MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[damo666]

Sorry my 'analysis' of reactions to Bona docclaim got interrupted. So far,

me NAI
Bunny townish
Chaqa scummy
ghug townish
Macca not great but I'm assuming town anyway
worcej NAI

heart and rdr to come

[damo666]

Just, heart, Macca? You all show as online.

Just has been posting here.

C'mon people! Play with me! I'm feeling stoked we got something going, and we got some mechs to decide as a group, and I think it's important you three weigh in!

Without having read much further than this post I agree that vig should do something. I'd forgotten that town even had power roles until Jamie was revealed as one. I think town has enough padding right now to use vig at least once before its too late. Dont want vig to be another NK like Jamie was.

The crumbing has been a really interesting conversation. I didn't realize that that was a thing people did. I agree it looks like he is pointing fingers at Bona but I sped through the Bona = doctor discussion to try and catch up so I'll need to reread bc that confused me a lot.

Attempt at a fake townslip?

[damo666]

I just don’t know why the hell Bona revealed so early? A very weird move, and I have some thoughts on it. My red flags keep going off for multiple reasons: Did he not think to wait until he actually became a potential target in the later stages of the game? Outwardly, this just feels like an extremely intentionally sub-optimal play. Currently, I think Bona errantly believed he was certainly going to die, and as mafia, decided to pull a Hail Mary and see what happens

As I said I need to reread this whole saga but I think I agree with this

This does not look great

[damo666]

I don't mind being Vig fodder btw

Chaqa voters, what do we think of this? Why would he say this?

heart trying to get people off Chaqa?

[damo666]

heart's response is pretty non-commital and given Bunny pointing out heart was online but didn't post I put him towards scumminess

[damo666]

I don't mind being Vig fodder btw

Chaqa voters, what do we think of this? Why would he say this?

Cos he's either vt or scum

I was right.

[damo666]

It's painful to say this, but Bona isn't the kill today. We don't kill uncced PR claims if there is a chance the claim is true, even if small. And it will resolve one way orc another.

I think Vig shooting today is a good idea, either the lead wagon at 24h mark or a Vig choice. Another shoot at EON is good only if the first hit Mafia. If not we need to give time to real doc CC tomorrow and Vig solve the problem.

##vote Chaqa - How it's a town reaction to this ask for Vig to shoot Bona?

Tem also believed Bona's claim too easily, I can't see any town not being at least a bit suspicious of Bona's claim.

Pretty NAI

[damo666]

'Analysis' of reactions to Bona docclaim

me NAI
Bunny townish
Chaqa scummy
ghug townish
Macca not great but I'm assuming town anyway
worcej NAI
heart scummy
rdr NAI

So, taking this and previous reads my S=>T is

Chaqa
Heart

Worcej

rdr Bunny ghug

Macca

Given we have a mk left I think concentrating on Chaqa/heart/worcej is probably gamewinning . However currently both heart and worcej are voting Chaqa so (if I'm right) either one of them is bussing or they are the scumpair.

I'm gonna ##vote heart for now to spread it out.

[Chaqa]

##vote Chaqa

The broken record is a concern.

You're one to talk

Am I? Because I feel like you’re just patiently letting town destroy ourselves and not interacting worth a damn to correct any stupidity, you’re just making snide comments about it.

You are a broken record in like every mafia game. You death-tunneled so hard you outed yourself as a PR once, yeah?

I don't agree with you saying I'm just making snide remarks. I've done some analysis and I've had my strong opinions, and you guys using me not changing my mind when it turns out I was right is the exact type of toxicity that I was enjoying not being in this game so far, but you do you.

[Chaqa]

I like Tem or Bunny for today

Could you elaborate on Tem?

Not really, and that's kinda the point. Maybe I've missed it, but Tem is the most non-present person from my perspective, and voted Macca D1 rather than either of the scum.

[Chaqa]

I like Tem or Bunny for today

What do you think of your wagon?

I think it's bullshit and I earnestly had been asking the vig to shoot me so this exact thing wouldn't happen, but c'est la vie.

[Chaqa]

I like Tem or Bunny for today

Could you elaborate on Tem?

And bunny too?

You know what you did

[Chaqa]

Chaqa voters, what do we think of this? Why would he say this?

Cos he's either vt or scum

I was right.

Indeed

[damo666]

On D3 at T-13mins I move from Bunny to heart making it (Tem 5 Heart 3 Bunny 3) with Bunny on Tem with the possibility of moving back to heart hus putting heart in danger.

5 minutes late Chaqa switches from heart to Tem making it 6-3-2 and moving heart to relative safety.

Could this be indicative of a Chaqa Heart scumpair? I think it very much might.

[Chaqa]

The case on me is basically that you don't like that you were wrong about Jamie/Bona, and you all think I'm so bad and dumb at this game I should have been wrong, and the fact I saw this coming and asked the vig to shoot me means I'm DEFINITELY scum.

yawn

[damo666]

I like Tem or Bunny for today

Could you elaborate on Tem?

Not really, and that's kinda the point. Maybe I've missed it, but Tem is the most non-present person from my perspective, and voted Macca D1 rather than either of the scum.

Tem's dead baby. Tem's dead.

[damo666]

The case on me is basically that you don't like that you were wrong about Jamie/Bona, and you all think I'm so bad and dumb at this game I should have been wrong, and the fact I saw this coming and asked the vig to shoot me means I'm DEFINITELY scum.

yawn

So I take it you are hardclaiming vt. Right?

[Chaqa]

Could you elaborate on Tem?

Not really, and that's kinda the point. Maybe I've missed it, but Tem is the most non-present person from my perspective, and voted Macca D1 rather than either of the scum.

Tem's dead baby. Tem's dead.

Oh geez.

In the original post "Tem or Bunny" should have been "Heart or Bunny"

In the meantime I forgot Tem was dead and so when rivera asked, I replied as such. As it turns out, it makes sense Tem isn't involved as theyre dead.

Carry on

[Chaqa]

I'm curious why Rivera asked that question now.

Was he trying to catch me in a slip?
Did he forget Tem was dead?

Someone smarter than me with these WIFOM things can figure it out

[damo666]

I'm curious why Rivera asked that question now.

Was he trying to catch me in a slip?
Did he forget Tem was dead?

Someone smarter than me with these WIFOM things can figure it out

I assumed he was taking the piss. I was amazed when you answered!