M82: Magic the Gathering Mafia [Game Thread]

[Kakarroto]

Why do you think so? (I know why you think you're town...but sweet?)

his posts don't have a maliciousness to them as far as i see. I mean sure I could be wrong, but even with some mistakes I see (like voting me for a long time) I think he is much more likely town, especially after this EoD

If you can't tell...I haven't caught up. Tell me what about his EoD speaks to you as towny?

well he was a staunch me-voter, but he was open to change his mind. He didn't do it on a whim too, as far as I can see. I mean, maybe he does that as mafia but it looks more like town behaviour to me. Also, his maf-read of fox aligned with mine, that's also a good sign to me. Without sweet I'd be in damo's place right now.

[BunnyGo]

@ghug: why did you vote sweet? Were you trying to rush him in the last minute?

[Vecna]

oh, EoD was 2 hours ago

Well, thats a thing. Was sorta expecting it to happen in 30 or 1,5h.

[rdrivera2005]

Bleh, not sure what we got from this D1. Ghug moving off Damo is weird, if you don't want to tie you change your vote like Bona did.

[Hamilton Brian]

Apologies to Bona for my previous post. I feel like it may have violated some of our code of ethics. We have been antagonistic in the past and that came out. I'll mind my manners.

[Kakarroto]

Kakarroto (3) sweetandcool Vecna damo666
sweetandcool (3) BunnyGo* rdrivera2005* Foxcastle
damo666 (2) Hamilton Brian ghug
ghug (2) Bonatogether worcej
Foxcastle (1) Kakarroto

End-votes (2/11):
BunnyGo rdrivera2005


No one is scheduled to die
34 minutes remain

so with me voting damo on the next post, it looks to me like the day was pretty much tvtvt and mafia just laid back.

explain

well, damo we know was town.

I'm pretty sure about sweet and ghug, with their EoD behaviour, that those two are likely town. I wouldn't locktown them like rd, but still very high. I mean, maybe be a bit cautious to over-town read ghug, he always can pull plays of as mafia, but I don't see too much of ghug's maf-game here.

and yeah, I don't think I have to explain my read of myself.

So therefore, I think, mafia had a pretty laid back day, well if we don't forget fox. But it never really looked enough for fox to come back into the top ratings, as far as i remember.

[Kakarroto]

Bleh, not sure what we got from this D1. Ghug moving off Damo is weird, if you don't want to tie you change your vote like Bona did.

nah, I totally understand ghug's vote here, i did the same some time ago to not tie. Like if ghug went on me and bona went on damo, it would've been tied again. So ghug did totally the right thing here

[Bonatogether]

Apologies to Bona for my previous post. I feel like it may have violated some of our code of ethics. We have been antagonistic in the past and that came out. I'll mind my manners.

i didn't find it antagonistic but i appreciate the thought

[Bonatogether]

so with me voting damo on the next post, it looks to me like the day was pretty much tvtvt and mafia just laid back.

explain

well, damo we know was town.

I'm pretty sure about sweet and ghug, with their EoD behaviour, that those two are likely town. I wouldn't locktown them like rd, but still very high. I mean, maybe be a bit cautious to over-town read ghug, he always can pull plays of as mafia, but I don't see too much of ghug's maf-game here.

and yeah, I don't think I have to explain my read of myself.

So therefore, I think, mafia had a pretty laid back day, well if we don't forget fox. But it never really looked enough for fox to come back into the top ratings, as far as i remember.

damo666 (5) Hamilton Brian rdrivera2005 Kakarroto sweetandcool Bonatogether
Kakarroto (4) Vecna damo666 worcej Foxcastle
sweetandcool (2) BunnyGo* ghug

so this is your worldview? poe of 5?

[ghug]

@ghug: why did you vote sweet? Were you trying to rush him in the last minute?

My reception was spotty enough that I couldn't tell what was happening beyond an apparent tie, so I thought it was better to leave an odd number of votes on the wagons than switch and end up undoing someone else's switch.

[Bonatogether]

Bleh, not sure what we got from this D1. Ghug moving off Damo is weird, if you don't want to tie you change your vote like Bona did.

nah, I totally understand ghug's vote here, i did the same some time ago to not tie. Like if ghug went on me and bona went on damo, it would've been tied again. So ghug did totally the right thing here

maybe ghug just has ligma

[ghug]

Bleh, not sure what we got from this D1. Ghug moving off Damo is weird, if you don't want to tie you change your vote like Bona did.

Does my D1 voting ever not strike people as weird?

[Kakarroto]

explain

well, damo we know was town.

I'm pretty sure about sweet and ghug, with their EoD behaviour, that those two are likely town. I wouldn't locktown them like rd, but still very high. I mean, maybe be a bit cautious to over-town read ghug, he always can pull plays of as mafia, but I don't see too much of ghug's maf-game here.

and yeah, I don't think I have to explain my read of myself.

So therefore, I think, mafia had a pretty laid back day, well if we don't forget fox. But it never really looked enough for fox to come back into the top ratings, as far as i remember.

damo666 (5) Hamilton Brian rdrivera2005 Kakarroto sweetandcool Bonatogether
Kakarroto (4) Vecna damo666 worcej Foxcastle
sweetandcool (2) BunnyGo* ghug

so this is your worldview? poe of 5?

that looks ... pretty good, yes. Most likely not a Vecna-worcej-fox team. Mafia probably was on different targets. But yeah, thanks for pointing that out exactly.

[Foxcastle]

If Kak is scum and was saved, then his teammates look like two of Rdr, ghug, and bunny.

If it was TvT, then I need to think about that.

[sweetandcool]

If Kak is scum and was saved, then his teammates look like two of Rdr, ghug, and bunny.

If it was TvT, then I need to think about that.

Hmmm, why not me as a Kak saviour?

[Hamilton Brian]

Alright; checking out to make supper and get ready for gaming. See yall in hours.

[Foxcastle]

If Kak is scum and was saved, then his teammates look like two of Rdr, ghug, and bunny.

If it was TvT, then I need to think about that.

Hmmm, why not me as a Kak saviour?

I'm skeptical that as scum you'd be that blatant about it. It's possible, I suppose, but I find it unlikely.

[BunnyGo]

If Kak is scum and was saved, then his teammates look like two of Rdr, ghug, and bunny.

If it was TvT, then I need to think about that.

All four of the people you mentioned are out of my current PoE. What do you conclude if kak is town and it was a TvT finish?

[rdrivera2005]

Bleh, not sure what we got from this D1. Ghug moving off Damo is weird, if you don't want to tie you change your vote like Bona did.

Does my D1 voting ever not strike people as weird?

Leaving an odd number is a good explanation, so it wasn't that weird after all.

Do you understand what Vecna is doing?

[Foxcastle]

If Kak is scum and was saved, then his teammates look like two of Rdr, ghug, and bunny.

If it was TvT, then I need to think about that.

All four of the people you mentioned are out of my current PoE. What do you conclude if kak is town and it was a TvT finish?

I don't know yet, but will have more thoughts tomorrow probably.