MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[Hamilton Brian]

Preferred D2K Temasek but wouldn't mind seeing Macca flipped.

Does this mean you think it is possible Temasek was bussing Macca, when Temasek joined the Macca wagon which you had started?

This post and vote:

##Vote Macca

Some very interesting development here. Holy hell.

... is Temasek's only mention of Macca in the entire game.

Hmmm.

Considering my only votes the entire D1 were sweet (proven scum) and Macca, it'll be really weird if I were scum bussing two teammates in a row honestly.

I only mentioned Macca once the entire game because she first posted like 18 hours before the deadline so there's absolutely nothing to talk about her before this.

Do we give credit for voting Sweet? How much of this is a deflection defense?

[Temasek22]

Also, ##VOTE Bona

I've decided that ND (Bona) could be scum.

ND's strategy actually halfway worked last time as Mafia. Several people townread him for his antics. So I'm thinking this game he decided to resurrect that strategy, banking on the fact that people would assume he wouldn't be so obvious about using his previous scum-strategy, and therefore would townread him.

This feels like some very forced reasoning. ##vote Sweet just to get out of the no kill vote for now

This was a secondary reason I voted for sweetandcool at EOD because it seemed like it could be a scum distancing vote. I reviewed Temasek's previous games, and he was mafia in 3 of his first 5 games here (M48, M50, and M52). In M48 and M50, Temasek placed a vote for one of his teammates at some point on D1.

Fwiw, the vote for my teammate on M48 (ItsHosuke) was purely because he was a close friend and previously my IRL roommate. I would have done it no matter if I'm town or scum or whether I believe him to be town or scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

Whom I trust now, who's left in POE.

Have you reached any conclusions, Dr. Bunny?

Yes! I do have some thoughts and observations that I've shared with the GT.

Are you interested in hearing them?

I believe that was implied by my question.

For some reason I do not have access to the God Thread, so perhaps you could share your thoughts and observations.

Thanks in advance.

[Jamiet99uk]

How many?

My guess would be that it's between one and two.

What? 1.43?

Allow me to clarify. I would guess it to be an integer in the range of 1 to 2 (inclusive).

[Bonatogether]

Whom I trust now, who's left in POE.

Have you reached any conclusions, Dr. Bunny?

Yes! I do have some thoughts and observations that I've shared with the GT.

Are you interested in hearing them?

why would you ever not post conclusions in the thread

[Jamiet99uk]

Have you reached any conclusions, Dr. Bunny?

Yes! I do have some thoughts and observations that I've shared with the GT.

I'm so clever!

Are you interested in hearing them?

why would you ever not post conclusions in the thread

There is a reason some people don't post some things at night, of course. But in this case I purport that Dr. Bungo is teasing us poor small-town-folks.

[BunnyGo]

Have you reached any conclusions, Dr. Bunny?

Yes! I do have some thoughts and observations that I've shared with the GT.

Are you interested in hearing them?

why would you ever not post conclusions in the thread

I post A LOT to the god thread, and don't want to overwhelm the main thread here. Been trying to listen more.

[damo666]

@Bozo fancy running a survey on how many bussers people think were on sweet?

I'll ko with 1

Are you counting "meaningful" votes, or anyone on at the end? I would not count your vote as "meaningful", I don't think Just was either.

What's "meaningful" go to do with it? Any voter is either bussing or not. Doesn't matter whether the vote was sincere, jocular, desperate, simply fulfilling mandate , selected at random using different flavour of marmalade or whatever.

So, iyo how many bussers on sweet do you guess?

[Jamiet99uk]

Yes! I do have some thoughts and observations that I've shared with the GT.

Are you interested in hearing them?

Why wouldst thou ever refrain thineself from posting conclusions in the thread?

I post A LOT to the god thread, and don't want to overwhelm the main thread here. Been trying to listen more.

As a regular GM, I can confirm that BunnyGo sends a lot of messages for the God Thread.

When I am GM I usually try to make sure I post at least 80% of them into the God Thread, too!

[damo666]

@Bozo fancy running a survey on how many bussers people think were on sweet?

I'll ko with 1

I reckon 2

You would lol!

[damo666]

My guess would be that it's between one and two.

What? 1.43?

Allow me to clarify. I would guess it to be an integer in the range of 1 to 2 (inclusive).

Care to choose?

[Jamiet99uk]

Damo's Survey:

Damo: 1
Worcej: 1
Temasek: 2
Jamiet99uk: 2

[Chaqa]

I say 3

[Bonatogether]

Yes! I do have some thoughts and observations that I've shared with the GT.

Are you interested in hearing them?

why would you ever not post conclusions in the thread

I post A LOT to the god thread, and don't want to overwhelm the main thread here. Been trying to listen more.

i mean there is no qualitative benefit to not saying what you think

[Jamiet99uk]

Damo's Survey:

Damo: 1
Worcej: 1
Temasek: 2
Jamiet99uk: 2
Chaqa: 3

[BunnyGo]

@Bozo fancy running a survey on how many bussers people think were on sweet?

I'll ko with 1

Are you counting "meaningful" votes, or anyone on at the end? I would not count your vote as "meaningful", I don't think Just was either.

What's "meaningful" go to do with it? Any voter is either bussing or not. Doesn't matter whether the vote was sincere, jocular, desperate, simply fulfilling mandate , selected at random using different flavour of marmalade or whatever.

So, iyo how many bussers on sweet do you guess?

I mean if everyone piles on at last second "to avoid a tie" that's voting to avoid a tie...

[damo666]

Are you counting "meaningful" votes, or anyone on at the end? I would not count your vote as "meaningful", I don't think Just was either.

What's "meaningful" go to do with it? Any voter is either bussing or not. Doesn't matter whether the vote was sincere, jocular, desperate, simply fulfilling mandate , selected at random using different flavour of marmalade or whatever.

So, iyo how many bussers on sweet do you guess?

I mean if everyone piles on at last second "to avoid a tie" that's voting to avoid a tie...

Yes. So?

[damo666]

Damo's Survey:

Damo: 1
Worcej: 1
Temasek: 2
Jamiet99uk: 2
Chaqa: 3

Thank you Jamie.

So far Jamie's answer is unique. Anyone want to say why?

[BunnyGo]

Damo's Survey:

Damo: 1
Worcej: 1
Temasek: 2
Jamiet99uk: 2
Chaqa: 3

Thank you Jamie.

So far Jamie's answer is unique. Anyone want to say why?

What does "unique" mean?

[BunnyGo]

What's "meaningful" go to do with it? Any voter is either bussing or not. Doesn't matter whether the vote was sincere, jocular, desperate, simply fulfilling mandate , selected at random using different flavour of marmalade or whatever.

So, iyo how many bussers on sweet do you guess?

I mean if everyone piles on at last second "to avoid a tie" that's voting to avoid a tie...

Yes. So?

Fine. Of the final 8 voters, I think 1-2 are probably scum. If I had to answer a specific number, I'd guess 1.