M82: Magic the Gathering Mafia [Game Thread]

[Bonatogether]

##vote ghug

[brainbomb]

With 2 life left, and only a few lands out, Gary was in trouble. Mark had tons of creatures, a full hand of tricks up his sleeve.

Sensing the tension in the room gary tapped one Island and played his best card he had left.



Kakarroto (2) sweetandcool Vecna
damo666 (2) Hamilton Brian Foxcastle
ghug (2) damo666 Bonatogether
sweetandcool (2) BunnyGo* rdrivera2005*
worcej (1) ghug

End-votes (2/11): BunnyGo rdrivera2005


Non-votes
Kakarroto, worcej

Currently no one is scheduled to die
4 hours and ten minutes remain in day 1

[worcej]

##vote ghug

I like this.

##vote ghug

[worcej]

I feel like the people complaining that the game is boring barely 24 hours into it need to reset their expectations of mafia games…

No

[ghug]

##vote ghug

I like this.

##vote ghug

Say more

[ghug]

I think I want damo, worcej, Rd, or Kak today. Sweet is the closest thing I have to a townread but it's not an especially compelling one.

[ghug]

Also I was hoping to not have to insult anyone's intelligence by making this explicit because I've played a hundred games with your people but my activity level is low because I'm traveling and wasn't expecting the game to start when it did, not because I rolled scum and am too scared to talk.

[rdrivera2005]

Uh oh, that's often a prelude to "feels off"!

Ghug feels off this game.

im hardly a good judge on all things ghug, clearly, but I also felt it

Why Vecna is playing scummy like this on purpose? It's weird and not helpful.

[BunnyGo]

EXACTLY! It looks crafted in a way that suggests he's trying to appear like sweet while also not screwing up again like he did with his statement about kak in the opening.

Do you have anything to imply about the post, or maybe more clearly...what seems crafted? How would you have expected sweet to compose a post if they WEREN'T trying to "appear?"

The strange pauses in the post where Sweet clearly said an opinion, then went back and checked that the opinion was false, but left it in the post so we could see him checking.

[rdrivera2005]

Also I was hoping to not have to insult anyone's intelligence by making this explicit because I've played a hundred games with your people but my activity level is low because I'm traveling and wasn't expecting the game to start when it did, not because I rolled scum and am too scared to talk.

As people seems to be having problem with basic irony, my post about Ghug being off was a joke.

[BunnyGo]

Did you pause in writing that post to go look up who had been posting what, and then go back and edit the post?

Yes. I wanted to look up precisely what worcej said and then found he wasn't the person saying the game was dead, rather he was saying the opposite.

Actually, I don't like your wording. I only continued my post, while adding the strikethrough command that didn't work.

In one post you went from "Bunny scum" to "Actually, Bunny doing town work" to "Actually BUNNY posting this stuff"

Why leave all that in? It seemed like you were crafting an appearance of thinking. Usually your posts are more consistent.

[BunnyGo]

I've been reading every post, but keep having the peculiar experience of seeing someone quote a post I absolutely have no recollection of reading. So yes, I would say I'm very off this game.

scumclaim

Meh.

facts

[BunnyGo]

I think I want damo, worcej, Rd, or Kak today. Sweet is the closest thing I have to a townread but it's not an especially compelling one.

Anything you can say to convince me? I was thinking not Rd or Kak today. Probably not damo either.

[ghug]

I think I want damo, worcej, Rd, or Kak today. Sweet is the closest thing I have to a townread but it's not an especially compelling one.

Anything you can say to convince me? I was thinking not Rd or Kak today. Probably not damo either.

Kak is immemorable for a leading poster. Damo is wrong about me, which is scum indicative for him, and isn't displaying anything anything in the way of thought process getting him to his assertions. rd's just rd.

[sweetandcool]

EXACTLY! It looks crafted in a way that suggests he's trying to appear like sweet while also not screwing up again like he did with his statement about kak in the opening.

Do you have anything to imply about the post, or maybe more clearly...what seems crafted? How would you have expected sweet to compose a post if they WEREN'T trying to "appear?"

The strange pauses in the post where Sweet clearly said an opinion, then went back and checked that the opinion was false, but left it in the post so we could see him checking.

It aligns with how I normally write posts. In previous games you will see me make an argument, then change my mind mid-post. Similar to when I concluded ghug was Town in M80. Only difference here is that I tried a strikeout, rather than completing the though and then turning about.

[sweetandcool]

I think I want damo, worcej, Rd, or Kak today. Sweet is the closest thing I have to a townread but it's not an especially compelling one.

I wish I understood your thought process that allows you to consider me more likely town.

I'm clearly down for Kak, and am okay with rdr. I like worcej's play so far.

[Hamilton Brian]

I'd go coin flips on damo, kak, or sweetandcool today. Or roll a 6-sided die. Easier.

[ghug]

I think I want damo, worcej, Rd, or Kak today. Sweet is the closest thing I have to a townread but it's not an especially compelling one.

I wish I understood your thought process that allows you to consider me more likely town.

I'm clearly down for Kak, and am okay with rdr. I like worcej's play so far.

What do you like about worcej's play?

You're just a tone/gut thing, though I also dislike your wagon.

[Kakarroto]

I am town. I am mafia. I am scum.
You are town. You are mafia. You are scum.

Brian is town. Brian is mafia. Brian is scum.
Hamilton is town. Hamilton is mafia. Hamilton is scum.
Bunny is town. Bunny is mafia. Bunny is scum.
BunnyGo is town. BunnyGo is mafia. BunnyGo is scum.
sweetandcool is town. sweetandcool is mafia. sweetandcool is scum.
sweet is town. sweet is mafia. sweet is scum.
bonatogether is town. bonatogether is mafia. bonatogether is scum.
bona is town. bona is mafia. bona is scum.
damo666 is town. damo666 is mafia. damo666 is scum.
damo is town. damo is mafia. damo is scum.
Vecna is town. Vecna is mafia. Vecna is scum.
Vekna is town. Vekna is mafia. Vecna is scum.
Foxcastle is town. Foxcastle is mafia. Foxcastle is scum.
fox is town. fox is mafia. fox is scum.
Rdrivera is town. Rdrivera is mafia. Rdrivera is scum.
rd is town. rd is mafia. rd is scum.
Worcej is town. Worcej is mafia. Worcej is scum.
worcej is town. worcej is mafia. worcej is scum.
ghug is town. ghug is mafia. ghug is scum.
ghuggles is town. ghuggles is mafia. ghuggles is scum.
Kakarroto is town. Kakarroto is mafia. Kakarroto is scum.
kak is town. kak is mafia. kak is scum.

Why are you mafia? Why are you scum?
I am PR. I am White Knight. I am The Virgin. I am Serra Angel. I am Angel.
I am Wandering Emperor. I am the Wandering Emperor. I am the 2 shot Day Exiler.
I am Squirrel Wrangler. I am the Squirrel Wrangler. I am the Hider.
I am Chatterfang Squirrel General. I am the Chatterfang Squirrel General. I am the Odd Night Watcher.
I am Prodigal Sorcerer. I am the Prodigal Sorcerer. I am the Even Night Watcher.
I am Aquameoba. I am the Aquameoba. I am the Vote Reversal.
Are you Shivan Dragon? Are you the Shivan Dragon? Are you the Arsonist?
Are you Kird Ape? Are you the Kird Ape? Are you a Goon? Are you the Goon?
Are you Orcish Lumberjack? Are you the Orcish Lumberjack? Are you the Day Shortener?
Are you Black Knight? Are you the Black Knight? Are you the Woebringer?
Are you Plague Rat? Are you the Plague Rat? Are you a goon? Are you the goon?
Are you Vindictive Lich? Are you the Vindictive Lich? Are you the Phrase Vanillizer?

Oh boy, that's the most I've ever used 'scum' in a mafia game, I believe. I feel dirty now.

im going to cc unless you retract

hold up, I never claimed anything here. I just wrote that all out to create save phrases. Don't waste any cc's against me.

[Kakarroto]

Kak. Did you try

I’m a PR! Get off me!

no, but good thinking, that's also kinda commonly used