MAFIA 83: HALLOWE'EN IN THE TOYSHOP - GAME THREAD

[dargorygel]

@vecna is there any reason to wait? But probably shoot hunting rather than the one we know, and can get any time.

[dargorygel]

Macca, you are depending on a lot of high falutin' bussing... which is possible but unlikely.

[rdrivera2005]

Other then that I agree ND is a pretty good scum candidate.

as are you so far.

No, I am not. I am as pure as a white baby lamb.

[rdrivera2005]

@vecna is there any reason to wait? But probably shoot hunting rather than the one we know, and can get any time.

And have another useless day? Can you explain why it's a good idea?

[brainbomb]

who should we kill? we wanna hit someone who wont be nurse saved because the nurse kit is apparently an infinite town protection item that only expires once it actually succeeds. any suggestions on who probably isnt gonna be saved?

[brainbomb]

he doesnt look a thing like jesus
but
he

talks like a gentleman
like you imagined when you
were

younnnnnnggg

[Vecna]

who should we kill? we wanna hit someone who wont be nurse saved because the nurse kit is apparently an infinite town protection item that only expires once it actually succeeds. any suggestions on who probably isnt gonna be saved?

just roleblock the nurses brain, let me have some fun

[Hamilton Brian]

Would this bizarro situation be any better if I had microdosed this morning?

[ND]

Alright people,

Here are my reads. I won't be on at eon like I wasn't on yesterday because I have a life unlike most of you losers.

Brain: Hardcore scumbag.
Will: Hardcore scumbag
If there is another then it's probably Damo. I keep going back and forth on it but there was some anti town shit that went down eod1. Damo is like the perpetrator of it. Really sus shit. If it's not Damo then probably Darg.

Townclear: Hamilton, Macca
Null: everyone else is a nitwit, idiot, loser, or inconsequential pissant.

Okay I'm done. If they kill me then vote brain and will and we win.

Peace out losers

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Night 1 Readish list

Macca town. I approve the tinfoiling, although I think in the end, that the axing was done pretty straightforwardly… Ham killed Sweet (no doubt because of MY superior tinfoil analysis!) and a scum member independently fear killed ghug. At any rate, macca is reasonable, responds, and I townread her.

Brain scum. While the tedious work of reading all of the lowposters seems townier than not, I find brain not tunnelly enough to be town. I wonder if ole brain is attempting to appear his usual self (he’s even pointed out how like normal he is being.) I heartily doubt the claim. Brain has fake-claimed as any alignment, but I see no crumbs, AND he ticked my tell.

Vecna town. His absence and low post count notwithstanding, vecna is properly analytic, and attempts conversations rather than pronouncements. (He tends, I believe, towards pronouncements as scum.) More to the point, he does not care what anyone thinks of him or his points.

Ham town. Almost a clear, really. If there IS some convoluted oddness going on, it will show up later. I particularly liked his response to all the musing about axe shenanigans. Pulled me back from some of my leanings towards tinfoil shenanigans, tbh.

Kak scum. Kak is too tunnelly. Kak is unenthused. Kak has expressed no silliness. Kak is scum.

Darg town. Ole Darg stubbornly plays his own game. He is more brilliant than most folk see (as evidenced in his artful (although slightly silly) catch of sweet.

Rdr not really null, but some pulling both ways. My gut at EoD yesterday, in the sudden panic of wanting to change my tunnelled vote from sweet, jumped me to rdr. He is usually hard for me to read. It might be some omgus on my part, but rdr seems busy, without claiming to be busy.

ND town. Maybe the least of my town reads. But his pendantic and argumentation seems town. Angry, but not for no reason. The stubbornness about moving his vote to avoid a tie is slightly concerning.

Will town. He is clearly more experienced than his newbiness implies. I do not buy ND’s narrative about Will. His high level of involvement, with more than filler, feels town.

Bozo town. Not a lot to go on. I note no quizzes, surveys, math problems, or mechanical conundrums outlined. But that is actually NAI. Just gut at this point.

Spirit town. I like spirit’s jumping all over the place. But not without firmly planting his feet before the next jump.

Worcej scum or town. Worcej has been quiet. I do not recall if he has given a reason. But he is very calm. Too calm. (Mysterious hallowe’en music) A SLIGHT lean towards town because I think it might be self-restraint instead of unabashed saying what he wants to say.

So my scumlist is: brain, kak, and an unenthusiastic worcej or rdr.

This is suspicious to me. Darg is the only person (other than me, but I don't count), to have a correct read on BB? Is it because he already knew and was trying to save face before Brain's fakeclaim inevitably blew up in his face?

Not true. On page 52 I stated that brainbomb was my #1 read.

“Brainbomb: 75% chance or being mafia”

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

at present one mafia member is yelling at me for claiming and for last nights kill choice which I hijacked.

the other teammate is still mad about something said in the chat itself

and then our third guy wants to concede

and all of us are fighting over letting town have a short night or me living longer and they all want me to just die

He is clearly joking. I assume the mafia wouldn’t want to give out such useful information. And I assume that a dead mafia can’t chat in mafia chat (idk tho I’m not mafia) so this is clearly just trying to throw us off.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Alright people,

Here are my reads. I won't be on at eon like I wasn't on yesterday because I have a life unlike most of you losers.

Brain: Hardcore scumbag.
Will: Hardcore scumbag
If there is another then it's probably Damo. I keep going back and forth on it but there was some anti town shit that went down eod1. Damo is like the perpetrator of it. Really sus shit. If it's not Damo then probably Darg.

Townclear: Hamilton, Macca
Null: everyone else is a nitwit, idiot, loser, or inconsequential pissant.

Okay I'm done. If they kill me then vote brain and will and we win.

Peace out losers

Thanks for not calling me a nitwit

So kind.

[Vecna]

brain, i can guarantee you noone will be saving ND, so in case he's not scum, kindly kill him

[brainbomb]

brain, i can guarantee you noone will be saving ND, so in case he's not scum, kindly kill him

Ill talk it over with the girls and see what they think

[brainbomb]

our morale is very low as a scumteam. we did the math and 5 miskills is alot. so we havent even put in a kill, were debating conceding. one team member is convinced that theyll survive even a massclaim. but who knows.

were broken.

scattered.

divided.

and so sad

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Will’s spectacular mafia extravaganza!

ND: If you go back to page 15, when he originally pointed out my “not talking” comment, this was when he first voted me. Which means that ND’s entire case is built around one admittedly useless piece of info. He has not strayed, meaning that he most likely doesn’t want to change because it would look suspicious. ND is definitely on my scum radar. 25% scum chance

Brainbomb: I wonder 99% chance scum (maybe everything just went terribly and half the players are gambitting on a wild play) never tell me the odds

Bona: poor bona rip

Hamilton Brian: Hamilton Brian voted me as mafia. Hamilton Brian jumped on me because: “
Sweet we definitely NOT bussing. I knew that shit smelled bad all day yesterday. Now Bona and Ghug on there too? Why would mafia coalesce like that? Makes me think they might be clear.


But Will jumping on? Maybe ND is totally on to something”
This is quite frankly idiotic because, shocker, sweet was mafia. I have a big read on an HB scumread. 40% scum chance

Macca: 0% scum chance unless someone else claims the detective kit. Then it goes up to 50%

Sweetandcool: 100% scum chance. Lol

Ghug: Ghug ghugged all last ghug, so ghug think that ghug is ghug. 0% ghug ghug

Bozothe clown: rip bozo

Jamie: it would be funny if Jamie claimed he was mafia. Would throw the game for a loop. (ND i know that he isn’t playing. Its a joke)

Dargorygel: darg voted sweet early, which makes me think that this was either a lucky guess (unlikely) or was intentionally set up by him to claim he was anti-sweet. That is my theory. But wait! There’s more! Darg goes hard on sweet. This is probably because if sweet dies, and brain didnt accidentally shoot himself in the foot, both brain and darg could claim they were anti sweet. This is a good alibi. BUT… darg switches his vote to rdr. Then to brain. With very little prompting. Then BACK to rdr. This is extremely suspicious. Darg is my #1 scumread 77% scum chance. Also how did darg know brain had a skull and not the armor, is it his item? He didn’t specify.

Spirit: sussed Macca when it is clear Macca is town. Called bozo town and was right. He did not give a read on brain. He called sweet scum. He was correct. Called me town and is correct. 5% chance scum.

Damo: 25% chance scum. Has not contributed much

Vecna, rdr, kak, and Demon i have no inclination on.

Worcej: 50% scum. I believe worcej may be scum.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Will’s spectacular mafia extravaganza!

ND: If you go back to page 15, when he originally pointed out my “not talking” comment, this was when he first voted me. Which means that ND’s entire case is built around one admittedly useless piece of info. He has not strayed, meaning that he most likely doesn’t want to change because it would look suspicious. ND is definitely on my scum radar. 25% scum chance

Brainbomb: I wonder 99% chance scum (maybe everything just went terribly and half the players are gambitting on a wild play) never tell me the odds

Bona: poor bona rip

Hamilton Brian: Hamilton Brian voted me as mafia. Hamilton Brian jumped on me because: “
Sweet we definitely NOT bussing. I knew that shit smelled bad all day yesterday. Now Bona and Ghug on there too? Why would mafia coalesce like that? Makes me think they might be clear.


But Will jumping on? Maybe ND is totally on to something”
This is quite frankly idiotic because, shocker, sweet was mafia. I have a big read on an HB scumread. 40% scum chance

Macca: 0% scum chance unless someone else claims the detective kit. Then it goes up to 50%

Sweetandcool: 100% scum chance. Lol

Ghug: Ghug ghugged all last ghug, so ghug think that ghug is ghug. 0% ghug ghug

Bozothe clown: rip bozo

Jamie: it would be funny if Jamie claimed he was mafia. Would throw the game for a loop. (ND i know that he isn’t playing. Its a joke)

Dargorygel: darg voted sweet early, which makes me think that this was either a lucky guess (unlikely) or was intentionally set up by him to claim he was anti-sweet. That is my theory. But wait! There’s more! Darg goes hard on sweet. This is probably because if sweet dies, and brain didnt accidentally shoot himself in the foot, both brain and darg could claim they were anti sweet. This is a good alibi. BUT… darg switches his vote to rdr. Then to brain. With very little prompting. Then BACK to rdr. This is extremely suspicious. Darg is my #1 scumread 77% scum chance. Also how did darg know brain had a skull and not the armor, is it his item? He didn’t specify.

Spirit: sussed Macca when it is clear Macca is town. Called bozo town and was right. He did not give a read on brain. He called sweet scum. He was correct. Called me town and is correct. 5% chance scum.

Damo: 25% chance scum. Has not contributed much

Vecna, rdr, kak, and Demon i have no inclination on.

Worcej: 50% scum. I believe worcej may be scum.

Note that these percentages don’t add up. These percentages are more of a meter from 0-100 that my suspicion is on.

[dargorygel]

He needs better math in many ways.

I knew tge skull instead of armor AT THE VERY LEAST because i read the setup.

I explained, my switches. I moved because sweet had been shot. I mived to rdr on gut. As a gut read. Then i moved to brain because in the fast glurry, during which i was at work, i was scrambling. I did scum read brain, but his reaction to me locked it in. When he claimed of course I left his wagon.

Are youreading the thread or just the bot?.

[dargorygel]

He needs better math in many ways.

I knew tge skull instead of armor AT THE VERY LEAST because i read the setup.

I explained, my switches. I moved because sweet had been shot. I mived to rdr on gut. As a gut read. Then i moved to brain because in the fast glurry, during which i was at work, i was scrambling. I did scum read brain, but his reaction to me locked it in. When he claimed of course I left his wagon.

Are youreading the thread or just the bot?.

[dargorygel]

He needs better math in many ways.

I knew tge skull instead of armor AT THE VERY LEAST because i read the setup.

I explained, my switches. I moved because sweet had been shot. I mived to rdr on gut. As a gut read. Then i moved to brain because in the fast glurry, during which i was at work, i was scrambling. I did scum read brain, but his reaction to me locked it in. When he claimed of course I left his wagon.

Are you reading the thread or just the bot?.

And are you fishing fir items? Your team should killl me o find out what i have