MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[ghug]

Why are URLs disabled?

Did you not just do it wrong?

[sweetandcool]

what are you doing

nd and i are the same slot. you either scumread both of us or you townread both of us. simple as. what it is?

I scumread ND. I nullread Bona. Too bad Bona=ND because I think it is a good vote.

This is getting silly. I don't like voting Bona D1, and I don't think I've ever seriously done it other than my first game with Bona. But Bona is also ND this game. I am okay voting ND this game.

Stop whining.

this is incoherent. from the top: you said you weren't voting me. i demonstrated that you were. you flipped your vote to the player i subbed in for, which is not a valid vote and so you are still voting me. i point out the inconsistency, and now you continue to insist that you're voting for and scumread the player i subbed in for, but not me, when in fact we are the same slot.

I'm done with this. At this point if it doesn't make sense to you that's your problem.

[ghug]

I thought ND was scum, and now Bona is in that slot. Sorry buddy.

Whoa.
Chronological anomaly klaxon!
Chronological anomaly klaxon!

The GM announced ND was replaced by Bonatogether on Page 13 with 18:45 hrs left to go.

Macca first posted on Page 15 with 17:56 to go.

Macca claims "I thought ND was scum" yet ND replaced out of the game before Macca first participated.

Suspect.

Exactly. Vote her.

You're definitely past five now.

[ghug]

##Vote Macca

Some very interesting development here. Holy hell.

##VOTE Temasek

[Bonatogether]

I scumread ND. I nullread Bona. Too bad Bona=ND because I think it is a good vote.

This is getting silly. I don't like voting Bona D1, and I don't think I've ever seriously done it other than my first game with Bona. But Bona is also ND this game. I am okay voting ND this game.

Stop whining.

this is incoherent. from the top: you said you weren't voting me. i demonstrated that you were. you flipped your vote to the player i subbed in for, which is not a valid vote and so you are still voting me. i point out the inconsistency, and now you continue to insist that you're voting for and scumread the player i subbed in for, but not me, when in fact we are the same slot.

I'm done with this. At this point if it doesn't make sense to you that's your problem.

you are bullshitting me. no way you actually believe what you're saying

[Jamiet99uk]

I appreciate the default to “them.” I tend to do the same.

A group of us has been playing at work, which has been a lot of fun. I’m GMing the next game (actually using one of your models - the Papers Please one but reskinned for Spongebob) and felt like I wanted to play some in the meantime.

I think I was a little scared off after the first game bc of how I didn’t know anybody or know the game that well. Now I feel like I know the game better enough to be excited to play it and learn how all of you work, through the game. Instead of trying to figure both out at once

aren't you bungus' colleague

Why didn’t Jamie bring this up? I’d literally told him two days before game start?! Great memory bona!

Oh, I forgot that in your message you referred to Heart-throb as "he".

[sweetandcool]

Okay, I've been ignoring this Macca drama.

What's going on? I don't understand.

[ghug]

I think the ND (Bona) wagon is the best one we have. There is no forced logic here. It's always hard to find a good vote D1 other than "vibes". I am content that I've found a reasonable reason to vote someone.

If we don't flip ND (Bona) now, we'll probably want to flip them later unless compelling evidence is brought up to clear them or there is something flawed with my logic.

Is there something wrong with my reasoning? I don't get it. Then again, Bona is the one decrying it, which makes sense because Bona=ND here.

This feels like a bit much this early in the game.

Sweet's post strikes me as a D3 type post when you have information to justify it more than just someone being a dick...

My vote is less joke and more legit as I've read.

Ok I feel dirty but ##VOTE sweet

[sweetandcool]

this is incoherent. from the top: you said you weren't voting me. i demonstrated that you were. you flipped your vote to the player i subbed in for, which is not a valid vote and so you are still voting me. i point out the inconsistency, and now you continue to insist that you're voting for and scumread the player i subbed in for, but not me, when in fact we are the same slot.

I'm done with this. At this point if it doesn't make sense to you that's your problem.

you are bullshitting me. no way you actually believe what you're saying

##END

[Jamiet99uk]

This is incoherent. From the top: you said you weren't voting me. I demonstrated that you were. You flipped your vote to the player I subbed in for, which is not a valid vote and so you are still voting me. I point out the inconsistency, and now you continue to insist that you're voting for and scumread the player I subbed in for, but not me, when in fact we are the same slot.

I'm done with this. At this point if it doesn't make sense to you that's your problem.

You are bullshitting me. No way you actually believe what you're saying.

This is a very weird exchange.

[ghug]

This feels like a bit much this early in the game.

Sweet's post strikes me as a D3 type post when you have information to justify it more than just someone being a dick...

My vote is less joke and more legit as I've read.

You and ghug don't seem to understand me. I'm not being a dick and I'm not claiming that we MUST flip ND. But personally, because of ND's behavior I think he is a good flip D1.

This is leaps and bounds better than some of my past play where I decry someone D1 and absolutely want them voted, only for them to flip town almost every time.

I'm just getting a little better at this game (:

It feels like you oversweeted and got cloying.

[BunnyGo]

Right... so just because he was town last game and we lost because we miskilled him means we can't question or point things out when he says contradictory, insane, unintelligible babble in THIS game? Glad to know your stated position up front girlfriend!

lol, Will's actual role is isn't important. We know with certainty he will say something scummy and the only real decision we have to make is when we townkill him and not if.

My real goal for the game is to teach the lobby how awesome using math in mafia is

only scum or damo uses math

@bona this is spirit

[sweetandcool]

I'm done with this. At this point if it doesn't make sense to you that's your problem.

You are bullshitting me. No way you actually believe what you're saying.

This is a very weird exchange.

It does look weird if you only quote that. Bona's summary is inaccurate.

[Bonatogether]

I'm done with this. At this point if it doesn't make sense to you that's your problem.

you are bullshitting me. no way you actually believe what you're saying

##END

i'm really glad you're sticking to your nullread of me, and that you really do dislike d1ing me.

[Jamiet99uk]

Okay, I've been ignoring this Macca drama.

What's going on? I don't understand.

I pointed out an inconsistency between Macca saying they thought ND was scum before Bona subbed in, whilst also Macca's first post was after ND subbed out.

Damo is now behaving like this is an incredible case-closed "gotcha", and Temasek and Heart-throb have jumped on board, which is all a bit weird.

[Bonatogether]

lol, Will's actual role is isn't important. We know with certainty he will say something scummy and the only real decision we have to make is when we townkill him and not if.

My real goal for the game is to teach the lobby how awesome using math in mafia is

only scum or damo uses math

@bona this is spirit

ok

[Jamiet99uk]

You are bullshitting me. No way you actually believe what you're saying.

This is a very weird exchange.

It does look weird if you only quote that. Bona's summary is inaccurate.

You're right.

##Vote Bona

[Bonatogether]

You are bullshitting me. No way you actually believe what you're saying.

This is a very weird exchange.

It does look weird if you only quote that. Bona's summary is inaccurate.

i mean the basic fact is that you hold the logically inconsistent position of different reads on me and ND (seperating me and him) but voting me on the basis of what ND did (not seperating them). this is not a real thought process

[Bonatogether]

what time is eod

[Jamiet99uk]

what time is eod

5hrs 24mins from the timestamp of this post.