M81: A Night To Remember [GAME THREAD]

[Chaqa]

##VOTE Vecna

[aarodactyl]

The person I am in a chat with openly admitted to being mafia and claimed that no one would ever believe me even if I announced it. I asked them who they were mafia with and they said ezio, Jamie, and sweetandcool.

I asked how that was possible and they said they were only lying about one of the three.

Wtf. We can do image posts now? Can someone go find emc and have them sub in?

[Chaqa]

Also I don’t hold anything against those of you that are saying 3/7 but bayes is rolling in his grave. Maybe don’t do that to him.

[worcej]

I think explaining why something is anti town just guarantees that mafia will get information from it

I think scum are more incentivized to keep pairs hidden than town are.

And you’re pushing that now without a good explanation as to why.

I'm afraid you are wrong. Please privately consider what the endgame will look like.

Fuck privately

If the game just falls into scum killing off pairs over time, we continue to kill day kills that make sense based off scummy behavior and opinions (such as the one’s currently present) and the pairs become irrelevant.

Protecting the hidden information until end game creates more opportunity for fake claims at KiLo that still need to be sorted out and not confirmable live.

Plus scum can easily just NK one of their partners to get access to the information in the chat.

[brainbomb]

##Call GM
are you aware that chaqa is listed as dead in the bot?

[Chaqa]

Reminder that all chats involving living players are closed until nighttime.

[aarodactyl]

I think scum are more incentivized to keep pairs hidden than town are.

And you’re pushing that now without a good explanation as to why.

I'm afraid you are wrong. Please privately consider what the endgame will look like.

Fuck privately

If the game just falls into scum killing off pairs over time, we continue to kill day kills that make sense based off scummy behavior and opinions (such as the one’s currently present) and the pairs become irrelevant.

Protecting the hidden information until end game creates more opportunity for fake claims at KiLo that still need to be sorted out and not confirmable live.

Plus scum can easily just NK one of their partners to get access to the information in the chat.

No one said to keep things private until the endgame lol.

[worcej]

Ugh, fuck it - my vote isn’t moving this phase.

##end

D1 me again if you want - but ghug’s opinion so far is polar opposite of his normal stance on dead player information.

[worcej]

I'm afraid you are wrong. Please privately consider what the endgame will look like.

Fuck privately

If the game just falls into scum killing off pairs over time, we continue to kill day kills that make sense based off scummy behavior and opinions (such as the one’s currently present) and the pairs become irrelevant.

Protecting the hidden information until end game creates more opportunity for fake claims at KiLo that still need to be sorted out and not confirmable live.

Plus scum can easily just NK one of their partners to get access to the information in the chat.

No one said to keep things private until the endgame lol.

It makes NO SENSE to keep your pair hidden until endgame.

[aarodactyl]

Fuck privately

If the game just falls into scum killing off pairs over time, we continue to kill day kills that make sense based off scummy behavior and opinions (such as the one’s currently present) and the pairs become irrelevant.

Protecting the hidden information until end game creates more opportunity for fake claims at KiLo that still need to be sorted out and not confirmable live.

Plus scum can easily just NK one of their partners to get access to the information in the chat.

No one said to keep things private until the endgame lol.

It makes NO SENSE to keep your pair hidden until endgame.

I agree. All I said was claiming early on is bad for town. It’s ultimately going to be a decision we make based on what information town thinks scum has access to.

[brainbomb]

this setup is not mechanical enough to warrant disbanding just playing a normal game. kill the scummy people.

[Chaqa]

Maybe we should just make all the pairs with scum in them claim, then.

that's a great idea!


how do we do that?

Well, we have two claims so far, so it follows that one of me and aaro and one of Chaqa and worcej each have to be scum.

[brainbomb]

so far im scumleaning RHK/aaro and s&c for not trying to gamesolve.

but theres alot of players who havent even posted.

jamie exists and is hiding

ect ect
lots of game to be played

[rdrivera2005]

Good night fellow townies and some evil rebels.

Why we are at 10 pages in 2 hours? I already told my chat partner that I will try to play interacting more and less catching up so I might skip some pages....

[worcej]

No one said to keep things private until the endgame lol.

It makes NO SENSE to keep your pair hidden until endgame.

I agree. All I said was claiming early on is bad for town. It’s ultimately going to be a decision we make based on what information town thinks scum has access to.

Let’s think about it objectively.

An unpaired dance partner will only have access to the opinions of dead players still watching the game, assuming they stay in purgatory. That’s it.

If we all know the partners, it allows for POE to be simplified and pairs to be eliminated from potential contention.

It also allows for a town clear to be established immediately on a scum flip and then a forced kill by scum on someone who may or may not be an ideal kill over another player.

It also ensures all information is accurate now and not potentially tampered with via lies in later phases when miskills are not an option anymore.

[Chaqa]

the old adage goes if you hate a brainbomb read wait five minutes.

[President Eden]

##Call GM
are you aware that chaqa is listed as dead in the bot?

lmfao

[worcej]

this setup is not mechanical enough to warrant disbanding just playing a normal game. kill the scummy people.

I agree and cannot help but find it scummy to believe hiding the information is more valuable to town when it’s almost exclusively better for town to utilize it for POE elimination and take it away from scum as a potential bs claim later.

[President Eden]

##resurrect chaqa

[brainbomb]

if its scummy to out your chat partner

scumhunt instead

if its scummy to not mass claim

also just scumhunt

there.

thank you for listening