MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[damo666]

Chaqa putting in effort pretty sus

this made me smile

[worcej]

So I do a fun thing where I procrastinate one thing by doing another.

In this case I need to work on D&D so I was doing mafia stuff.

This is why I stopped DM’ing

[damo666]

Chaqa putting in effort pretty sus

Yeah, and he's towned rdr worcej and Bunny which fh(t)pov leaves heart with ypu, me or Macca so something not right.

I was joking.

[damo666]

Chaqa putting in effort pretty sus

Yeah, and he's towned rdr worcej and Bunny which fh(t)pov leaves heart with ypu, me or Macca so something not right.

I actually town'd Macca too

Does anyone not?

[rdrivera2005]

I'm operating in a world where I think there's a decent shot Chaqa and Bunny are both town, and that means I can't accept the "we have to solve them eventually" argument.

##VOTE heart. Rd's still in the POE but there's nothing making him especially scummy.

Have you considered my argument about why I think Heart is town?

I considered it but it doesn't really move me. I think it's very plausible he just felt like he had to do something on the spot, and he only really moved when the day was decided.

The day wasn't decided. I tied the vote with 6 minutes to EOD and he voted with 3 minutes to go almost at same time with Bozo. And Ham could have voted too. I know it's TxT but why make this flip from Tem to Ham and got some pressure over this (at least until Tem flipped).

[damo666]

I'm operating in a world where I think there's a decent shot Chaqa and Bunny are both town, and that means I can't accept the "we have to solve them eventually" argument.

##VOTE heart. Rd's still in the POE but there's nothing making him especially scummy.

worcej heart possibly?

Yeah, I'm basically at:
heart

Rd

Worcej
Bunny
Chaqa

Macca
Damo

Curious to hear reasons to rule out specific pairs if you have them, because I don't really.

you/heart
Chaqa/worcej

but not for strong reasons, just current voting

[Chaqa]

I think my strongest TRs are Macca and worcej

Beyond that probably also rivera.

Bunny is maybe town but I can’t read him unless he’s drunk

##vote heart

I need to reread Damo more

[ghug]

Can the people voting for Chaqa summarize why for me?

[damo666]

Imo vig should claim with more than an hour to go of they think they might be in trouble knowing that any claim in the last hour will be ignored (because I've just said so).

No kill is daft. They will just NK Macca and we are no further forward.

My town to scum list is now

Macca
rdr
Bunny
Heart/ghug
Worcej
Chaqa

##vote Chaqa

This

[dargorygel]

Everyone in the Village, temporarily falls in love with Vanilla Ice Cream, salt-free Saltine crackers, old stale oatmeal… and water.

Flavorless.

VOTE COUNT
Chaqa (4): worcej, damo666, Bunnygo, rdrivera2005
Heartthrob24909: (2): ghug, Chaqa
Rdrivera (1): Heartthrob
Bunnygo (1): Macca573

Chaqa is leading the Neilson Ratings

Everyone has voted and posted.
52 minutes until EoD.

[damo666]

Can the people voting for Chaqa summarize why for me?

POE, lack of engagement, Bona reaction

[damo666]

Chaqa votng for heart is interesting as heart is off-Chaqa. Almost an invitation for heart to vote him.

If Chaqa flips scum I think heart is a must tomorrow.

[ghug]

Can the people voting for Chaqa summarize why for me?

POE, lack of engagement, Bona reaction

POE I buy
Why is lack of engagement scummy?
Why is his bona reaction scummy?

[Chaqa]

Because they all play like anything they don’t agree with is scummy

Being scummy isn’t even a real thing

[dargorygel]

30 Minuites... no change of vote.

[Chaqa]

I think bunny voting for me is the most suspicious one. He was pretty reasonably reading me all game.

[heartthrob24909]

I'm back. Catching up from 134

[heartthrob24909]

There are gonna be massive doubts about Chaqa tomorrow if we miskill today so let's just do him now. If he's town at least tomorrow we won't have that doubt hanging over us.

##vote Chaqa

@rdr @Macca @ghug @heart

thoughts?

I'm not sure. I like the thought but I'm never that comfortable seeing 4/8 votes on the same name. It makes me nervous when so many people are happily camped out. Compared to, say, what the end of D1 looked like.

[damo666]

Can the people voting for Chaqa summarize why for me?

POE, lack of engagement, Bona reaction

POE I buy
Why is lack of engagement scummy? a
Why is his bona reaction scummy? b

a more non-town than scummy
b see post 2508 p126

[heartthrob24909]

So far I scumread worcej and ND. Why? Worcej and ND have been playing really weirdly comparatively to the last game. Especially ND. He completely dipped after we pointed out his unusual actions.

What's different about worcej to you?

Would Sweet ask his teammate Will about his teammate Worcej?

No comment on what Sweet/Will specifically would do bc idk them but this seems like it could be pretty low hanging S-to-S engagement.

Would Scum 1 ask his teammate Scum 2 about his teammate Scum 3? My gut would say yes.