MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

In essence I love strategy and social games. So games like Diplomacy basically

Great stuff. Anything with partnerships or teammates?

Clue (Cluedo for you nasty Brits), Project Zomboid (gaming with my boys), Terraria, Secret Hitler, Paintball, Football , Soccer

[worcej]

Off to Doctor's - kill sweet

[Hamilton Brian]

Bunny, what's your sense of why you've got two votes on you?

I like what Spirit has to say...despire my disagreement.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

What’s your point Bunny?

[BunnyGo]

I'm not familiar with all those, but of the ones I am: there's no teammates.

Do you realize that *if* you're town, then you don't need to win the game, you need your TEAM to win the game; and that there's a difference?

Yo, it’s a joke. Civilization (multiplayer), Dead Last, Wolvesville, and Catan are all games where you need to cut you losses and progress with others, as you need help from others to win. In Dead last, you can use your life as a bargaining chip to forge alliances and help yourself and your allies. This absolutely applies here

Those are literally NOT the same thing.

Forming an ALLIANCE where only one will end up winning (Catan) or where you will play kingmaker is a FUNDAMENTALLY different style of game.

I'm talking about a TEAM. Like fu**ing baseball, or bridge, or MAFIA where you win or lose with THE WHOLE TEAM regardless of your actual actions.

Your answer suggests you do not understand that fundamental thing.

So to answer your original question: I do think there's a chance you're mafia. But I don't actually care. Town's chances of winning will be increased if we eliminate you day 1 regardless. I care about that statement (usually that statement requires me to believe a player is mafia)

[BunnyGo]

Bunny, what's your sense of why you've got two votes on you?

I like what Spirit has to say...despire my disagreement.

Just is WIFOM

Spirit is weird. I honestly don't recall him pushing Just. I do recall scumreading him for his early posts.

[BunnyGo]

In essence I love strategy and social games. So games like Diplomacy basically

Great stuff. Anything with partnerships or teammates?

Clue (Cluedo for you nasty Brits), Project Zomboid (gaming with my boys), Terraria, Secret Hitler, Paintball, Football , Soccer

I don't know 3 of those. But Clue is yet another THAT IS NOT A TEAM.

[BunnyGo]

Bunny, what's your sense of why you've got two votes on you?

I like what Spirit has to say...despire my disagreement.

Just is WIFOM

Spirit is weird. I honestly don't recall him pushing Just. I do recall scumreading him for his early posts.

Not WIFOM...OMGUS

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Great stuff. Anything with partnerships or teammates?

Clue (Cluedo for you nasty Brits), Project Zomboid (gaming with my boys), Terraria, Secret Hitler, Paintball, Football , Soccer

I don't know 3 of those. But Clue is yet another THAT IS NOT A TEAM.

My bad, just wanted to include it. Still, what’s your point?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Yo, it’s a joke. Civilization (multiplayer), Dead Last, Wolvesville, and Catan are all games where you need to cut you losses and progress with others, as you need help from others to win. In Dead last, you can use your life as a bargaining chip to forge alliances and help yourself and your allies. This absolutely applies here

Those are literally NOT the same thing.

Forming an ALLIANCE where only one will end up winning (Catan) or where you will play kingmaker is a FUNDAMENTALLY different style of game.

I'm talking about a TEAM. Like fu**ing baseball, or bridge, or MAFIA where you win or lose with THE WHOLE TEAM regardless of your actual actions.

Your answer suggests you do not understand that fundamental thing.

So to answer your original question: I do think there's a chance you're mafia. But I don't actually care. Town's chances of winning will be increased if we eliminate you day 1 regardless. I care about that statement (usually that statement requires me to believe a player is mafia)

Ok, so you say joking about being mafia is detrimental. That’s why I only really did it in the beginning, where we all kind of joke around and have fun with it

[BunnyGo]

Yo, it’s a joke. Civilization (multiplayer), Dead Last, Wolvesville, and Catan are all games where you need to cut you losses and progress with others, as you need help from others to win. In Dead last, you can use your life as a bargaining chip to forge alliances and help yourself and your allies. This absolutely applies here

Those are literally NOT the same thing.

Forming an ALLIANCE where only one will end up winning (Catan) or where you will play kingmaker is a FUNDAMENTALLY different style of game.

I'm talking about a TEAM. Like fu**ing baseball, or bridge, or MAFIA where you win or lose with THE WHOLE TEAM regardless of your actual actions.

Your answer suggests you do not understand that fundamental thing.

So to answer your original question: I do think there's a chance you're mafia. But I don't actually care. Town's chances of winning will be increased if we eliminate you day 1 regardless. I care about that statement (usually that statement requires me to believe a player is mafia)

The point.

You seem to su** as a teammate. You seem to even be incapable of recognizing what a TEAM IS!! So I have 2 options:

1) you are mafia (so I should vote you)
2) you’re a shitty teammate and will harm my team (so I should vote you)

[Jamiet99uk]

Bunny, it feels like you're scumreading Will's personality, rather than his alignment.

I'm not sure I can get on board with that.

[Bonatogether]

bongo those are not kind words

[BunnyGo]

Those are literally NOT the same thing.

Forming an ALLIANCE where only one will end up winning (Catan) or where you will play kingmaker is a FUNDAMENTALLY different style of game.

I'm talking about a TEAM. Like fu**ing baseball, or bridge, or MAFIA where you win or lose with THE WHOLE TEAM regardless of your actual actions.

Your answer suggests you do not understand that fundamental thing.

So to answer your original question: I do think there's a chance you're mafia. But I don't actually care. Town's chances of winning will be increased if we eliminate you day 1 regardless. I care about that statement (usually that statement requires me to believe a player is mafia)

Ok, so you say joking about being mafia is detrimental. That’s why I only really did it in the beginning, where we all kind of joke around and have fun with it

Go see how often you KEPT GOING BACK TO IT UNPROMPTED. It was excessive and out of nowhere repeatedly.

I’m walking away and going to dinner. But if you survive today, shape the f*** up.

[Bonatogether]

voting for self-pres as i stated i would

##vote sweetandcool

[Hamilton Brian]

Worcej leading the anti-Sweet charge and pulling ghug along by the hand.

I don't see anything from Sweet that rings as mafia-like, though.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Forming an ALLIANCE where only one will end up winning (Catan) or where you will play kingmaker is a FUNDAMENTALLY different style of game.

I'm talking about a TEAM. Like fu**ing baseball, or bridge, or MAFIA where you win or lose with THE WHOLE TEAM regardless of your actual actions.

Your answer suggests you do not understand that fundamental thing.

So to answer your original question: I do think there's a chance you're mafia. But I don't actually care. Town's chances of winning will be increased if we eliminate you day 1 regardless. I care about that statement (usually that statement requires me to believe a player is mafia)

Ok, so you say joking about being mafia is detrimental. That’s why I only really did it in the beginning, where we all kind of joke around and have fun with it

Go see how often you KEPT GOING BACK TO IT UNPROMPTED. It was excessive and out of nowhere repeatedly.

I’m walking away and going to dinner. But if you survive today, shape the f*** up.

I feel like this argument is based upon me liking non team games. I don’t really have an argument against that, so I won’t really.

[sweetandcool]

This conversation has been so painful in so many ways.

I don't care too much about the jokes, I'm sure Will will learn not to make them. But I think he's having too much fun throwing out accusations. His jab about me buddying Jamiet and his attitude in general means we should

##VOTE Just

[sweetandcool]

voting for self-pres as i stated i would

##vote sweetandcool

Ach, bad timing, I just changed my vote.

[Hamilton Brian]

Lot of energy directed toward JustWill. I get what jamie is saying. Might merit a vote later but I am not sure D1.