M81: A Night To Remember [GAME THREAD]

[Jamiet99uk]

My dance partner and I declared a toast to the king.

He calculated the odds of having a scum dance partner as 23.1%.

He felt if two dance partners trusted each other they could scumhunt as a pair.

We discussed whether a mass claim was a good idea. He felt that on balance it was bad for town.

I used a German word and he asked me about it.

He suggested a potential town benefit to fake claiming partners.

Gesundheit

Verboten

[ghug]

Chaqa, if you're town and wrong about me here, will you stop trying to claim you're good at reading me?

Oh yeah I forgot I was voting you lol

Begrudgingly, based

[Kakarroto]

Ah I see the massclaim has begun.

well it should be relatively if not totally obvious who my partner is by deduction. so ill not blurt it out just yet

my dance partner is Sissi

a very lovely person ♥

[ghug]

My dance partner and I declared a toast to the king.

He calculated the odds of having a scum dance partner as 23.1%.

He felt if two dance partners trusted each other they could scumhunt as a pair.

We discussed whether a mass claim was a good idea. He felt that on balance it was bad for town.

I used a German word and he asked me about it.

He suggested a potential town benefit to fake claiming partners.

Gesundheit

Verboten

Ausgezeichnet

[brainbomb]

Im back

[Kakarroto]

Still reading quickly but wanted to get my feelings known. My partner and I were pretty confident that claiming dance partners was more in town’s favour than not. I am not sure I am convinced that NOT claiming is more town than anti-mafia. However we both decided that we’d go with the consensus of the group. I think we need a simple 50%+1 to come to the decision.

Don’t make a claim until we’ve decided though.

I’m favour of claiming:
1. Brian

Clearly I am in favor as I already claimed.

sweet against
aaro against (at least in the beginning)

brain not pro, not con

demonRHK sees no advantage nor disadvantage, claims to have played out the scenarios; is NOT supporting it, but doesn't see any anti-town

jamies partner (whoever that is) says it's on balance, bad for town

Also, I guess this is now outdated and not needed anymore. For what's worth, my stance has been cautiously pro claim, since I didn't see a major flaw and no one who saw wanted to explain it to me.

[Kakarroto]

My night chat was laid back. There was only a little game talk, most of that sprinkled with mechanics and numbers. They were not very defensive, more natural. I am wary of them, but not enough to ddeclare a sumread or a claim.

So thats gotta be Kakarrotto

[Jamiet99uk]

Still reading quickly but wanted to get my feelings known. My partner and I were pretty confident that claiming dance partners was more in town’s favour than not. I am not sure I am convinced that NOT claiming is more town than anti-mafia. However we both decided that we’d go with the consensus of the group. I think we need a simple 50%+1 to come to the decision.

Don’t make a claim until we’ve decided though.

I’m favour of claiming:
1. Brian

Clearly I am in favor as I already claimed.

sweet against
aaro against (at least in the beginning)

brain not pro, not con

demonRHK sees no advantage nor disadvantage, claims to have played out the scenarios; is NOT supporting it, but doesn't see any anti-town

jamies partner (whoever that is) says it's on balance, bad for town

Also, I guess this is now outdated and not needed anymore. For what's worth, my stance has been cautiously pro claim, since I didn't see a major flaw and no one who saw wanted to explain it to me.

Why are you reacting to something you know is out of date?

[damo666]

sorry but how am I pair hunting my own fucking partner dude. please read the game and practice a bare minimum level of intellect

People guessing an answer to your question will help scum narrow down the pairings.

It was really explicitly obvious that you were his partner, Damo.

How did you guess?

[worcej]

oh god are we gonna now spend 6 hours talking about how we shouldnt have claimed?

Yeah probably

[Kakarroto]

I should get an award for not having claimed yet.

[Jamiet99uk]

People guessing an answer to your question will help scum narrow down the pairings.

It was really explicitly obvious that you were his partner, Damo.

How did you guess?

For me, it was this post:

I should get an award for not having claimed yet.

Send me your fax number and I'll send you a fax of a piece of paper on which I have written "Well Done" with a black marker.

if your partner is S&C, why then do you assume damo is not partnered with mafia?

[worcej]

ghug I would appreciate any feedback you have on HamiltonBrians "race to the cure" readslists which seem to progress the game for him in very scummy ways. Any thoughts on even a single one of those read progressions.

like for example going from saying vecna is doing a great job catching up when vecna is townreading RHK

to then saying Vecna is a null-scumlean who is shading bb and jamie?

and reading vecnas posts do you think he is "shading" me and Jamie?

HB's bad read lists have caught him as scum before and he's sneakily my #4 on my scum list because of the reasoning he used in said list

[worcej]

@worc I think I figured out the answer to the question we had in pre-game.

Which one lol?

[ghug]

Worcej, have you ever felt this confident on D1 before?

[brainbomb]

##Vote Chaqa

[worcej]

ghug I would appreciate any feedback you have on HamiltonBrians "race to the cure" readslists which seem to progress the game for him in very scummy ways. Any thoughts on even a single one of those read progressions.

like for example going from saying vecna is doing a great job catching up when vecna is townreading RHK

to then saying Vecna is a null-scumlean who is shading bb and jamie?

and reading vecnas posts do you think he is "shading" me and Jamie?

That's a little too much conditional relationship for me to have internalized a lot of it on first read, but in general I think Brian is unlikely to subtly push an agenda and plenty likely to read posts in a way that others aren't, so neither of the things you're accusing him of worry me that much.

I can second your verification

what if I had verification that he does reads lists like this as mafia, and has done it before, and has pushed agendas in this way before based on what townies are doing and then forming his reads this way to look engaged

[aarodactyl]

Im back

By contradiction theory, brain isn’t scum.

[worcej]

Worcej, have you ever felt this confident on D1 before?

Frankly speaking, no. But I am also not on the defense for stupid reasons and have been able to focus on reading players more than just OMGUS'ing.

I could of course be wrong on you, but I don't think I am and that's a better reason to vote than just hip firing someone randomly.

[worcej]

does chaqa get mad when he gets sussed as scum. or does he just retreat

He gets mad when people like say shitty thing just to show how shitty they can be.