M82: Magic the Gathering Mafia [Game Thread]

[sweetandcool]

Was writing more than you

makes sense

i have less brain activity than you

I just started drinking coffee again after a 5 week hiatus...

Also about to go do shabbat with the fam, so will be out for a bit.

Missed this, also makes Bunny look suspicious under the coasting excuse lense.

[sweetandcool]

But then Bunny REACTED by getting more active rather than less as their excuse would indicate.

[sweetandcool]

As a rule I'm going to essentially believe any IRL claims, so I refuse to pass judgement on rdr and I assume they were traveling. NAI

[sweetandcool]

I feel like my starting point for analysis would be in the movers of votes over the last 10 minutes of Day 1. Obviously ghug is out but that leaves rivera, sweet, kak, Fox, bona.

Then there's the others. With the chatter that this game has enabled mafia to sit back, coast and/or lurk...that looks bad on that group of me, bunny, worcej, and vecna.

Why did Ham list players in this order?

[sweetandcool]

I dont have any complete lock-towns yet from the catchup, but im pretty sure my readslist right now looks something like;

Rdrivera
HB
Kakkarotto

Sweet
Fox

Bunny
Bona
Worcej

Man, Vecna fires off some brilliant analysis and then drops this dookie of a reads list. Could he be Mafia?

[Bonatogether]

catching up

[Bonatogether]

I think I want damo, worcej, Rd, or Kak today. Sweet is the closest thing I have to a townread but it's not an especially compelling one.

This post has enough cross-over feels that would warrant a kill on Ghug.

Worcej so far not leaving any impressions whatsoever.

Kak on the far scummy side.

I think he's potentially 2/3 in this post. excellent reason for a NK.

you just had a post before this townleaning rd, so 2/3 would be 2/3 from damo (dead town), worcej (town but not dead at this time), and kak. interested what happened vis a vis kak later

[rdrivera2005]

I dont have any complete lock-towns yet from the catchup, but im pretty sure my readslist right now looks something like;

Rdrivera
HB
Kakkarotto

Sweet
Fox

Bunny
Bona
Worcej

Man, Vecna fires off some brilliant analysis and then drops this dookie of a reads list. Could he be Mafia?

Why this read list is so bad? You voted Worcej and Bunny was on your suspect list as far as I remember.

[Bonatogether]

ok sequence of 3 cited posts wrt kak

ummm

i see what you think and why but thinking about it

[sweetandcool]

Alright, pretty sure I've nailed at least two scum. Scumpool is out of 4 so there is a small chance I messed one up. I will post the juicy stuff near EoN, as is tradition. I assume I will die but it will be worth nailing them.

And in the event I don't die I fully expect scum to come guns blazing pointing out I didn't die, but jokes on them because I'm obvious locktown and only a fool couldn't see that.

[Bonatogether]

GughDamnit!

You guys are soooo so wrong about sweet. And Fox's logic is bad.

Yes, he is correct that by not getting direct wagons on potential deep threats, we leave them until later.

But killing a scum player now gives us information on their interactions, confirmation on their votes, and ability to read their posts and posts about them (or actively ignoring them) with an idea.

##vote sweet

Would not consider:

rdr
Vecna
Fox
Bona

Would consider:

Hamilton
kak
worcej

would ##end sweet. I think this one's easy.

how on earth would you not consider me at this point?

That is some grade a+ bullshit.

Every town should be highly highly suspicious of me just after N1.

I hadnt done shit. Bunny especially should know that fits my disinterested scumplay to a T.

This just smells like the fear of knowing an impending town Vecna will do some catchup of the gods.

torn between wanting to say real and being wary of self-awareness

[sweetandcool]

I dont have any complete lock-towns yet from the catchup, but im pretty sure my readslist right now looks something like;

Rdrivera
HB
Kakkarotto

Sweet
Fox

Bunny
Bona
Worcej

Man, Vecna fires off some brilliant analysis and then drops this dookie of a reads list. Could he be Mafia?

Why this read list is so bad? You voted Worcej and Bunny was on your suspect list as far as I remember.

Well, to be fair to Vecna this is in hindsight. Worcej was town so that's one problem with the list. I'm not willing to explain the rest of it until my final post.

[Bonatogether]

Has Vecna come out from under his Terraforming Mars odyssey?

I played all throughout friday as well

Epic session from 1400-03:30.

13h straight with a short dinner break.

rest in peace i hope you recover soon

[Bonatogether]

Man, Vecna fires off some brilliant analysis and then drops this dookie of a reads list. Could he be Mafia?

Why this read list is so bad? You voted Worcej and Bunny was on your suspect list as far as I remember.

Well, to be fair to Vecna this is in hindsight. Worcej was town so that's one problem with the list. I'm not willing to explain the rest of it until my final post.

town should always be willing to explain everything they say even if it is just 'idk man i feel it'

[Bonatogether]

Mark was doing great in round 2. Sipping his mountain dew and everything was going great until those damn orcish lumberjacks came into play.

The day has been shortened

Day 2 Deadline moved to 24 hours earlier

Guess scum were scared of my catchup and didnt wanna give me the time

Explain?

unnecessary question on a self explanatory post

[Bonatogether]

I dont have any complete lock-towns yet from the catchup, but im pretty sure my readslist right now looks something like;

Rdrivera
HB
Kakkarotto

Sweet
Fox

Bunny
Bona
Worcej

How did kaka get all greeny in your readthrough and why bona so red?

Because always when he's scum all he does is just pretend to be silly and reckless.

Even more so than as town. He becomes a caricature of himself because he knows people interpret it as his real self.

if this is about me, i don't feel that i've been reckless in any decision this game that's actually important so i'm unsure how this actually tracks with what i've been doing

[sweetandcool]

How did kaka get all greeny in your readthrough and why bona so red?

Because always when he's scum all he does is just pretend to be silly and reckless.

Even more so than as town. He becomes a caricature of himself because he knows people interpret it as his real self.

if this is about me, i don't feel that i've been reckless in any decision this game that's actually important so i'm unsure how this actually tracks with what i've been doing

I thought it was about Kak.

[Bonatogether]

Not wholly comfortable with sweet and I lining up on the same player right now.

Bunny with this End voting. That’s pinging me wrong.

Then there’s Bona with the one word responses; just doesn’t offer anything.

But there’s the low key Rivera factor and that’s jammed town time and time again. Totally rethinking my Vecna vote.

And if I seem staccato I’m in the car traveling.

you can't misrepresent me too - i've not had any more than a few one word posts in this whole game.

nobody actually reads what i post and people will just believe whatever people post about me but genuinely i have not been purely reactive in this game, despite not having put a huge amount of time in

[Bonatogether]

Because always when he's scum all he does is just pretend to be silly and reckless.

Even more so than as town. He becomes a caricature of himself because he knows people interpret it as his real self.

if this is about me, i don't feel that i've been reckless in any decision this game that's actually important so i'm unsure how this actually tracks with what i've been doing

I thought it was about Kak.

he addresses kak by name in a post after so i thought it was about me

not 100% but

[sweetandcool]

Not wholly comfortable with sweet and I lining up on the same player right now.

Bunny with this End voting. That’s pinging me wrong.

Then there’s Bona with the one word responses; just doesn’t offer anything.

But there’s the low key Rivera factor and that’s jammed town time and time again. Totally rethinking my Vecna vote.

And if I seem staccato I’m in the car traveling.

you can't misrepresent me too - i've not had any more than a few one word posts in this whole game.

nobody actually reads what i post and people will just believe whatever people post about me but genuinely i have not been purely reactive in this game, despite not having put a huge amount of time in

I've thought you've played a great game so far, not sure about your alignment though.