look his way, he imagined their thoughts about him: the weirdo alone at the bar; the creep scoping people out. He kept thinking about leaving, he hated this place, but wasn't going to stand Adrienne up again.

Then he got the text from her saying she wouldn't be coming.

Tom paid his bill, tipping well out of guilt instead of generosity, and left.

ghug (2) heartthrob24909 dargorygel
sweetandcool (2) JustAGuyNamedWill TheMadMonarch
bozotheclown (2) Hamilton Brian sweetandcool
Hamilton Brian (1) ghug

Many people still have to post enough and vote enough, but the day is young. Day ends in about 44 hours.

[Chaqa]

Ya'll are playing checkers while I am playing chess.

I'm playing Lethal Company

[ghug]

I recognize that ghug did get a vote but only 1 and it was there very briefly. Main point of my thought is we avoid HB, Jamie, and Just at least to start

I'm probably a fine vote but we should not be avoiding people because they got attention yesterday. They're the ones we have more info on.

##VOTE Ham

A little drunk, a little high (maybe), but stoked that I got my bass player friend to open up on Miles Davis' So What. Just hanging on those two chords and hitting the pentatonics.

Then this shit. C'mon my pxychedeilic godson. WTF?

You're scummy, and wiith damo and darg resolved, you're the most interesting thing left about D1.

[ghug]

Hi... rip damo, well played.

Been footballing with family. Not dine.

See you tomorrow.

I like bozi's push on ghug for now.

##vote ghuggles

Bozi's what now?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

What altercation are you referring to?

Just posted it

OK, so you agree that sweetandcool saying he always scum reads Just looks suspicious?

How? He has been scum 2/2 times I played previously?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Somehow this exchange makes me think it was scripted in the mafia chat as a planned bus of sweetandcool.

It really does look that way. How unfortunate if you believe that though.

We do not want two MK in a row, this is just Will being Will.

Either way, Just's point is valid.

First time I genuinely win an argument and now its scripted

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

It really does look that way. How unfortunate if you believe that though.

We do not want two MK in a row, this is just Will being Will.

Either way, Just's point is valid.

I feel like I'm living in the twilight zone, this makes absolutely no sense.

I'll spell it out for you, but I really am getting tired of explaining obvious things.

1. damo strongly suggests we don't DK him, that it is a big mistake.

Practically anyone is going to take that as him sitting the investigator role.
If he really is investigator this is incredibly bad play, particularly because he was far from guaranteed to be the DK (but yes, under some pressure).

Consequently we must conclude one of three things (for Mafia only two).

A. Damo pulled a worcej and PR claimed under some pressure.
B. Damo is bluffing in an attempt to eat a NK.
C. Damo is Mafia trying to forestall his demise.

I would expect Mafia to conclude B because A is unlikely and it is so damo-like. It is incredibly interesting that Mafia was naive enough to conclude A (or at least treat it as enough of a possibility that it would be worth a NK).

It is more tricky for town because we were stuck trying to decide between B or C.

If damo had come under pressure D2 (if he is investigator then why is he not the NK?), I would have tried to ensure his survival another day. This would have ensured that if he was town that Mafia would feel pressure to NK him N2 or in the case he was Mafia we would have felt comfortable voting him D3.

So yeah, damo was obviously not the investigator.

D. You are reading too much into it. If I was worried about being a Day Kill and I was town i would say they’re making a big mistake, because I am not mafia. Sweet has shot himself in the foot so much at this point that I’m surprised he’s still alive.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Sweet and Jamie had an altercation last night that I, in a very surprising turn of events, sided with Jamie on.

Then sweet has been weird again this morning.

I really wish bunny was in this game, he would understand.

Have you read his notes in the godthread for other Mafia games? He frequently reads people's alignment, ignoring the fact as Mafia or spectator he would know it.

I am baffled so many people on this website think it is impossible to make alignment reads as Mafia.

I can with 100% accuracy. I’m pretty dang good sweet, tied for first with literally everyone that has ever played.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Ya'll are playing checkers while I am playing chess.

Sweet chess is boring.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Ya'll are playing checkers while I am playing chess.

I'm playing Lethal Company

I love Lethal!
@Bunny this is a team cooperation game

[sweetandcool]

Either way, Just's point is valid.

I feel like I'm living in the twilight zone, this makes absolutely no sense.

I'll spell it out for you, but I really am getting tired of explaining obvious things.

1. damo strongly suggests we don't DK him, that it is a big mistake.

Practically anyone is going to take that as him sitting the investigator role.
If he really is investigator this is incredibly bad play, particularly because he was far from guaranteed to be the DK (but yes, under some pressure).

Consequently we must conclude one of three things (for Mafia only two).

A. Damo pulled a worcej and PR claimed under some pressure.
B. Damo is bluffing in an attempt to eat a NK.
C. Damo is Mafia trying to forestall his demise.

I would expect Mafia to conclude B because A is unlikely and it is so damo-like. It is incredibly interesting that Mafia was naive enough to conclude A (or at least treat it as enough of a possibility that it would be worth a NK).

It is more tricky for town because we were stuck trying to decide between B or C.

If damo had come under pressure D2 (if he is investigator then why is he not the NK?), I would have tried to ensure his survival another day. This would have ensured that if he was town that Mafia would feel pressure to NK him N2 or in the case he was Mafia we would have felt comfortable voting him D3.

So yeah, damo was obviously not the investigator.

D. You are reading too much into it. If I was worried about being a Day Kill and I was town i would say they’re making a big mistake, because I am not mafia. Sweet has shot himself in the foot so much at this point that I’m surprised he’s still alive.

This is an idiotic response when clearly Mafia team took damo's response seriously.

Shame on you if you are town.

[ghug]

Starting to think sweet is just town too, though this is my least favorite iteration of him.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I feel like I'm living in the twilight zone, this makes absolutely no sense.

I'll spell it out for you, but I really am getting tired of explaining obvious things.

1. damo strongly suggests we don't DK him, that it is a big mistake.

Practically anyone is going to take that as him sitting the investigator role.
If he really is investigator this is incredibly bad play, particularly because he was far from guaranteed to be the DK (but yes, under some pressure).

Consequently we must conclude one of three things (for Mafia only two).

A. Damo pulled a worcej and PR claimed under some pressure.
B. Damo is bluffing in an attempt to eat a NK.
C. Damo is Mafia trying to forestall his demise.

I would expect Mafia to conclude B because A is unlikely and it is so damo-like. It is incredibly interesting that Mafia was naive enough to conclude A (or at least treat it as enough of a possibility that it would be worth a NK).

It is more tricky for town because we were stuck trying to decide between B or C.

If damo had come under pressure D2 (if he is investigator then why is he not the NK?), I would have tried to ensure his survival another day. This would have ensured that if he was town that Mafia would feel pressure to NK him N2 or in the case he was Mafia we would have felt comfortable voting him D3.

So yeah, damo was obviously not the investigator.

D. You are reading too much into it. If I was worried about being a Day Kill and I was town i would say they’re making a big mistake, because I am not mafia. Sweet has shot himself in the foot so much at this point that I’m surprised he’s still alive.

This is an idiotic response when clearly Mafia team took damo's response seriously.

Shame on you if you are town.

How would you know??? Maybe they got lucky and now that you know he is the Night Kill you justify his comment as intentional. If Hamilton said something vaguely investigatorey and he was the NK would you say that he was eating the night kill? You seem to have given damo’s quotes more merit after you saw the outcome of the night.