MAFIA 83: HALLOWE'EN IN THE TOYSHOP - GAME THREAD

[Hamilton Brian]

Vecna, I don't know what your plan is but...

In light of the possibility that the doc items are gone (owners killed), it might be better you taking the shot sooner to avoid being the NK of mafia and losing the item.

I think Vecna should.

It can be very helpful to kill mafia right now.

Certainly, but since Brain is outed make the shot out of the other suspects.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I think Vecna should.

It can be very helpful to kill mafia right now.

Certainly, but since Brain is outed make the shot out of the other suspects.

Wouldn’t it be funny if Vecna killed HB.

Would be a twist lol

[ND]

I sent Jamie my vote. Makes sense to move this along asap. We got two hardcore scumbags to dispose of like yesterday's garbage.

[ND]

I expected the phase to change earlier hence my quick reads from the phone this afternoon. It's really rare that I can ever make an eod due to my job.

[Hamilton Brian]

Brain: Bona, Darg, Damo, Rivera, Worcej, then Bona finally. Does this protect Darg?

Damo: Worcej, Demon, Darg, Worcej, Bona, ND then Bona finally. Gives Bona the 5th vote.

Darg: Vecna, Sweet, Rivera, Brain, then landing on Rivera at 1:00 to go. Is Darg protecting Brain here because it is 3 Rivera and 3 Brain? But why not come back?

Demon: Vote on Rivera the whole time

JustAWill: Demon, Sweet, HB, Brain, Darg, Bona. Unnecessary move to Bona since it was not competitive. Could be said to be saving Brain.

Kak: Darg the whole day.

MaccaL Brain, then Ghug for a moment, then rest of time on Brain

ND: Started Ghug but then on JustAWill from the 31:48 mark.

Rivera: HB, then Darg with 00:20 to go.

Spirit: Bona the entire time

Sweet: ghug, then HB until I killed him.

Vecna: no vote

Worcej: Sweet (his vote on HB seemed shit), then Brain with 02:06 to go. Was Sweet vote a way of distancing? Because then it’s Brain….3 Darg 3 HB 2 Brian

[Hamilton Brian]

The red naturally reflected Mafia. Blue for town.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

JustAWill: Demon, Sweet, HB, Brain, Darg, Bona. Unnecessary move to Bona since it was not competitive. Could be said to be saving Brain.

I like this take honestly. It is a well thought out argument against me. Unlike someone else commonly referred to with two letters. But I did vote sweet which was my final vote choice before he got axed. And I highly scumread brain and was willing to vote him before the whole detective shenanigans.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Brain: Bona, Darg, Damo, Rivera, Worcej, then Bona finally. Does this protect Darg?

Damo: Worcej, Demon, Darg, Worcej, Bona, ND then Bona finally. Gives Bona the 5th vote.

Darg: Vecna, Sweet, Rivera, Brain, then landing on Rivera at 1:00 to go. Is Darg protecting Brain here because it is 3 Rivera and 3 Brain? But why not come back?

Demon: Vote on Rivera the whole time

JustAWill: Demon, Sweet, HB, Brain, Darg, Bona. Unnecessary move to Bona since it was not competitive. Could be said to be saving Brain.

Kak: Darg the whole day.

MaccaL Brain, then Ghug for a moment, then rest of time on Brain

ND: Started Ghug but then on JustAWill from the 31:48 mark.

Rivera: HB, then Darg with 00:20 to go.

Spirit: Bona the entire time

Sweet: ghug, then HB until I killed him.

Vecna: no vote

Worcej: Sweet (his vote on HB seemed shit), then Brain with 02:06 to go. Was Sweet vote a way of distancing? Because then it’s Brain….3 Darg 3 HB 2 Brian

Like how you put yourself in blue. Lol

[ND]

Hamilton is a town clear. He shot Sweet.

You are such a scumbag Will. Unbelievable.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Hamilton is a town clear. He shot Sweet.

You are such a scumbag Will. Unbelievable.

Are you reffering to the fact that I commented on his blue name? Because I just thought it was funny. I didn’t mean much of it.

ND who have your votes/ scumreads been the whole game, huh?
Seems to me you have bigger worries then me

[Hamilton Brian]

There was 2:53 to go when Sweet died. Those who posted, and thus confirmed Online until ghug got killed include Bona, Rivera, JustAWIll, Spirit, bozo, ghug, worcej. Ghug’s demise happened with 2:05 to go.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

JustAWill: Demon, Sweet, HB, Brain, Darg, Bona. Unnecessary move to Bona since it was not competitive. Could be said to be saving Brain.

I like this take honestly. It is a well thought out argument against me. Unlike someone else commonly referred to with two letters. But I did vote sweet which was my final vote choice before he got axed. And I highly scumread brain and was willing to vote him before the whole detective shenanigans.

Also if I am being honest, I should probably clear the air, I panic voted Bona. I wasn’t really paying attention to the case against Bona because I was much more worried about sweet. So when sweet kicked the bucket and I saw Bona had a lot of votes, I assumed Bona was probably obviously mafia because of how many votes he had.

[Hamilton Brian]

And with that I think I am gone until tomorrow morning. Hopefully there's a transition out of the night phase, but before then I hope Vecna has the wherewithall to make use of that repaired axe. And I think they know; hell we all know, who they need to hit.

[ND]

Hamilton is a town clear. He shot Sweet.

You are such a scumbag Will. Unbelievable.

Are you reffering to the fact that I commented on his blue name? Because I just thought it was funny. I didn’t mean much of it.

ND who have your votes/ scumreads been the whole game, huh?
Seems to me you have bigger worries then me

What's that supposed to mean scumbag?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Hamilton is a town clear. He shot Sweet.

You are such a scumbag Will. Unbelievable.

Are you reffering to the fact that I commented on his blue name? Because I just thought it was funny. I didn’t mean much of it.

ND who have your votes/ scumreads been the whole game, huh?
Seems to me you have bigger worries then me

What's that supposed to mean scumbag?

It means I’m mafia MWAHAHAH

It means you are going to get voted because you have comically terrible reads.

[ND]

Are you reffering to the fact that I commented on his blue name? Because I just thought it was funny. I didn’t mean much of it.

ND who have your votes/ scumreads been the whole game, huh?
Seems to me you have bigger worries then me

What's that supposed to mean scumbag?

It means I’m mafia MWAHAHAH

It means you are going to get voted because you have comically terrible reads.

There you have it. He just confessed to being mafia.

Now, everyone explain this to me?

"OH GEE ND HE IS TOWN HE MUST JUST BE JOKING" Idiots.

[ND]

So, it's just you and Brain isn't? You two might as well just concede. You have a zero percent chance of winning. You must know this, right?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

What's that supposed to mean scumbag?

It means I’m mafia MWAHAHAH

It means you are going to get voted because you have comically terrible reads.

There you have it. He just confessed to being mafia.

Now, everyone explain this to me?

"OH GEE ND HE IS TOWN HE MUST JUST BE JOKING" Idiots.

[TheMadMonarch]

Night 1 Readish list

Macca town. I approve the tinfoiling, although I think in the end, that the axing was done pretty straightforwardly… Ham killed Sweet (no doubt because of MY superior tinfoil analysis!) and a scum member independently fear killed ghug. At any rate, macca is reasonable, responds, and I townread her.

Brain scum. While the tedious work of reading all of the lowposters seems townier than not, I find brain not tunnelly enough to be town. I wonder if ole brain is attempting to appear his usual self (he’s even pointed out how like normal he is being.) I heartily doubt the claim. Brain has fake-claimed as any alignment, but I see no crumbs, AND he ticked my tell.

Vecna town. His absence and low post count notwithstanding, vecna is properly analytic, and attempts conversations rather than pronouncements. (He tends, I believe, towards pronouncements as scum.) More to the point, he does not care what anyone thinks of him or his points.

Ham town. Almost a clear, really. If there IS some convoluted oddness going on, it will show up later. I particularly liked his response to all the musing about axe shenanigans. Pulled me back from some of my leanings towards tinfoil shenanigans, tbh.

Kak scum. Kak is too tunnelly. Kak is unenthused. Kak has expressed no silliness. Kak is scum.

Darg town. Ole Darg stubbornly plays his own game. He is more brilliant than most folk see (as evidenced in his artful (although slightly silly) catch of sweet.

Rdr not really null, but some pulling both ways. My gut at EoD yesterday, in the sudden panic of wanting to change my tunnelled vote from sweet, jumped me to rdr. He is usually hard for me to read. It might be some omgus on my part, but rdr seems busy, without claiming to be busy.

ND town. Maybe the least of my town reads. But his pendantic and argumentation seems town. Angry, but not for no reason. The stubbornness about moving his vote to avoid a tie is slightly concerning.

Will town. He is clearly more experienced than his newbiness implies. I do not buy ND’s narrative about Will. His high level of involvement, with more than filler, feels town.

Bozo town. Not a lot to go on. I note no quizzes, surveys, math problems, or mechanical conundrums outlined. But that is actually NAI. Just gut at this point.

Spirit town. I like spirit’s jumping all over the place. But not without firmly planting his feet before the next jump.

Worcej scum or town. Worcej has been quiet. I do not recall if he has given a reason. But he is very calm. Too calm. (Mysterious hallowe’en music) A SLIGHT lean towards town because I think it might be self-restraint instead of unabashed saying what he wants to say.

So my scumlist is: brain, kak, and an unenthusiastic worcej or rdr.

This is suspicious to me. Darg is the only person (other than me, but I don't count), to have a correct read on BB? Is it because he already knew and was trying to save face before Brain's fakeclaim inevitably blew up in his face?

Not true. On page 52 I stated that brainbomb was my #1 read.

“Brainbomb: 75% chance or being mafia”

Is this to protect darg? Or incriminate yourself?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

This is suspicious to me. Darg is the only person (other than me, but I don't count), to have a correct read on BB? Is it because he already knew and was trying to save face before Brain's fakeclaim inevitably blew up in his face?

Not true. On page 52 I stated that brainbomb was my #1 read.

“Brainbomb: 75% chance or being mafia”

Is this to protect darg? Or incriminate yourself?

Kind of both. I do believe darg is mafia, but it is incorrect that only he had a correct read on brainbomb. I just don’t think having a CORRECT scum read on someone should incriminate you.? It doesn’t make sense. Other than that your case on darg is holding up well.