MAFIA 83: HALLOWE'EN IN THE TOYSHOP - GAME THREAD

[damo666]

Ok Kak shifts back townwards.

I now think it's Demon and Spirit, if not worcej, if not rdr, if not I think we lose but I'm confident we won't.

[damo666]

##vote Macca.

The elaborate detective scan ploy.

This is scummy. Are you trying to out a nurse?

[Kakarroto]

Hmmm, I can't speak for Brian, but I don't think he is mafia in this game.

Contrary to the "brainbomb-gamble" scenario where mafia could've communicated and talked about how they might do this ludicrous plan, in Brian's case it all happened on day one, so there was no communication and info of other items.

Brian comes from a streak of being mafia, the last game he heavily bussed his teammate and got ND day one-ed. From his posts in the mafia chat from this mini game he also heavily regrets his decision.

Now picture this scenario: Brian again being mafia, hoping not to be a detriment for his team, seeing there is sweet and himself on the block ... I can't see that he would just axe his teammate and maybe being the dayvote, costing mafia two losses on day one. I just can't. If I'm wrong there and Brian is actually this cold, I'll happily always vote him day one from now on. But no, this just doesn't fit with his character. If he was thinking of losing one teammate, maybe himself, sure he would've used his axe; but not on his teammate. And thus far, we have no one who did confess on axing ghug, which wouldn't really make sense if a town did that. Nor did we have a counterclaim that someone else axed sweet.

While I might see Brian being able to do that on a day two or if mafia had a chat night 0 (which they clearly didn't have as the game needed to restart due to the issue), so if they could arrange something like that, I think Brian would do this for the team, but I can't see it in a world where Brian was mafia and axing another mafia without prior communication. He would've just gone for the towniest town or the biggest threat for mafia.

I do think though voting macca here is wrong here, not gonna lie.

[Hamilton Brian]

##vote Macca.

The elaborate detective scan ploy.

This is silly.

Maybe? There's all sorts of weird business going on.

[ND]

I don't see Macca or Brian as scum. Period.

[Hamilton Brian]

since all three have used their item, they can only protected by the nurse costume visit.

Yep, and I am begging the nurse NOT to protect me. There's better protectees.

[rdrivera2005]

Voting Macca isn't that bad as at least make people to consider the possibilities and reevaluate things.

We have two semi clears, a future clear (unless killed before claiming) and one nurse that saved Macca. If we can be sure the other nurse is in play and alive is almost auto win.

But there is too many "ifs" and "almost" on this, so we need to avoid the apathy in order to win.

[Hamilton Brian]

##vote Macca.

The elaborate detective scan ploy.

This is scummy. Are you trying to out a nurse?

Nope, the opposite. Just want people thinking that not everything is entirely clear. Just be wary.

[Hamilton Brian]

Voting Macca isn't that bad as at least make people to consider the possibilities and reevaluate things.

We have two semi clears, a future clear (unless killed before claiming) and one nurse that saved Macca. If we can be sure the other nurse is in play and alive is almost auto win.

But there is too many "ifs" and "almost" on this, so we need to avoid the apathy in order to win.

Probably the most town you've appeared to be to me this game.

I think expect all possibilities but also assume the simplest path to arrive at a daykill.

[DemonRHK]

Hai peoples!

I see we’ve escape the brain drain.

##Vote rdr

Call it a tunnel, but a shot scum tried to deflect me off it, so imma ride or die here.

[damo666]

I don't see Macca or Brian as scum. Period.

If either are scum I'll eat my hat.

@Ham don't waste your vote please.

[Hamilton Brian]

##vote Worcej

[Hamilton Brian]

I was rereading everyone to come up with to help my gutreads make sense to me. I was absolutely too overwhelmed to finish reading all that Demon submitted.

[DemonRHK]

I was rereading everyone to come up with to help my gutreads make sense to me. I was absolutely too overwhelmed to finish reading all that Demon submitted.

My sides

[ND]

I don't see Macca or Brian as scum. Period.

If either are scum I'll eat my hat.

@Ham don't waste your vote please.

Lol

[ND]

I think I'm going to have to eat my hat about Will

[DemonRHK]

Aight here’s the deal.

I am not going to read anything I have missed unless it’s a case that comes up. You aren’t gonna daykill me, so let’s come together and just get rdr out so we can get another scum out, Kay?

[DemonRHK]

Also is rdr saying he is so lock on worc being town or just straight voting with a scumread of his?

[ND]

Why rdr. Only way I see him as scum is if the d1 bona vote + brain claim was to steer the day away from rdr. What else is there in terms of evidence e?

[rdrivera2005]

Also is rdr saying he is so lock on worc being town or just straight voting with a scumread of his?

Not lock on W orcej being town. There is too little info to have really solid scumreads, so it's a POE.

I think Macca, Brian, Spirit, Will and Kak are town. So, it's between you, ND, Damo and Worcej and this is the order I think we should go.

And you tunneling on me is useless, you won't get me day killed today and it's a complete lazy take. So either start doing something usefull or get killed.