M1025 Game Thread

[Fluminator]

When I voted PE here, he was tied for top wagon approaching the eod 1. The annoyance feels real here.

Scum PE: Annoyed he might get day 1ed over a town lurker who by no rights should be survive over him
Town PE: Annoyed he might get day 1ed instead of a lurker who by no rights should survive over him

Both seem real lol

[Fluminator]

I'm starting to wonder if there's merit to bona's open tab theory.

what is that, I missed it

[Bonatogether]

its when i get an excuse to lurk despite being visible in the bottom of the screen

[President Eden]

flum, you've had successful scum games in the past right? like not just wins, but standout performances where you really shined

what was it like to play town afterward?

[ghug]

its when i get an excuse to lurk despite being visible in the bottom of the screen

You could just hide your online status and save me the headache...

[ghug]

flum, you've had successful scum games in the past right? like not just wins, but standout performances where you really shined

what was it like to play town afterward?

It blows.

-ghug, aka Flum

[Fluminator]

You could give us all the reasons you sent to the godthread for ghug being scum if you want this vote to have a chance at meaning anything.

Ghug opening feels scummy

Oh man…I’m voting Ghug so hard here. Would end

Gah! Gotta reset

But also…gotta get ghug

i hate that i believe this

I forgot about this lol. Bunny, was this actually your secret notes on ghug? What happened to your scumread on him anyway?

[ghug]

flum, you've had successful scum games in the past right? like not just wins, but standout performances where you really shined

what was it like to play town afterward?

It blows.

-ghug, aka Flum

Even worse is being scum again though cause they won't give you any leeway.

[Fluminator]

flum, you've had successful scum games in the past right? like not just wins, but standout performances where you really shined

what was it like to play town afterward?

I feel like my town and scum games are actually quite notably different so in the cases I played a scum game and then had a town game, I was usually pretty widely townread by players familiar with both. (But mafiascum is a much bigger community so the overlap between players you're familiar with was a lot less, allowing me to play my wolf style more and get away with it more)

This was also 8ish years ago though.

[Fluminator]

unfortunately the number of people who would do that and are not me is small

FTR I would do that

[Fluminator]

my gut reaction is to just ignore it but

i want it to be real so bad

the interesting(?) part is that i think pyx has a good shot at being mafia but basically can't be scum with bona, who is also not a bad shot atm

This is the first PE post I've seen where I think the PE being town narrative might make more sense.

[brainbomb]

Anyone who still had flum as scum should adjust their view of game now

[President Eden]

unfortunately the number of people who would do that and are not me is small

FTR I would do that

i forgot that whole thing

@brain - you were contemplating bona/pyx right? thoughts on bona apparently believing pyx died when rdr did?

[ghug]

unfortunately the number of people who would do that and are not me is small

FTR I would do that

i forgot that whole thing

@brain - you were contemplating bona/pyx right? thoughts on bona apparently believing pyx died when rdr did?

Yeah Bona/pyxxy is out.

[Fluminator]

Wait Eden, do you take notes about the game separate from the thread you could share? You could get an easy townread from me that way.

[President Eden]

that kinda makes me want to get pyx

I recognize that doesn’t logically follow so I’m gonna think it over more

[President Eden]

Wait Eden, do you take notes about the game separate from the thread you could share? You could get an easy townread from me that way.

unfortunate then lol

no I don’t

[President Eden]

actually is Bona/pyx truly off the table here

what stops Bona from faking a dumbtell about his partner

[brainbomb]

that kinda makes me want to get pyx

I recognize that doesn’t logically follow so I’m gonna think it over more

Im actually surprised youre so self aware that you fear making a scumread on pyx. You dont have to pad such a read, you have votes on you but being cautious is kind of pointless at this point anyway

[ghug]

actually is Bona/pyx truly off the table here

what stops Bona from faking a dumbtell about his partner

I think even bona has limits.