MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[damo666]

I don't mind being Vig fodder btw

Chaqa voters, what do we think of this? Why would he say this?

Cos he's either vt or scum

[BunnyGo]

I don't mind being Vig fodder btw

Chaqa voters, what do we think of this? Why would he say this?

Cos he's either vt or scum

Or vig

[damo666]

Chaqa voters, what do we think of this? Why would he say this?

Cos he's either vt or scum

Or vig

If he was vig he'd have shot you by now.

[BunnyGo]

Cos he's either vt or scum

Or vig

If he was vig he'd have shot you by now.

Nah...he's very good at town reading me

[bozotheclown]

@damo

So is your theory that the scumteam is Sweet, ND/Bona, and myself?

I think you're more likely to be correct about that if that's true.

Bona being scum gives much higher likelihood to you being scum. And nothing you've done this game leads me to move you out of "null".

And since rdr is correct that I can't vote Bona without a CC...

Why did you need rdrivera to tell you that?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Did I just become the consensus Vigilante? Of course I did. Can anyone explain why they think I am vig?

[BunnyGo]

So is your theory that the scumteam is Sweet, ND/Bona, and myself?

I think you're more likely to be correct about that if that's true.

Bona being scum gives much higher likelihood to you being scum. And nothing you've done this game leads me to move you out of "null".

And since rdr is correct that I can't vote Bona without a CC...

Why did you need rdrivera to tell you that?

Because it seems so obvious he's lying I forgot we weren't in a rush to get him today. That we can wait on getting bofa and get a different scum today.

[bozotheclown]

Did I just become the consensus Vigilante? Of course I did. Can anyone explain why they think I am vig?

I believe it is the way you responded to BunnyGo's questions about the Vig.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Did I just become the consensus Vigilante? Of course I did. Can anyone explain why they think I am vig?

For the record I am sure anyone would hesitate on such a rash decision to kill

[bozotheclown]

I think you're more likely to be correct about that if that's true.

Bona being scum gives much higher likelihood to you being scum. And nothing you've done this game leads me to move you out of "null".

And since rdr is correct that I can't vote Bona without a CC...

Why did you need rdrivera to tell you that?

Because it seems so obvious he's lying I forgot we weren't in a rush to get him today. That we can wait on getting bofa and get a different scum today.

Why is it obvious that he is not the real doctor?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Did I just become the consensus Vigilante? Of course I did. Can anyone explain why they think I am vig?

I believe it is the way you responded to BunnyGo's questions about the Vig.

I see. I still think my logic stands up even if Im not Vigilante

[bozotheclown]

Did I just become the consensus Vigilante? Of course I did. Can anyone explain why they think I am vig?

For the record I am sure anyone would hesitate on such a rash decision to kill

Not everyone, but it makes sense to be careful.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Why did you need rdrivera to tell you that?

Because it seems so obvious he's lying I forgot we weren't in a rush to get him today. That we can wait on getting bofa and get a different scum today.

Why is it obvious that he is not the real doctor?

It’s such a dumb decision on the doctors part to reveal so early. I am 95% sure this is a fake claim so that Bona can save his own ass.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Because it seems so obvious he's lying I forgot we weren't in a rush to get him today. That we can wait on getting bofa and get a different scum today.

Why is it obvious that he is not the real doctor?

It’s such a dumb decision on the doctors part to reveal so early. I am 95% sure this is a fake claim so that Bona can save his own ass.

##VOTE BONA

We aren’t going to see anything interesting other than Vigilante talks, so this vote is sealed no matter what happens.

[BunnyGo]

Why did you need rdrivera to tell you that?

Because it seems so obvious he's lying I forgot we weren't in a rush to get him today. That we can wait on getting bofa and get a different scum today.

Why is it obvious that he is not the real doctor?

a) I was already coming around to the idea he was scum during N2

b) his snap claim is silly as doctor; both to claim, and to specifically claim both his night actions--just don't say them

c) his claim is in contradiction to the assumption Jamie saw him visiting spirit

d) his only prior claims that I could dig up were dragged out of him at last minute (see my post referencing all the claims he's ever made that weren't of the nature "I claim I'm an american" or "I claim bofa deez nuts!")

[bozotheclown]

Because it seems so obvious he's lying I forgot we weren't in a rush to get him today. That we can wait on getting bofa and get a different scum today.

Why is it obvious that he is not the real doctor?

It’s such a dumb decision on the doctors part to reveal so early. I am 95% sure this is a fake claim so that Bona can save his own ass.

I agree that seems likely, although I would put it at less than 95%. If Bonatogether's claim is fake we will know with 100% certainty when the real doctor is revealed.

[brainbomb]

Yeah, this is how I read the post originally.

Bona claiming Doctor is the bit that makes me think Jamie *did* see something, but it's unclear to me what the truth of it all is yet.

Does the person who gets watched know that they were watched? For ease pretend Jamie did see Bona do something. What would give Bona the impression that he was seen doing whatever he was doing?

Almost surely not, but I haven't checked with GM. This would allow them to use watching as a signal.

You can check with GM by typing:

##CALL GM does the person watched or tracked know they were the target of an action?

A person who has been visited by the watcher will
not know they were visited

[bozotheclown]

Because it seems so obvious he's lying I forgot we weren't in a rush to get him today. That we can wait on getting bofa and get a different scum today.

Why is it obvious that he is not the real doctor?

a) I was already coming around to the idea he was scum during N2

b) his snap claim is silly as doctor; both to claim, and to specifically claim both his night actions--just don't say them

c) his claim is in contradiction to the assumption Jamie saw him visiting spirit

d) his only prior claims that I could dig up were dragged out of him at last minute (see my post referencing all the claims he's ever made that weren't of the nature "I claim I'm an american" or "I claim bofa deez nuts!")

The assumption about Jamie could be wrong, and Bonatogether's claim is not a good claim as mafia either. Also, the mafia have a ninja.

[BunnyGo]

Why is it obvious that he is not the real doctor?

a) I was already coming around to the idea he was scum during N2

b) his snap claim is silly as doctor; both to claim, and to specifically claim both his night actions--just don't say them

c) his claim is in contradiction to the assumption Jamie saw him visiting spirit

d) his only prior claims that I could dig up were dragged out of him at last minute (see my post referencing all the claims he's ever made that weren't of the nature "I claim I'm an american" or "I claim bofa deez nuts!")

The assumption about Jamie could be wrong, and Bonatogether's claim is not a good claim as mafia either. Also, the mafia have a ninja.

And roleblocker...they probably used both on spirit.

[bozotheclown]

Because it seems so obvious he's lying I forgot we weren't in a rush to get him today. That we can wait on getting bofa and get a different scum today.

Why is it obvious that he is not the real doctor?

a) I was already coming around to the idea he was scum during N2

b) his snap claim is silly as doctor; both to claim, and to specifically claim both his night actions--just don't say them

c) his claim is in contradiction to the assumption Jamie saw him visiting spirit

d) his only prior claims that I could dig up were dragged out of him at last minute (see my post referencing all the claims he's ever made that weren't of the nature "I claim I'm an american" or "I claim bofa deez nuts!")

What made you suspect Bonatogether N2?