M82: Magic the Gathering Mafia [Game Thread]

[Bonatogether]

i think bunnygo is likely scum and i'm going to make a wallpost for it

[sweetandcool]

Wow, Fox being Town legit blows my mind. Glad we all posted at the last moment because I think this is going to be so helpful.

I am busy on Sundays, not to mention it being my MIL's birthday, so I would appreciate no silly hammers.

yeah, I know that feeling.

I also had an idea just now: maybe mafia was hunting for the last PR. They removed ghug N1 and we thought it was because of his thoughts. Well, maybe partially, but did they choose him because mafia thought he was a PR? Maybe the same was with fox, just a try to get the last PR?

Well, maybe we shouldn't talk too much about it, but it might explain the choice. Well, they also could've tried to make it look like a certain person or group made the kill? But yeah, it makes you think.

Also, I hope for a great birthday at your mother in law (? if I see this correctly). Also no hammers are preferred by me. I fully need to reread fox with new eyes.

Thanks, yeah MIL=Mother In Law, for once I didn't feel like writing it out and saved time with the abreviation.

It was a successful day. The grandkids were sweet for her, the cake was an absolute triumph, she even thought it looked pretty which was nice to hear because decoration is easily my weakest point.

We are now home and the kids are down for a late nap, we're relaxing and I don't think I'll get any game stuff done until either tonight or tomorrow.

[sweetandcool]

I know people aren't used to performative sweetandcool, and I tend to play in a very guileless way.

However, I was being very performative N2. No, I don't think I'm locktown by any means, but I was relying on the fact that Bunny claimed I townslipped. I thought that was enough to secure me.

But now I've been betrayed by Bunny, and people hate performative sweetandcool, so I'm a bit worried. Actually, I think that's besides the point, because even if town doesn't fall into the trap of voting me, I don't think it's likely we'll even come to a consensus in order to survive today anyways.

I am disturbed at the mudslinging going on between Bunny and Vecna, who I'm pretty sure are both town. Now Bona is chiming in against Bunny too apparently.

I definitely need to take another gander, but Vecna, Bunny, Kak, and I are town (I know I'm town because I know my alignment).

If I'm wrong anywhere, I guess it must be one of Vecna and Bunny. For various reasons Kak was already a town read, and on top of that the whole GM thing strongly indicated Town for Kak (I think Town was done dirty by that whole situation, so I don't think it's wrong to use that information [and yes I could be wrong about GM motivation, but I find it hard to believe Kak wouldn't be modkilled if they were Mafia]).

[sweetandcool]

And of course being wrong about Fox damages my reads.

I will reanalyze and reassess, but that's where I'm at right now.

[Bonatogether]

drawing conclusions from gm actions that aren't specifically and clearly game related (ie, basically anything other than pr info) is a dangerous game

i'd recommend you drop it and find another reason

[sweetandcool]

drawing conclusions from gm actions that aren't specifically and clearly game related (ie, basically anything other than pr info) is a dangerous game

i'd recommend you drop it and find another reason

Fine. I already strongly townread Kak and nothing has changed that.

[sweetandcool]

Since Fox was Town, and I know I am Town, it's extremely interesting that Mafia wasn't around for EoD. We were the only two around.

[BunnyGo]

Sweet. I’m mostly with you.

Sadly bona was a townread of mine…so if I’m right about him and he’s wrong about me this time.

Either way I want to point out to EVERYONE that rdr is playing identical to last game and is also STILL ALIVE. Both are scum tells. He’s also in everyone’s POE (except Vecna, who didn’t even MENTION RDR!!)

##vote rdr

[BunnyGo]

I know people aren't used to performative sweetandcool, and I tend to play in a very guileless way.

However, I was being very performative N2. No, I don't think I'm locktown by any means, but I was relying on the fact that Bunny claimed I townslipped. I thought that was enough to secure me.

But now I've been betrayed by Bunny, and people hate performative sweetandcool, so I'm a bit worried. Actually, I think that's besides the point, because even if town doesn't fall into the trap of voting me, I don't think it's likely we'll even come to a consensus in order to survive today anyways.

I am disturbed at the mudslinging going on between Bunny and Vecna, who I'm pretty sure are both town. Now Bona is chiming in against Bunny too apparently.

I definitely need to take another gander, but Vecna, Bunny, Kak, and I are town (I know I'm town because I know my alignment).

If I'm wrong anywhere, I guess it must be one of Vecna and Bunny. For various reasons Kak was already a town read, and on top of that the whole GM thing strongly indicated Town for Kak (I think Town was done dirty by that whole situation, so I don't think it's wrong to use that information [and yes I could be wrong about GM motivation, but I find it hard to believe Kak wouldn't be modkilled if they were Mafia]).

I’m not slinging mud at Vecna. I’m slinging mud at you. You deserve it. Stop harassing the GM. That was really uncool.

Vecna, we cool? Did I miss something?

[sweetandcool]

Sweet. I’m mostly with you.

Sadly bona was a townread of mine…so if I’m right about him and he’s wrong about me this time.

Either way I want to point out to EVERYONE that rdr is playing identical to last game and is also STILL ALIVE. Both are scum tells. He’s also in everyone’s POE (except Vecna, who didn’t even MENTION RDR!!)

##vote rdr

I think one difference is that I don't think anyone has really actually even casually expressed suspicion of rdr this game. Last game there was plenty of it, but nobody acted on it because they were distracted.

But yeah, rdr is simply in my purview because there is noone else left who it could be.

My scumpool is literally 3 now.

So I guess I could vote rdr.

Bona was the most townie out of the pool of 4 I had before Fox died. And he was only in the pool because of the other players being even more townie.

[sweetandcool]

I know people aren't used to performative sweetandcool, and I tend to play in a very guileless way.

However, I was being very performative N2. No, I don't think I'm locktown by any means, but I was relying on the fact that Bunny claimed I townslipped. I thought that was enough to secure me.

But now I've been betrayed by Bunny, and people hate performative sweetandcool, so I'm a bit worried. Actually, I think that's besides the point, because even if town doesn't fall into the trap of voting me, I don't think it's likely we'll even come to a consensus in order to survive today anyways.

I am disturbed at the mudslinging going on between Bunny and Vecna, who I'm pretty sure are both town. Now Bona is chiming in against Bunny too apparently.

I definitely need to take another gander, but Vecna, Bunny, Kak, and I are town (I know I'm town because I know my alignment).

If I'm wrong anywhere, I guess it must be one of Vecna and Bunny. For various reasons Kak was already a town read, and on top of that the whole GM thing strongly indicated Town for Kak (I think Town was done dirty by that whole situation, so I don't think it's wrong to use that information [and yes I could be wrong about GM motivation, but I find it hard to believe Kak wouldn't be modkilled if they were Mafia]).

I’m not slinging mud at Vecna. I’m slinging mud at you. You deserve it. Stop harassing the GM. That was really uncool.

Vecna, we cool? Did I miss something?

I went on that rant earlier, I haven't since. I would hardly consider it harassing

More like worrying at a bone, perhaps.

[sweetandcool]

I know people aren't used to performative sweetandcool, and I tend to play in a very guileless way.

However, I was being very performative N2. No, I don't think I'm locktown by any means, but I was relying on the fact that Bunny claimed I townslipped. I thought that was enough to secure me.

But now I've been betrayed by Bunny, and people hate performative sweetandcool, so I'm a bit worried. Actually, I think that's besides the point, because even if town doesn't fall into the trap of voting me, I don't think it's likely we'll even come to a consensus in order to survive today anyways.

I am disturbed at the mudslinging going on between Bunny and Vecna, who I'm pretty sure are both town. Now Bona is chiming in against Bunny too apparently.

I definitely need to take another gander, but Vecna, Bunny, Kak, and I are town (I know I'm town because I know my alignment).

If I'm wrong anywhere, I guess it must be one of Vecna and Bunny. For various reasons Kak was already a town read, and on top of that the whole GM thing strongly indicated Town for Kak (I think Town was done dirty by that whole situation, so I don't think it's wrong to use that information [and yes I could be wrong about GM motivation, but I find it hard to believe Kak wouldn't be modkilled if they were Mafia]).

I’m not slinging mud at Vecna. I’m slinging mud at you. You deserve it. Stop harassing the GM. That was really uncool.

Vecna, we cool? Did I miss something?

Yeah okay, I misread and confused you and Kak. Vecna was floating you as a scumcandidate, but yeah you're right not mudslinging.

[sweetandcool]

I'll try to make this the last time I mention it, but maybe I should say it now rather than waiting until after the game.

I know I haven't been nice about the whole D2 debacle, in fact I've been a bit mean.

I am upset about the mistake(s), rather than the perpetrator of the mistake(s).

Because I cannot have the satisfaction of hearing from all parties involved in the debacle, I have no outlet really to get over it. Consequently, I have been harping on it a bit in the game thread, which is in poor taste.

All of that being said, I can sincerely and genuinely apologize for my behavior. Brainbomb is a swell dude and my opinion of them has not changed.

But I'm still upset nonetheless.

I will try not to mention this again, and if I do feel free to roll your eyes and ignore me for being a butt.

[BunnyGo]

I'll try to make this the last time I mention it, but maybe I should say it now rather than waiting until after the game.

I know I haven't been nice about the whole D2 debacle, in fact I've been a bit mean.

I am upset about the mistake(s), rather than the perpetrator of the mistake(s).

Because I cannot have the satisfaction of hearing from all parties involved in the debacle, I have no outlet really to get over it. Consequently, I have been harping on it a bit in the game thread, which is in poor taste.

All of that being said, I can sincerely and genuinely apologize for my behavior. Brainbomb is a swell dude and my opinion of them has not changed.

But I'm still upset nonetheless.

I will try not to mention this again, and if I do feel free to roll your eyes and ignore me for being a butt.

That's fine...in the future this is what PMing the GM is for. I do it ALL the time.

Thanks GMs! Love youse!

[BunnyGo]

We now return to our regularly scheduled game, already in progress...

[sweetandcool]

I'll try to make this the last time I mention it, but maybe I should say it now rather than waiting until after the game.

I know I haven't been nice about the whole D2 debacle, in fact I've been a bit mean.

I am upset about the mistake(s), rather than the perpetrator of the mistake(s).

Because I cannot have the satisfaction of hearing from all parties involved in the debacle, I have no outlet really to get over it. Consequently, I have been harping on it a bit in the game thread, which is in poor taste.

All of that being said, I can sincerely and genuinely apologize for my behavior. Brainbomb is a swell dude and my opinion of them has not changed.

But I'm still upset nonetheless.

I will try not to mention this again, and if I do feel free to roll your eyes and ignore me for being a butt.

That's fine...in the future this is what PMing the GM is for. I do it ALL the time.

Thanks GMs! Love youse!

For some reason I never think to do that, I suppose because I'd be potentially a lot less civil.

But yeah, GM appreciation is the correct message to convey.

[rdrivera2005]

Rivera are you suggesting out the information now and possibly hammer?

No, never said nothing about hammer. Probably better to let the day go as usual and drop any info with time for people to react.

[sweetandcool]

Rivera are you suggesting out the information now and possibly hammer?

No, never said nothing about hammer. Probably better to let the day go as usual and drop any info with time for people to react.

Yeah no hammers.

But if rdr, Ham, or Bona is our last PR then I would love to find out ASAP because that will again shake me up quite a bit and require an even more thoughtful analysis.

[BunnyGo]

Rivera are you suggesting out the information now and possibly hammer?

No, never said nothing about hammer. Probably better to let the day go as usual and drop any info with time for people to react.

This is the way...we're still in a marathon. If someone has intel, wait at least 24 hours before dropping it. Give us time to get some VCA/debate and extra intel. Give the wolf rope and lead to others.

[BunnyGo]

Rivera are you suggesting out the information now and possibly hammer?

No, never said nothing about hammer. Probably better to let the day go as usual and drop any info with time for people to react.

Yeah no hammers.

But if rdr, Ham, or Bona is our last PR then I would love to find out ASAP because that will again shake me up quite a bit and require an even more thoughtful analysis.

This is not the way.