M1026: ghughog Day [Game Thread]

[brainbomb]

your argument is flawed because when damo voted it was already ND 4-3 anyway
he claims he crossposted.
its possible he didnt, this is not the most important talking point anyway

[brainbomb]

I consider the duality of claiming the game is easy and gonna be over soon while also soliciting from people who theyd vote for in f3 to be more mafia indicative of peicing together what type of endgame he wants to aim for

[bozotheclown]

My suspect list is worcej>>>>>>Jamie>brain>>>>>>sweet

I'll be surprised if the NK is outside bozo/me/Ham

I think worcej being the D2 kill looks inevitable.

I also think there's a 66% chance of at least one doc save in the first two nights so even if worcej flips town we're still in decent shape.

Wcs worcej town, no saves, last three me, Jamie, brain.

this moves the goalposts in such a strange way. How can you force me to break the tie and then a few hours later list me as a busser. I had to vote ND or we wouldve had no flip at all.

I also thought after D1 that you could have been bussing by voting for ND after your vote moves did not get anyone to move off of ND. Also, damo did not force you to break the tie, damo broke the tie at 4 minutes, then your vote caused another tie. Then, damo voted to break the tie again in the last minute, but your vote, which he likely did not see, had broken the tie first.

[brainbomb]

and bozo
literally no one else is doing any of that

weve demanded the poe present who they scumread
worcej did that
sweet did that
ham did that

damo just basically said everyone is eligible
and then when I claimed he moved the goal posts again to fit the circumstance

[bozotheclown]

damo was not willing to kill ND and I don't know if he really calls ND town ever bit just says he wasn't willing to go there. its pretty obstinate to do this to the bitter end and seems alot like damo just wanting the end of day to go a different way that was more interesting to him. we all do this.
mhe was asked by bozo if he was willing to unbreak the tie and he was openly saying he would not do so.

which made it forced that I would be the one to have to do so.

ill need to reread but if damo later concluded that I bussed and that my vote on ND was scummy then damo is also aware he refused so I had no other choice. which would be hipocrisy

damo did not say he would not break the tie, he said he would not vote for ND to break the tie. damo did break the tie when he moved his vote at 4 minutes, and I believe he was trying to again when he moved his vote in the last minute.

this isnt true

We can't leave it at 3-3

Are you willing to vote for ND to break the tie?

No

[brainbomb]

I respectfully disagree with your conclusions on the grounds that damo comes off as opportunistic while trying to portray himself as “yea sure cool
lets go with that”

he pretty much is okay with anyone but hamilton dying because he thinks ham is a good f3 candidate to have around

[bozotheclown]

your argument is flawed because when damo voted it was already ND 4-3 anyway
he claims he crossposted.
its possible he didnt, this is not the most important talking point anyway

He did break the tie at 4 minutes, though, and very well could have been trying to with his last vote, although we can't know for sure if he saw your vote.

[brainbomb]

no one else is doing any of that
no one else but damo is claiming game is about to end
and no one else is also claiming we need to be worried about who would vote for who in f3

[bozotheclown]

and bozo
literally no one else is doing any of that

weve demanded the poe present who they scumread
worcej did that
sweet did that
ham did that

damo just basically said everyone is eligible
and then when I claimed he moved the goal posts again to fit the circumstance

I think damo was clear with his scum reads.

[bozotheclown]

your argument is flawed because when damo voted it was already ND 4-3 anyway
he claims he crossposted.
its possible he didnt, this is not the most important talking point anyway

Don't you see that damo put ND in the lead at 3-2, and you are the one who tied it at 3-3?

[bozotheclown]

your argument is flawed because when damo voted it was already ND 4-3 anyway
he claims he crossposted.
its possible he didnt, this is not the most important talking point anyway

Don't you see that damo put ND in the lead at 3-2, and you are the one who tied it at 3-3?

Why do you think he would do that as mafia?

[worcej]

and bozo
literally no one else is doing any of that

weve demanded the poe present who they scumread
worcej did that
sweet did that
ham did that

damo just basically said everyone is eligible
and then when I claimed he moved the goal posts again to fit the circumstance

I think this is too dismissive of damo - my issue with him is he has stated people with no real reasoning for his read.

[brainbomb]

and bozo
literally no one else is doing any of that

weve demanded the poe present who they scumread
worcej did that
sweet did that
ham did that

damo just basically said everyone is eligible
and then when I claimed he moved the goal posts again to fit the circumstance

I think damo was clear with his scum reads.

He clearly was not
at end of day 1 he said it probably isnt a busser and its likely sweet or worcej
then he adjusted when you did
and claimed it was worcej-jamie-bb-sweet was his poe
then when you survived he said it was worc or sweet
then when worc was arguing well he said its sweet
then when worc kept saying bb is scum he changed me yo be third then second scummiest
then he wanted jamie to say who he would vote for in an f3 with me
then when i claimed he was back to sweet and worc and game is super easy

[bozotheclown]

I respectfully disagree with your conclusions on the grounds that damo comes off as opportunistic while trying to portray himself as “yea sure cool
lets go with that”

he pretty much is okay with anyone but hamilton dying because he thinks ham is a good f3 candidate to have around

I think he is OK with sweetandcool, worcej, or Jamie being the DK because he knows we have 3 chances to get the last mafia and those are the players he thinks might be mafia.

[bozotheclown]

and bozo
literally no one else is doing any of that

weve demanded the poe present who they scumread
worcej did that
sweet did that
ham did that

damo just basically said everyone is eligible
and then when I claimed he moved the goal posts again to fit the circumstance

I think damo was clear with his scum reads.

He clearly was not
at end of day 1 he said it probably isnt a busser and its likely sweet or worcej
then he adjusted when you did
and claimed it was worcej-jamie-bb-sweet was his poe
then when you survived he said it was worc or sweet
then when worc was arguing well he said its sweet
then when worc kept saying bb is scum he changed me yo be third then second scummiest
then he wanted jamie to say who he would vote for in an f3 with me
then when i claimed he was back to sweet and worc and game is super easy

Maybe he is town and not certain, and has adjusted his reads as things happen.

[brainbomb]

no.
this is simply not how he would play as town. he doesnt give a shit about this as town

[brainbomb]

i mean if you wanna do something else its jamie you have to convince. thats fine. do that.

[worcej]

your argument is flawed because when damo voted it was already ND 4-3 anyway
he claims he crossposted.
its possible he didnt, this is not the most important talking point anyway

Don't you see that damo put ND in the lead at 3-2, and you are the one who tied it at 3-3?

Damo did this by moving his vote off to Jamie to make a 3-2-2 situation and I believe that was more to allow for consolidation options from others, such as myself, to get a non-ND wagon tied again.

[brainbomb]

worcej to be clear are you arguing damo should be spared?

because then you die so go ahead and say what you think clearly and simply

[brainbomb]

I respectfully disagree with your conclusions on the grounds that damo comes off as opportunistic while trying to portray himself as “yea sure cool
lets go with that”

he pretty much is okay with anyone but hamilton dying because he thinks ham is a good f3 candidate to have around

I think he is OK with sweetandcool, worcej, or Jamie being the DK because he knows we have 3 chances to get the last mafia and those are the players he thinks might be mafia.

okay but that doesnt make sense why hes so certain on hamilton then