M82: Magic the Gathering Mafia [Game Thread]

[sweetandcool]

Somehow I missed that.

But other than that, which honestly is the same attitude I am currently taking, why would you think voting Bona makes sense
As far as pairs go, Bona + Kak is the strongest one we have.

[Kakarroto]

well I know I'm town. I'm convinced rd is town too and I'm extremely sure you are town too, sweet.

That leaves 4 other people for 3 mafia. I think Brian is one of it. When Vecna put out the theory of bona bussing bunny because he is the black knight, it made kinda sense. And if that's case we should vote bona before bunny.

But yeah, there is also the possibility of maf-Vecna just guiding us to another mk.

And for the bona-kak maf-pair, I can only say that it's not it. Maybe we are both town, maybe bona is mafia, but we surly aren't mafia together.

[Bonatogether]

Somehow I missed that.

But other than that, which honestly is the same attitude I am currently taking, why would you think voting Bona makes sense
As far as pairs go, Bona + Kak is the strongest one we have.

i strongly dispute that kak and i are paired

if you actually read eod1, i was voting damo not out of a reason for him, but in tie avoidance

[sweetandcool]

Somehow I missed that.

But other than that, which honestly is the same attitude I am currently taking, why would you think voting Bona makes sense
As far as pairs go, Bona + Kak is the strongest one we have.

i strongly dispute that kak and i are paired

if you actually read eod1, i was voting damo not out of a reason for him, but in tie avoidance

I read and did an extensive VCA on it. But Vecn's theory, which I disagree with, doesn't come from nowhere and it's at least plausible that you two are a Mafia team, at least, if you only consider the VCA and ignore everything else.

Let's just suppose the three of us are town (I think that just means Kak decides Bona is town).

Then who would we vote? Who would be the last Town?

[sweetandcool]

I guess Kak and I would vote Ham. Bona, even if you are right about Bunny, would you consolidate with town on Ham first? Or is Ham a bad vote?

And if you are right about Bunny, does that make Vecna the final town?

[brainbomb]

Find Waldo Now
Gary got tired of Magic the Gathering and switched to Waldo books.


Hamilton Brian (3) Kakarroto sweetandcool BunnyGo
Bonatogether (1) Vecna
BunnyGo (1) Bonatogether

Non-votes
Hamilton Brian
rdrivera2005

Currently Hamilton is scheduled to be eliminated

[sweetandcool]

Gah, they both left. Okay, is it time for the PR to come out and play? I'm going to predict it is Vecna but idk that's practically a random guess.

[Bonatogether]

I guess Kak and I would vote Ham. Bona, even if you are right about Bunny, would you consolidate with town on Ham first? Or is Ham a bad vote?

And if you are right about Bunny, does that make Vecna the final town?

if vecna is the final town, he'd be wrong on rdr, which i deem unlikely. therefore if rdr is scum, vecna must be as well.

i haven't really thought about hamilton so hard to say

[sweetandcool]

I guess Kak and I would vote Ham. Bona, even if you are right about Bunny, would you consolidate with town on Ham first? Or is Ham a bad vote?

And if you are right about Bunny, does that make Vecna the final town?

if vecna is the final town, he'd be wrong on rdr, which i deem unlikely. therefore if rdr is scum, vecna must be as well.

i haven't really thought about hamilton so hard to say

Could you explain that more for me? I don't understand.

Why would it be unlikely for Town Vecna to be wrong about rdr?

[sweetandcool]

I guess Kak and I would vote Ham. Bona, even if you are right about Bunny, would you consolidate with town on Ham first? Or is Ham a bad vote?

And if you are right about Bunny, does that make Vecna the final town?

if vecna is the final town, he'd be wrong on rdr, which i deem unlikely. therefore if rdr is scum, vecna must be as well.

i haven't really thought about hamilton so hard to say

If not Vecna, the who would be final town? Assuming that Kak and I are town.

[Bonatogether]

I guess Kak and I would vote Ham. Bona, even if you are right about Bunny, would you consolidate with town on Ham first? Or is Ham a bad vote?

And if you are right about Bunny, does that make Vecna the final town?

if vecna is the final town, he'd be wrong on rdr, which i deem unlikely. therefore if rdr is scum, vecna must be as well.

i haven't really thought about hamilton so hard to say

Could you explain that more for me? I don't understand.

Why would it be unlikely for Town Vecna to be wrong about rdr?

i believe town!vecna understands rdr

if you say all four scum are in vecna, rdr, ham, bunny, then either vecna is town and wrong (which i don't think is likely), or scum vecna is white knighting rdr, or a scum pair.

so i say in the world where that poe of 4 is correct, that rdr being scum implies vecna is scum, but not all worlds where vecna is scum need rdr to be scum

[BunnyGo]

##vote hamil, mark hamil.

Reasons for the naked vote?

In the POE. And must vote with kak. Willing to change to anyone else in my POE that kak will vote for.

[Bonatogether]

this day is suspiciously low activity

[BunnyGo]

I guess Kak and I would vote Ham. Bona, even if you are right about Bunny, would you consolidate with town on Ham first? Or is Ham a bad vote?

And if you are right about Bunny, does that make Vecna the final town?

Kak. You see this is sus, right?

Sweet open wolfing?

I see kak, and bona as town. But we can’t miss on the 4th. If you’re sure it’s rdr, then sweet MUST be a wolf.

[BunnyGo]

Gah, they both left. Okay, is it time for the PR to come out and play? I'm going to predict it is Vecna but idk that's practically a random guess.

This is soooo false. And sweet should know better.

##vote sweet.

[BunnyGo]

this day is suspiciously low activity

Yes.

Hey bona, let’s solve this.

You, me, kak. And?

Kak says it’s rdr

You say it’s sweet

I say…gah. Maybe either of those. Maybe Vecna.

But we’re all good voting Hamilton. Which is weird for low activity?

What’s the scum team doing in ANY of those cases?

Case 1: sweet-Vecna-ham. Sweet wolfing makes sense. Vecna can do anything. Hamilton lurking makes sense too.

Case 2: rdr-Vecna-ham. Same as above but rdr played odd for scum.

Case 3: rdr-sweet-ham. I could see it too.

Thoughts?

[Bonatogether]

this day is suspiciously low activity

Yes.

Hey bona, let’s solve this.

You, me, kak. And?

Kak says it’s rdr

You say it’s sweet

I say…gah. Maybe either of those. Maybe Vecna.

But we’re all good voting Hamilton. Which is weird for low activity?

What’s the scum team doing in ANY of those cases?

Case 1: sweet-Vecna-ham. Sweet wolfing makes sense. Vecna can do anything. Hamilton lurking makes sense too.

Case 2: rdr-Vecna-ham. Same as above but rdr played odd for scum.

Case 3: rdr-sweet-ham. I could see it too.

Thoughts?

i don't accept your premise

[BunnyGo]

this day is suspiciously low activity

Yes.

Hey bona, let’s solve this.

You, me, kak. And?

Kak says it’s rdr

You say it’s sweet

I say…gah. Maybe either of those. Maybe Vecna.

But we’re all good voting Hamilton. Which is weird for low activity?

What’s the scum team doing in ANY of those cases?

Case 1: sweet-Vecna-ham. Sweet wolfing makes sense. Vecna can do anything. Hamilton lurking makes sense too.

Case 2: rdr-Vecna-ham. Same as above but rdr played odd for scum.

Case 3: rdr-sweet-ham. I could see it too.

Thoughts?

i don't accept your premise

Well…then we will lose eventually. But we can also delay that loss until later and find mutual ground before that.

So, you say you and sweet and kak are town.

That means all but one of the other players are wolves. Let’s get one…

[BunnyGo]

##vote ham bone

[Bonatogether]

Yes.

Hey bona, let’s solve this.

You, me, kak. And?

Kak says it’s rdr

You say it’s sweet

I say…gah. Maybe either of those. Maybe Vecna.

But we’re all good voting Hamilton. Which is weird for low activity?

What’s the scum team doing in ANY of those cases?

Case 1: sweet-Vecna-ham. Sweet wolfing makes sense. Vecna can do anything. Hamilton lurking makes sense too.

Case 2: rdr-Vecna-ham. Same as above but rdr played odd for scum.

Case 3: rdr-sweet-ham. I could see it too.

Thoughts?

i don't accept your premise

Well…then we will lose eventually. But we can also delay that loss until later and find mutual ground before that.

So, you say you and sweet and kak are town.

That means all but one of the other players are wolves. Let’s get one…

true but i'm more sure on you than i am on the other 3