MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[Chaqa]

I'll admit to being unable to read rdr.

I usually assume if he thinks I'm scum, he's town, but otherwise he is a tough cookie to crack, and I've cracked many a cookie.

[ghug]

One question about Bunny, before i Go:

In my limited experience a game will have one or two high profile beefs where characters just love to argue back and forth. I feel like this game, BunnyGo has found himself in two memorable ones: with Just and with Bona.

Can those of you who've played with him more on webdip share any info around whether this in particular feels indicative of any alignment of his, or if he generally finds himself in these situations?

I find him pretty annoying regardless of alignment lol

[ghug]

If anything it's probably town points, though.

[TheMadMonarch]

Hey everyone, sorry. One long day has turned into 2.

[TheMadMonarch]

I've got about 10 minutes now if there is important information to be shared.

[TheMadMonarch]

I am going to vote how I previously planned to with ##VOTE BunnyGo for now.

[TheMadMonarch]

With at 6am (again) tomorrow, this is going to be close to the limit of what I can do today. I should be able to read it all tommorrow.

[TheMadMonarch]

This is 5 posts, but I understand if you think they are not "meaningful"

[rdrivera2005]

Why's that?

Because you always vote me when I am town. And because my voting record deserve at least some thought.

Anyway, help me with Chaqa. Do you think he is this lazy as town or it's just an act?

My gut all game has said that the laziness is more likely to come from town Chaqa. I also don't feel like scum Chaqa playing the lazy cats wouldn't try to get credit for being right about Bona. Flum taught me all some point that only scum forget when a town player is dead, hence the brief vote earlier, but I think Chaqa may be the exception to that rule.

What do you think of worcej?

Worcej is on my blind side (more or less like you) because of the D1 Sweet vote, but after that he just went understand the radar. Still, not feeling a, scum agenda on him and some of his reactions to Bona claim and flip made me feel he's more likely townie.
My choices for today are Bunny, Chaqa and heart. Buy my only solid townread is Macca, which is pretty bad considering we have only 1 miskill.

[rdrivera2005]

His scum game always scares me because he is very good at being towny as scum.

I have irrational fears of certain players still existing in later phases of games - notable ghug, rdr, and bozo. They are great at being towny as scum and I just start doubting them as the game progresses.

Does town!ghug advocate shooting bona that hard? I think he does...but I'm not 100% anymore.

IDK why anyone advocates shooting bona with no CC coming. It made no sense to me.

Yep, even scum probably acknowledged this, unless they have a strong hint Vig is newbie or someone really trigger happy.

[rdrivera2005]

One question about Bunny, before i Go:

In my limited experience a game will have one or two high profile beefs where characters just love to argue back and forth. I feel like this game, BunnyGo has found himself in two memorable ones: with Just and with Bona.

Can those of you who've played with him more on webdip share any info around whether this in particular feels indicative of any alignment of his, or if he generally finds himself in these situations?

Bunny is, usually vocal and likes to argue so this kind of engagement is NAI to him. I was townreading him because we were in sintony this game like he said, but I started to think if he was buddying me. Last game one of the reasons town lost wad Kak buddying me and I falling like a duck.
And his reaction to Bona's flip was over to me. But I still don't feel this is the right choice.

Chaqa on the other side is almost a coin flip, but if we don't flip him now he will be alone at end game as any alignment unless we flip two scum in a row.

I also don't have any idea why I just gave Damo a pass.

[damo666]

My current thoughts:

Town:

Me, rdr, Macca, ghug, heart

POE:

damo, chaqa, worcej

How do you town heart?

[rdrivera2005]

By the way, I have one strong reason to want to vote heart. In that EOD I got really pissed with Bona for convincing Heart to vote Ham and there is no reason for scum Heart to play that way considering both wagons were town. He could have just stayed back and let Bona lead the misskill. That could be fake of course but I don't think it is.

[rdrivera2005]

By the way, I have one strong reason to want to vote heart. In that EOD I got really pissed with Bona for convincing Heart to vote Ham and there is no reason for scum Heart to play that way considering both wagons were town. He could have just stayed back and let Bona lead the misskill. That could be fake of course but I don't think it is.

I meant a strong reason to NOT want to vote Heart.

[damo666]

If my analysis is correct, then of the remaining players, only 3 have been a leading wagon (counting 3+ votes and having the most votes or tied) at some point in the game so far and live to tell the tale. Those are the following:
- Macca on Day 1 and Day 2
- Chaqa on Day 3
- Heartthrob (me) on Day 3

At the time the aforementioned wagon fell apart:
- alternative wagons to Macca on Day 1 were Just (S) and Sweet (S)
- alternative wagons to Macca on Day 2 were Temasek (T), Bona (T), and Ham (T)
- alternative wagons to Chaqa were Temasek (T) and ultimately Heartthrob (?)
- alternative wagon to Heartthrob was Temasek (T)

Additional wagons on surviving players that have emerged but did not gain enough momentum to ever take the lead are:
- a BunnyGo wagon emerged on Day 3 once Temasek (T) had already taken a commanding lead in the votes.

Can at least one person say something about this? I color coded it...

You missed a green on a Tem.

This is why Macca is town (where is she?)

Weak bad for Chaqa

[damo666]

There are gonna be massive doubts about Chaqa tomorrow if we miskill today so let's just do him now. If he's town at least tomorrow we won't have that doubt hanging over us.

##vote Chaqa

[BunnyGo]

Why rdr?

[BunnyGo]

Why bunny?!

[BunnyGo]

##vote chaqa

Sigh.

Not sure when I’m back

[damo666]

My 4 most likely scumpairs in order

1. Chaqa heart
2. Heart worcej
3. Chaqa ghug
4. ghug worcej