MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[ghug]

resident guy claims meta read, only has one data point

He's done it several other times as scum too if that helps.

ok but he doesn't know that

Sure but I do.

Do you think sweet is being scummy for making that leap in meta logic or just wrong?

[Bonatogether]

He's done it several other times as scum too if that helps.

ok but he doesn't know that

Sure but I do.

Do you think sweet is being scummy for making that leap in meta logic or just wrong?

it's certainly in line with the jumping on the easy kill ship

both me and nd are easy dk shots

[ghug]

ok but he doesn't know that

Sure but I do.

Do you think sweet is being scummy for making that leap in meta logic or just wrong?

it's certainly in line with the jumping on the easy kill ship

both me and nd are easy dk shots

That's an evasive answer.

[Bonatogether]

Sure but I do.

Do you think sweet is being scummy for making that leap in meta logic or just wrong?

it's certainly in line with the jumping on the easy kill ship

both me and nd are easy dk shots

That's an evasive answer.

it's not

i scumlean it but it's not a big read because it's d1

[Bonatogether]

which is clearly implied in the post

[Temasek22]

Just realised ND left. Welcome in Bona!

[ghug]

Just realised ND left. Welcome in Bona!

This post gives me bad vibes.

[Temasek22]

Also, ##VOTE Bona

I've decided that ND (Bona) could be scum.

ND's strategy actually halfway worked last time as Mafia. Several people townread him for his antics. So I'm thinking this game he decided to resurrect that strategy, banking on the fact that people would assume he wouldn't be so obvious about using his previous scum-strategy, and therefore would townread him.

This feels like some very forced reasoning. ##vote Sweet just to get out of the no kill vote for now

[Bonatogether]

this game is not actually happening

[Temasek22]

Just realised ND left. Welcome in Bona!

This post gives me bad vibes.

My bad for not keeping up

[Temasek22]

this game is not actually happening

I see someone making a lot of posts to try and make the game more lively and I respect that

[sweetandcool]

Did this bug anyone else?

Did you notice me voting for him?

I didn't note who was voting him, just that he had about three votes already. Didn't recall anyone stating a compelling reason for it, and now that I'm checking it sems nobody really did.

[ghug]

Did this bug anyone else?

Did you notice me voting for him?

I didn't note who was voting him, just that he had about three votes already. Didn't recall anyone stating a compelling reason for it, and now that I'm checking it sems nobody really did.

I quoted him doing exactly what you're talking about.

[Bonatogether]

this game is not actually happening

I see someone making a lot of posts to try and make the game more lively and I respect that

why are you saying this to that

[sweetandcool]

resident guy claims meta read, only has one data point

He's done it several other times as scum too if that helps.

ok but he doesn't know that

True. But I have two data points. There was a marked difference between him hamming it up in the Mini and what felt like the more "real" ND in the previous game. He also hunted in what felt like a towny way. I strongly townread him, so I don't understand why he would revert to the over the top performance.

Like I said before, the performative nature of his posts were so obvious to be NAI. But it creates a WIFOM that makes him someone I'd personally like to flip.

[sweetandcool]

I think the ND (Bona) wagon is the best one we have. There is no forced logic here. It's always hard to find a good vote D1 other than "vibes". I am content that I've found a reasonable reason to vote someone.

If we don't flip ND (Bona) now, we'll probably want to flip them later unless compelling evidence is brought up to clear them or there is something flawed with my logic.

Is there something wrong with my reasoning? I don't get it. Then again, Bona is the one decrying it, which makes sense because Bona=ND here.

[ghug]

I think the ND (Bona) wagon is the best one we have. There is no forced logic here. It's always hard to find a good vote D1 other than "vibes". I am content that I've found a reasonable reason to vote someone.

If we don't flip ND (Bona) now, we'll probably want to flip them later unless compelling evidence is brought up to clear them or there is something flawed with my logic.

Is there something wrong with my reasoning? I don't get it. Then again, Bona is the one decrying it, which makes sense because Bona=ND here.

This feels like a bit much this early in the game.

[Jamiet99uk]

##GM NOTE

Bonatogether has replaced ND

(ND requested to be replaced due to out of game issues IRL)

Oh. Welcome Bona.

##Unvote to re-assess.

[Jamiet99uk]

I wanted to make a ginger cake (I added Orange to it, a great combo) and found the recipe in my cookbook. Apparently, it is traditionally made for Guy Fawkes Day. So much so that in some parts of England they call it Parkin Day.

Jamie's usually too busy planning bombings on that day to have time for cake.

jamie's a monarchist?

Jamie is neither a monarchist nor a terrorist.

Jamie is, for wiw, a Green Marxist.

[rdrivera2005]

Glad to have you back Will. You played well last game. Maybe this game you won't newbie-stumble as much.

So who are your other teammates, other than Ham?

I started to have a feeling that Will might be scum this game.

Huh awfully bold claim 13 pages in, Mr. Rivera.

And yes, i will still be defending myself extremely hard, like last time, so come at me

I have seen more then once scum joking about being scum and you are fully capable of doing this.

This said, defending yourself as either town or scum is what I expect for any decent player, so let's see.