MAFIA 39 - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

at this point i bet i'm dead even if i'm wrong because if i'm wrong, the right scum would want to potentially set up the townie/s among worcej/xorxes i have pegged wrong for a lynching.

y2k, I wouldn't worry too much if I were you. You are the safest of all the clears.

what does that mean?

Means no one is killing you because you derail us so much

[Durga]

Yavu shush, he's not scum. Can we stop pointing fingers at obv townies and focus on scum like worcjejejx thanks

[y2kjbk]

yavuz we get it, you read one post and make accusations

[ghug]

Yavuz is def town for this shit.

[y2kjbk]

y2k, I wouldn't worry too much if I were you. You are the safest of all the clears.

what does that mean?

Means no one is killing you because you derail us so much

my derailing was fairly ineffectual against the Squigs lynch

[worcej]

why not? were his two buddies trying to save him?

The vote count ended like this:

Squigs44 (6) - worcej, xorxes, rdrivera2005, flash2015, Tom Bombadil, damo666
Tom Bombadil (3) - ND, y2kjbk, DemonRHK
ghug (1) - Vecna
ND (2) - ghug, Durga
Durga (2) - brainbomb, Squigs44

This was far from a super-majority. I would imagine that the scum, based off choosing BB as a kill apparently on N1 and failing, are smart and at least one is not a noob. Because of this, that eliminates damo666, Demon, and flash2015 right from my list (sorry guys) as being scum. We know Tom wasn't scum now too, which leaves rdrivera - who isn't playing like I've seen, so either he's adapted his gameplay significantly in a short timeframe, but I also think he is town so far this game.

That left me with the following: ND, y2k, xorxes, Vecna, ghug, and Durga. Now, I am taking you at your word (since BB confirmed the save) that you had a kit, so you're cleared. Only way you're not is BB is deep lying and pulled off the con of the century on webDip Mafia, which would leave you and him as scum. Even I am not willing to go down that rabbit hole, so you're cleared.

That leaves this: ND, xorxes, Vecna, ghug, and Durga.

Back on the BB target: BB was leading the town and people like me were following him, they wanted town to be disorganized and chaos because they are at a huge disadvantage right now. Armors are most likely in play, along with the shield, and maybe one more Nurse Kit - their power at night is weak right now and this needs to last several more nights. This type of thinking/move strikes me a Vecna or Xorxes kinda plan - it's thought out and strategic, something these both seem to do.

[ghug]

what does that mean?

Means no one is killing you because you derail us so much

my derailing was fairly ineffectual against the Squigs lynch

You told me yesterday that you'd stop talking to that I could solve the game. You haven't, and that makes me sad.

[damo666]

a scum can only have a nurse kit if they stole it, they could not have started with it based on the rules.

If ghug is to be believed they can't have stolen it.

They could have repaired it though.

[y2kjbk]

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm

[xorxes]

y2k really stands out here. I will reread him. I mean, he beats BB at spamming. It's also interesting this happened after BB accused him for using bb as a weapon against us.

yavu, are you a masochist by any chance? Don't waste time rereading y2k, he is clear.

For him not to be clear some very weird stuff should happen:

(1) bb lied about being saved and Mafia withheld their kill

or

(2) someone other than y2k saved bb but didn't claim it

or

(3) y2k was sticky and got the nurse kit from bozo, who from some weird reason decided to save y2k N0

or

(4) y2k is the thief who stole the nurse kit from bozo, and then ghug is lying so he must be scum too.

Of those, the last one is the least unlikely (though still very unlikely), so if you want to reread someone, better reread ghug. It will be shorter and you will learn more.

[y2kjbk]

sorry ghug, i jumped on it. let me know if you disagree about xorxes or worcej bussing squigs.

[y2kjbk]

xorxes, as insightful as ever about our item mechanics

[worcej]

Yavu shush, he's not scum. Can we stop pointing fingers at obv townies and focus on scum like worcjejejx thanks

I like how I've been shit ever since I questioned your authenticity. It's cute.

[xorxes]

y2k, I wouldn't worry too much if I were you. You are the safest of all the clears.

what does that mean?

That Mafia is very happy to keep you around as long as possible.

[y2kjbk]

worcej would have given up defending himself from me if he was town

[y2kjbk]

flash got defensive a bit and then eventually was like w/e

[worcej]

worcej would have given up defending himself from me if he was town

You clearly haven't read my past games...

[y2kjbk]

your past games you were just adamant about not faking your claims

[damo666]

Yavuz is def town for this shit.

If you're right the scumpool is getting quite small now.

[xorxes]

a scum can only have a nurse kit if they stole it, they could not have started with it based on the rules.

If ghug is to be believed they can't have stolen it.

They could have repaired it though.

Not before it was used to save bb.