MAFIA 83: HALLOWE'EN IN THE TOYSHOP - GAME THREAD

[damo666]

3 deaths already. okay then.

You're lucky it wasn't 4

[Vecna]

indeed. i was negligent and jamiet decided to not smite me.

ill try to be better going forward

[Hamilton Brian]

If we take damo's assertion that there are no mafia on Bona on its face, then that leaves a pool of: Kak, Rivera, macca, worcej, demon, darg, ND, and Vecna. So 2 or 3 out of that pool are mafia.

But what's more believable? There was no mafia on Bona or there was one or more mafia on Bona?

[Vecna]

Willie is new, and I think new people tend to say weird things like this. I'll confess, I definitely chuckled when he apologized for not talking and then followed up immediately by stating he was scumreading people who hadn't talked.

He probably just meant that at the end of the day he'd vote for a non-poster, which is fair enough.

I feel dumb right now. I was so tired i just wanted to get my posting in so I couldn’t be caught as a nonposter, which I thought was a bad thing. Idk the nonposters have less votes then me

Don't beat yourself up too much. People (rightfully) like to complain about nonposters, but as long as you post something of note before EoD (end of day), then it's not much of a problem.

Unfortunately, your posts were contradictory and insubstantial. So I can't blame ND for suspecting you.

Regardless, I wouldn't be too worried yet. D1 votes tend to shift on a dime and people who are in the lead the whole day tend to not be voted in the end.

sweet n cool did a lot of talking at will.

could bith be safeguardibg a teammate or mother goosing a poor newby town.

the way he says here "I cant blame ND for suspecting you" really reads more as an informed scum talking to a town though.

[brainbomb]

From the Abomidable snowman lair

ND: this is stupid youre all pathetic and this is dumb, and idiotic

worcej: but we got bona dead. durt hurr uhhh yea

ND: youre an idiot and a fool

Hamilton: guys wanna do some DMT

ND: I am a far right wing fanatic, I do not use drugs. I only support guns, alcohol, tobacco, and reversing the suffrage movement

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I feel dumb right now. I was so tired i just wanted to get my posting in so I couldn’t be caught as a nonposter, which I thought was a bad thing. Idk the nonposters have less votes then me

Don't beat yourself up too much. People (rightfully) like to complain about nonposters, but as long as you post something of note before EoD (end of day), then it's not much of a problem.

Unfortunately, your posts were contradictory and insubstantial. So I can't blame ND for suspecting you.

Regardless, I wouldn't be too worried yet. D1 votes tend to shift on a dime and people who are in the lead the whole day tend to not be voted in the end.

sweet n cool did a lot of talking at will.

could bith be safeguardibg a teammate or mother goosing a poor newby town.

the way he says here "I cant blame ND for suspecting you" really reads more as an informed scum talking to a town though.

I don’t understand what is so contradictory about my statements.

When I said that I disliked nonposters, I meant that. That is why I apologized for not posting in that same message, because I wanted it to be known that it was not the norm for me to be inactive. ND just wants a target.

[damo666]

If we take damo's assertion that there are no mafia on Bona on its face, then that leaves a pool of: Kak, Rivera, macca, worcej, demon, darg, ND, and Vecna. So 2 or 3 out of that pool are mafia.

But what's more believable? There was no mafia on Bona or there was one or more mafia on Bona?

Of the Bona voters I assume you and brain are town, I know I am, I suspect Will is, that only leaves Spirit and Bozo. One tops I'd say but more likely none.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

FOR REFERENCE

Page 3:
Vecna has been voted for byGhug.
Ghug has been voted for by Sweetandcool
Brain has been voted for by Macca

None of these have much merit, most likely as jokes

Bona votes kak as a joke. No weight to his decision. Disregard.

Page 4: Ghost Rider HELL YEAH

Brainbomb notes that sweet already has reads.
ND is noted to be less standoffish than usual (according to brain)

Ghug votes sweetandcool as a joke.

Page 5:

Ghug notes brainboms post that ND is more observant and less assholish. Ghug states that ND may be scum because of this.

Sweetandcool unvotes

Brainbomb accuses macca of being mafia because of macca’s joke vote

ND notes his observant and nonasshole nature

Page 6:

ND starts a “train” on himself. Votes himself.

Dargoyel votes Vecna

Dargoyel proposes a mass claim of items.

Page 7:
Bona protects Macca from brainbomb’s claim that Macca is mafia because of a joke vote.

Bona is opposed to massclaim

Darg states that a massclaim may be a viable option

Sweetandcool notes that brainbomb is acting weird

Page 8: Nothing of note

Page 9: Spirit expresses his dislike of the massclaim idea

Brainbomb notes ghug is towny

Brainbomb is called the “meta guy”. Lol

Filler

Page 10:

Brainbomb is criticized for being “too reliant on meta” by sweetandcool

EDITGATE (dramatic music)

Brainbomb: “darg is one of those players who will try to be personable as town and as scum will be more likely to just latch onto someone to vote for. already hes been more personable than hungry.”

brainbomb notes that Hamilton is coming off a mafia loss. Brain expects hamilton to show signs of being relieved or at ease this game if he were town. Brain declares he has not seen such behavior.

MORE IS TO COME

[dargorygel]

I did not propose massclaim. But go on.

[Hamilton Brian]

sweet n cool did a lot of talking at will.

could bith be safeguardibg a teammate or mother goosing a poor newby town.

the way he says here "I cant blame ND for suspecting you" really reads more as an informed scum talking to a town though.

Good pick-up. Could it be..."They're on to you; cool it before you make it worse?"

Going back to the post that twigged ND where JustAWill mentions not talking and mafiareading those that don't talk...maybe it's as bad as ND is asserting?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Anybody wanna talk about mass reveal of items before scum meets to plan?

Is this not proposing a massclaim?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

sweet n cool did a lot of talking at will.

could bith be safeguardibg a teammate or mother goosing a poor newby town.

the way he says here "I cant blame ND for suspecting you" really reads more as an informed scum talking to a town though.

Good pick-up. Could it be..."They're on to you; cool it before you make it worse?"

Going back to the post that twigged ND where JustAWill mentions not talking and mafiareading those that don't talk...maybe it's as bad as ND is asserting?

But I voted sweet?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

sweet n cool did a lot of talking at will.

could bith be safeguardibg a teammate or mother goosing a poor newby town.

the way he says here "I cant blame ND for suspecting you" really reads more as an informed scum talking to a town though.

Good pick-up. Could it be..."They're on to you; cool it before you make it worse?"

Going back to the post that twigged ND where JustAWill mentions not talking and mafiareading those that don't talk...maybe it's as bad as ND is asserting?

But I voted sweet?

I feel like that should be a red flag in NDs claim

[dargorygel]

Anybody wanna talk about mass reveal of items before scum meets to plan?

Is this not proposing a massclaim?

No... it is asking for discussion. Which I received

[dargorygel]

Anybody wanna talk about mass reveal of items before scum meets to plan?

Is this not proposing a massclaim?

No... it is asking for discussion. Which I received

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Anybody wanna talk about mass reveal of items before scum meets to plan?

Is this not proposing a massclaim?

No... it is asking for discussion. Which I received

Ah I see. This is the power of discussion.

[TheMadMonarch]

Still reading through, but I just checked the bot.

The fuck happened guys

[TheMadMonarch]

having a good think about it is always a good idea (well, except when it's one minute before EoD and the whole game is depending on your answer), though I think ghug looks good enough.

I'm interested now, what did brain and ghug do or write (or not do/write) to get your vote?

The only obvious thing is that he actually read the set-up. Other than that he's just generally suspicious.

I have to read the setup because I'm on the Kouncil now.

fair

[TheMadMonarch]

Suddenly.... A TERRIBLE SCREAM RINGS OUT.

One of the toys was found on the floor towards the back of the shop, with their plastic head hacked clean off.

Sweetandcool has died! They were the CHUCKY DOLL, an EVIL TOY!

Game continues...

HOLY SHIT!

well done

[TheMadMonarch]

Suddenly..... ANOTHER TERRIBLE SCREAM RINGS OUT!

The toys rushed to the source of the sound and found that:

GHUG has died. He was the CAPTAIN PICARD ACTION FIGURE, a Nice Toy!

(Game continues).

Based on timings, I would think whoever called this shot, did so before HB claimed the first one. Given that and this post from ghug.

Suddenly.... A TERRIBLE SCREAM RINGS OUT.

One of the toys was found on the floor towards the back of the shop, with their plastic head hacked clean off.

Sweetandcool has died! They were the CHUCKY DOLL, an EVIL TOY!

Game continues...

Holy shit I was right

I think its possible a scum member saw this as a ghug claim (which would cement him [-ish] as town), and decided to get rid of a conf townie. maybe. My first thought when I saw this ghug post was that he did it.